News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why taxing robots is not a good idea by delinka on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:03AM (#13724227)
That seems a bit pedantic. If you're taxing "hammers," you're taxing the owner of the hammer, either at the point of sale, or perhaps as a tax on capital equipment. So, if you're taxing "robots," you have to define "robot" and then collect tax at the time of sale, or on capital equipment.

This whole idea (limiting a new tax to robots or the work they do) seems fraught with disaster. I think it'd make more sense to increase tax on both liquid capital and capital equipment to make the whole scheme

Re:Why taxing robots is not a good idea by mason240 on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:24AM (#13724421)
Do we really need to reinvent the wheel when it comes to taxes? Tax personal and corporate incomes, just like we do now.

If someone is able run an automated business with no employees, just tax the profits and income. Nothing changes.

Re:Why taxing robots is not a good idea by briandear on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:31AM (#13724515)
Why tax any of that? What's wrong with a consumption tax? You buy something, you pay a tax. Everything gets taxed equally and the government no longer gets to pick winners and losers based on the relative political power of the entity being taxed.

The way it works now is that taxes are used to manipulate behavior rather than simply collecting money to provide services for citizens. Income taxes provide too much power to governments.

Re:Why taxing robots is not a good idea by mcguire on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:55AM (#13724731)
Not everyone gets taxed equally with a consumption tax. "You can only eat so much filet mignon," to quote a professor I once had.

Non-progressive taxes (which is mostly what we have in the US now) provide too much power to the wealthy. Further, in non-totalitarian societies, the government isn't a separate entity---it is controlled by whoever has the most power in the society.

Re:Why taxing robots is not a good idea by mason240 on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:39AM (#13725174)
I agree. I've long been a in favor a consumption tax such as FairTax, which gives everyone a "prebate" for taxes on the first $50,000 or so, to ensure it is still a progressive tax.

However, I don't think that would work in a theoretical "post labor" world where only 25% or less of the population is actually employed.

Re:Why taxing robots is not a good idea by delinka on Friday February 24, 2017 @02:43PM (#13727028)
Had there been employees, taxes would also have been collected from them. Replacing employees with robots reduces tax revenue. Sure, additional profits going to the owners make for more tax paid by those owners, but not enough to offset the reduction in tax revenue caused by eliminating employees.
Re:Why taxing robots is not a good idea by talmand on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:32AM (#13724517)
Except for the reduced tax revenue for the government, nothing changes at all.
Re:Why taxing robots is not a good idea by joncrocks on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:08AM (#13724274)
I think the point is that 'robot' isn't really a well-defined term. When does a machine become a robot?
Re:Why taxing robots is not a good idea by conanbatt on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:02AM (#13724808)
I would be hilarious if not dystopian to see the government changing the definition of what a robot is constantly in pursuit of tax revenue.

In any case, i suspect the whole push a government could do to a robot tax is simply to increase tax revenue, all else be damned.