News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by peteretep on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:35AM (#13723472)

    > Socioeconomic factors are
    > not the major ones
... is your opinion, contradicted by the available evidence. You finish with a suggestion to call things "by its real names", so I will: pushing a false narrative of cultural superiority is racism. Begone.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by DoofusOfDeath on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:41AM (#13723526)
Wouldn't that be called "culturism"?
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by edblarney on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:50AM (#13723587)
"... is your opinion, contradicted by the available evidence"

This is false.

In fact - the evidence points much more strongly towards 'behaviour' than it does 'economic status'.

(By the way, I'm not making the case entirely that 'ethnicity is it' - rather, saying that there's tons of evidence to support it. I believe that it's rather more complicated).

'Economic status' is loosely correlated with crime in the USA for example. More crime is committed in poorer areas. Ok - so are they poor and therefore commit crime - or they have bad behaviours and are therefore poor?

The problem is - 'ethnicity' is considerably more correlated with crime, particularly violent crime.

For example, poor African Americans commit considerably more violent crime than their poor White or Asian peers.

Now - you could argue it's due to 'racism' etc. - and that's a good point, but it only goes so far.

Also - I'd argue that this is not about 'racism' - it's about 'ethnicity'. What is 'ethnicity' but a group of values, behaviours, norms, viewpoints, beliefs, patterns etc? Two groups with different ethnic backgrounds are likely to have very different outcomes overall in life. That's just reality - and it doesn't have to have anything to do with race.

I'm not actually making an argument one way or another - I think there's a lot to be said for how hard it is go grow up poor, or how hard it is to grow up facing racism and injustice - but at the same time - behaviours, mannerism, values etc. will define most of an individuals future - and those are passed down to children from their parents, and close community members, i.e. ethnicity. So it would be basically crazy to ignore this issue as well.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by peteretep on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:54AM (#13723621)
Can we exit crazy world for a moment and say that "there's tons of evidence" doesn't cut it unless you provide that evidence?

The level of rampant irrationality here is disheartening.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by w0utert on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:21AM (#13723828)
Well I'm not from Sweden so I cannot comment on that, but it's a well-known and documented fact that e.g. here in the Netherlands, ethnicities other than 'Dutch' are over-represented in about every negative statistic that is being tracked, amongst which are crime statistics. I could point you to cbs statline, which is the goverment statistics body, but it's in Dutch so I don't know if it's of any use to you, see [1] and particularly [2] for an overview table of crime statistics grouped by native, non-native, non-native+non-western, etc.

Whether these groups are over-represented because of socio-economic status, cultural factors, genetics or whatever seems largely irrelevant to me if you ask me, especially if you are reasoning about immigration in the context of public safety. None of these factors are controllable, and typically immigrants from distressed countries will both fall in the 'different culture' and 'low economic status' category at the same time. For public safety, the root cause why they are over-represented in 'bad lists' seems irrelevant to me.

Let's be clear that I don't mean to pass judgement on immigration policy, just pointing out that if you are creative with statistics you can prove or disprove almost anything to be related to everything, depending on your agenda. Correcting a statistic 'immigrants are over-represented in crime statistics' by saying 'but not compared to swedes with low economic status' seems like a pretty desperate attempt to paper over the fact that accepting large number of immigrants will not improve public safety, so to say.

[1] http://statline.cbs.nl/Statweb/

[2] http://statline.cbs.nl/StatWeb/publication/?DM=SLNL&PA=81947...

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by readittwice on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:49AM (#13724682)
Same for Austria. Immigrants are both over-represented both in prisons and criminal statistics.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by peteretep on Saturday February 25, 2017 @04:02AM (#13730733)

    > Whether these groups are
    > over-represented because of 
    > socio-economic status, 
    > cultural factors, genetics 
    > or whatever seems largely 
    > irrelevant to me
Then I'm entirely unsure why you're contributing to a thread of conversation about evidence on that specific point, and providing evidence for something else entirely.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by sharemywin on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:09AM (#13724286)
So, what's the point. Should I judge you based on your specific actions or based on what all idiots(myself included) on the internet post?
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by aaron-lebo on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:39AM (#13723511)
Cultures advance. Some are more refined and progressive than others. The practice of throwing homosexuals to their deaths is obviously not enlightened. Of course other cultures have their faults, too, but to argue that comparing cultures is racism is willfully ignorant.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by peteretep on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:52AM (#13723606)
The parent comment stated that differences were due to culture and not baseline economic status. This is inspite of evidence.

What alternative explanation - other than racism or ignorance - is there for that mistruth?

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by aaron-lebo on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:55AM (#13723633)
Culture != race.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by MK999 on Friday February 24, 2017 @12:56PM (#13725892)
Shouting "racism!" is a good way to shut down the discussion

Shouting "culture!" doesn't really work as well.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by otalp on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:35AM (#13723476)
What are your sources that try to prove that socioeconomic factors are not 'the major ones', to the extent that that you can confidently state that it is 'plainly' wrong to attribute differences to poverty and lack of education?
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by factsaresacred on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:08AM (#13723731)
> What are your sources that try to prove that socioeconomic factors are not 'the major ones'?

How about the Swedish government themselves?

- A 1996 BRA (Swedish Criminal statistics) study found that "there any indication that immigrants in Sweden are discriminated in the courts. Immigrant overrepresentation in registered crime is almost certainly real...nor is it caused by any generally lower social economic status (calculated as per SEI code) in Sweden."

- Swedish National Council for Crime Prevention determined that between 1985 and 1989 individuals born in Iraq, North Africa (Algeria, Libya, Morocco and Tunisia),Africa (excluding Uganda and the North African countries), other Middle East (Jordan, Palestine, Syria), Iran and Eastern Europe (Romania, Bulgaria) were convicted of rape at rates 20, 23, 17, 9, 10 and 18 greater than individuals born in Sweden respectively."

http://www.pdf-archive.com/2011/05/08/br-1996-2-invandrares-...

Besides, socioeconomic factors to justify rape....really?

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by otalp on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:37AM (#13723968)
Is there a link to an actual government site instead of pictures of a book in Swedish that was published decades ago?

> Besides, socioeconomic factors to justify rape....really?

I'm sorry, but it is really difficult to have a serious conversation with someone unable to differentiate between the process of analyzing reasons for crimes and 'justifying' crimes. That is elementary stuff.

And your point doesn't even make sense. Are you saying rich, well educated muslims or african immigrants are still more likely to rape someone than a white person? Is your argument genetic? If that is not what you are implying - and I'll pay you the complement of assuming it's not, then you will have to at least consider socioeconomic factors.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by factsaresacred on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:50AM (#13724106)
> is there a link to an actual government site instead of pictures of a book in Swedish that was published decades ago?

That book was published by the goverment of Sweden. Does the host matter?

In 2005 BRA (Swedish Criminal statistics) published an update saying: "Immigrants’ risk of being registered for crime has not changed in any pronounced way since the previous study conducted by the National Council, which related to the situation at the end of the 1980s" Link: https://www.bra.se/download/18.cba82f7130f475a2f1800010674/1...

> it is really difficult to have a serious conversation with someone unable to differentiate between the process of analyzing reasons for crimes and 'justifying' crimes.

Justification: "give grounds for, give reasons for, give a justification for". Pointing at socioeconomic factors is justifying the crimes by allusion to the circumstances of the crime.

Maybe you're confused it with 'condoning' which means something else.

So my point is, do we think we can analyze and find reason for aggravated rape within socioeconomic circumstances?

> Are you saying rich, well educated muslims or african immigrants are still more likely to rape someone than a white person?

Am I? I don't think that I am.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by otalp on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:16AM (#13724345)
1)'Justify' meaning: https://www.google.co.uk/#q=justify+meaning

"show or prove to be right or reasonable"

2) > That book was published by the goverment of Sweden.

Probably, but pictures on "pdf-archive.com" are not a valid source since anyone can doctor them. It should be trivial and take a matter of minutes to find a link to the official government manual from a government site, if you're familiar with the study.

>So my point is, do we think we can analyze and find reason for aggravated rape within socioeconomic circumstances?

Possibly. We do not have any information that makes socioeconomic factors irrelevant, and comparable studies strongly tilt the balance in the favour of such an explanation.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by glormph on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:33AM (#13723934)
I am not arguing against your point, but are there reports which are not 20+ years old?

Also, my understanding of the words may be wrong but I didn't see anyone _justifying_ rape in this thread.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by factsaresacred on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:40AM (#13724000)
> are there reports which are not 20+ years old?

I asked the same question. In 2005 Bra released a report saying "Immigrants’ risk of being registered for crime has not changed in any pronounced way since the previous study conducted by the National Council, which related to the situation at the end of the 1980s".

https://www.bra.se/download/18.cba82f7130f475a2f1800010674/1...

Your claim was "What are your sources that try to prove that socioeconomic factors are not 'the major ones'?" so my question is 'what of rape'? This is the main crime making headlines. How does one explain it with socioeconomic factors? And even if you could, would that be a satisfactory explanation?

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by glormph on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:01AM (#13724208)
I see you have already dealt with my question about the word justify with another commenter.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by lngnmn on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:44AM (#13723545)
It is obvious - poor but educated people are different from poor and uneducated. To lift people out of misery and poverty is what education is for in the first place.

In countries like India that could be clearly seen. Poverty alone does not account for the behavioral patterns. Education is the key. People knew this since antiquity, independently of a particular civilization - Indians knew this, Chinese knew this, you name it.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by Voloskaya on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:03AM (#13723698)
In many country, including France where issues similar to sweden exists, the quality of the education you receive is directly correlated with the median wealth of your neighborhood. Poor suburbs have way worse education than rich ones.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by lngnmn on Friday February 24, 2017 @02:36PM (#13726944)
Education is not only about academic knowledge per se. It is also a set of habits of self-control, acquired skills, social behavior patterns and transformed perceptions. This is what we call conditioning or exposure to certain culture.

Street kids, usually members of a gang, who never have experienced transforming influence of the culture of a good school and a good teacher are definitely not the same as those who vent through one.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by jkscm on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:37AM (#13723493)
[citation needed]

Socioeconomic factors are significant factors: http://www.apa.org/pi/ses/resources/publications/violence.as...

As a side note: You seem to agree with your parent poster since you mention “well-educated people” which are most likely richer.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by lngnmn on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:49AM (#13723578)
Education is asymmetric. Educated could clearly see the world in the same naive way as uneducated, but the contrary is not true. This constitutes the fundamental difference and incompatibility which is supposed to be eliminated by providing the basic right for receiving an education.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by k_swden on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:42AM (#13725224)
First you state socioeconomic factors are not major factor, but then you go on saying "well-educated people of any origin would behave more or less similarly", but socioeconomic factors are: income, EDUCATION and occupation, ergo you're contradicting yourself or you have no clue what socioeconomic factors are.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by lngnmn on Saturday February 25, 2017 @07:35AM (#13731320)
Yes, you are right, I have messed it up a little. What I have tried to say is that there are major and minor factors, and the major ones, with highest weights, so to speak, are cultural instead of economical, and I will keep my stand.

A culture, which is a set of shared values, views and behavioral patterns, defines a person more than just his income. Occupation is important, (think of the castes of India) but the modern world a truck driver could be a physicist or a philosopher could make and sell sandwiches.