News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by Tycho on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:11PM (#13708749)
Apologies if this has been discussed extensively. But it occurs to me that the US (and maybe other Western countries) has a retirement crisis - ie. people have not saved nearly enough for their retirement, and state-related pensions/entitlements are a massive strain on the budgets.

So with that in mind, how the heck can these countries even consider rolling out a new "basic income" program? Doesn't this seem a bit incongruous?

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:41PM (#13708962)
> So with that in mind, how the heck can these countries even consider rolling out a new "basic income" program?

Unconditional income programs (whether they meet basic needs or not) are conceived of as replacing some or all existing means-tested benefit programs, and reducing or eliminating the adverse employment effects of minimum wage laws (without eliminating the income-floor effects of those same laws).

They can be budget neutral by either being cost neutral (redirecting funds from the displaced programs) or by being tied to specific new funding sources. (Given that one of the long-term goals is to address long-term concentration of economic gains in capital rather than labor, capital-specific income or ad valorem taxation is the natural place to look for dedicated new revenue streams.)

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by Tycho on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:54PM (#13709052)
How can they be cost neutral? That would only happen if by luck the same number of people applied to basic income as previously applied for means-tested benefits. I find this scenario unlikely! Also, even if you have some new funding source, the system would have potentially huge liabilities if lots of people decide to sign up for it. Given that we can barely manage pensions, which I suspect have more stable characteristics than the hypothetical distribution of basic income requests, I'm skeptical that we could successfully manage a basic income program.
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:02PM (#13709121)
> How can they be cost neutral?

That's literally exactly what the GP post explains. If the funds distributed as UBI are the funds redirected from replaced programs, the costs are, by definition, the same.

> That would only happen if by luck the same number of people applied to basic income as previously applied for means-tested benefits.

No, it wouldn't. You are assuming equal per beneficiary per time period total benefit + administrative costs.

> Also, even if you have some new funding source, the system would have potentially huge liabilities if lots of people decide to sign up for it.

No, its not dependent on people who "decide to sign up for" since, by definition, an unconditional income is given unconditionally to every member of the target population; that's part of the basic calculation of the benefit that can be given at any funding level.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by Tycho on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @05:23PM (#13709798)
Isn't becoming part of the target population essentially the same thing as signing up?

If the cost remained exactly the same, then either you spread similar benefits across a similar group size, or you spread greatly reduced benefits over a much larger group of people, to the point where it's no longer a living "wage".

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @05:32PM (#13709868)
> Isn't becoming part of the target population essentially the same thing as signing up?

Its a lot more predictable than "requests", especially if the target population is something like adult citizens and legal permanent residents.

> If the cost remained exactly the same, then either you spread similar benefits across a similar group size, or you spread greatly reduced benefits over a much larger group of people, to the point where it's no longer a living "wage".

Yes, the cost neutral version would be reduced maximum benefit in the short term (though, again, you make the mistake of assuming that the full cost is just benefits, and ignore changes in administrative overhead), while the budget-neutral-by-increased-revenue versions might retain similar maximum benefits.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by Tycho on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @06:12PM (#13710164)
> Its a lot more predictable than "requests", especially if the target population is something like adult citizens and legal permanent residents.

In that case it would basically just be removing all welfare and giving everyone a tax-cut.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by morgante on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:31PM (#13709338)
> How can they be cost neutral? That would only happen if by luck the same number of people applied to basic income as previously applied for means-tested benefits.

In addition to the other points being made (about new funding sources), you're assuming the payout for basic income would exactly match previous means-tested benefits. Realistically spending, any basic income program will likely provide less than the upper end of many existing entitlement programs.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by Tarrosion on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:16PM (#13708790)
Part of the idea is that with a basic income, there's no longer a need for many "social safety net" programs: disability, social security, food stamps, medicaid, etc. The money saved eliminating all these programs (and their nontrivial overhead) can be used to give everyone a modest basic income.

I'm not sure if this is true or not. You can find serious people with reasonable seeming numbers on both sides of that argument.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by marcell on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:43PM (#13708969)
> The money saved eliminating all these programs (and their nontrivial overhead) can be used to give everyone a modest basic income.

This isn't really the case. Basic income is not about cost savings.

The programs you mention are wealth transfers, so the overhead is in fact trivial. They take money from person A, and give it to person B. There are checks in place to make sure person B qualifies, which accounts for the overhead. For retirement transfer (social security), you check each persons age--not too hard in America.

All those programs would have to be colossally, amazingly inefficient for basic income to be more efficient at redistributing wealth. Out of it's over $1 trillion budget, estimates of administrative overhead are around 1%. Even for more complex programs like foodstamps, overhead is likely low and under 10% [1].

Basic income is about wealth re-distribution, not efficiency. It applies a huge tax increase to the top 10-20% of society, and gives that money to the bottom 80-90%. It's that simple.

So the question everyone should ask is: should we have a policy of taking money from the top 10%, and giving it to the bottom 90%?

[1] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/susan-blumenthal/food-stamp-my... (not the most reliable source, but best I could find quickly)

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by massysett on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:53PM (#13709036)
Even for Social Security old age benefits, the overhead is a lot more than just checking someone's age. Benefits depend upon how much income someone had during his working years. So those records have to be checked. You also have to make sure people don't get fraudulent benefits.

And that's just for old age benefits. For Social Security disability, you have to make sure someone is disabled. For unemployment, you have to make sure they worked in the first place, that they lost their job in a manner that garners them benefits, and their benefit size depends on what their pay was.

Making all this work takes bureaucrats, judges to adjudicate claims, and people to investigate fraud. I have no idea whether UBI would be dramatically more efficient but even something like Social Security is far more complex than just checking someone's age.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by snarf21 on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:58PM (#13709089)
I agree with you, taxes on the top are required no matter what. BI has other problems but I thought one of the other benefits of it was that it reduces fraud. You can't game the system as much.

Needs based systems are easily defeated and then some of give you money based on your "need". This means you get more than you should (and presumably more than BI would provide). I actually think the best BI approach is like an EITC on steroids. You get all your money back if you are at the super low end and you can also make that a multiplier to encourage filling of lower wage jobs.

What I mean by that is that if someone makes $15K a year, they may get 20K + $10K (2/3 earnings) back as a refund (could be quarterly, etc.) Someone who makes $0K a year would just get the $10K. Not well thought out yet but illustrating approach.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by petra on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:26PM (#13709303)
So so for the sake of political simplicity ,why not just say to the bottom 80% -"let's greatly raise taxes for the rich, and than let's discuss about how to use it to help society "? Sounds like a great political promise.

Or maybe there's a problem ?

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:52PM (#13709529)
The problem is that if you say that, "the rich", who control more economic power than the bottom 80%, will expend considerable resources to discredit your ideas and you personally, and you won't get elected.

We have a democratic republic in theory, but very much a plutocratic one in practice.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by morgante on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:33PM (#13709358)
Yet the candidate who basically ran on that platform didn't even make it past the primary while someone doing the opposite is now president.

Politics isn't rational.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by eanzenberg on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:22PM (#13708822)
Right.. Basic income essentially wants to take mone out of the pot currently reserved for the needy and disabled, and distribute it to able-bodied people who choose not to enter the work force.
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by mrec on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:48PM (#13709005)
It would arguably also encourage people to enter the work force, by removing the welfare traps that can, all too often, make people who switch from benefits to paid work worse off.

There's also a distinction to be made between "not working" and "not in paid employment". Carers, OSS devs etc can add value to society without ever showing up in employment stats.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by petra on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:32PM (#13709352)
You could just take that money and give it to a million other causes more socially valuable than distributing BI to everyone.

Heck just think what some of this could do to research.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by mrec on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @06:57PM (#13710412)
> You could just take that money and give it to a million other causes more socially valuable than distributing BI to everyone.

You're thinking of it as extra money. Try thinking of it instead as money that's already being paid to everyone, just made unconditional. People are not (generally) starving in the streets, so the money is clearly being spent to keep them alive. Some of that is via benefits, which BI would replace. Some of it is via pay-for-work, and given a BI employers could pay less with the BI making up the difference. You can make a separate argument about whether a BI removes incentives to work, but AIUI evidence from pilot programs so far suggests that it doesn't.

> Heck just think what some of this could do to research.

How many of the famous names in science were able to make their discoveries because they belonged to a gentry class who didn't have to work for a living? How many people have to leave academic research because they can't get funding any more? What tends to happen to OSS contribution rates once people move from study to full-time work?

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by RyanZAG on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:26PM (#13708854)
I believe the basic idea is to use that able-bodied distribution as an excuse to heavily raise taxes, with the goal being that the needy and disabled would not receive less. The logic being that if everyone has a safety net, we don't need to reward people as much since they now have lower risk.

Personally I don't believe that would actually happen, but the idea does account for that angle.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by snuxoll on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:28PM (#13708870)
There's nothing inherently wrong with not entering the workforce in the post-scarcity society we are rapidly approaching. People can instead choose to spend time raising their children, practicing a hobby, or trying to start their own business without fear of not being able to support themselves.

Most humans naturally don't want to sidle idle all their lives, some will, but the vast majority will find some productive use of their time - a basic income means they don't have to work 40 hours a week just to survive so they can do what they really want to do in their spare hours.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by yummyfajitas on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:45PM (#13708982)
...a basic income means they don't have to work 40 hours a week just to survive so they can do what they really want to do in their spare hours.

The data suggests that men, at least, really want to watch TV and take drugs. They don't spend much time raising children or on civic engagement.

Here is a good survey article:

https://www.commentarymagazine.com/articles/our-miserable-21...

If you want to say "that isn't a true Scotsman/basic income", please explain how writing "basic income" at the top of the check would change things.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:53PM (#13709040)
I'm assuming you intend to reference the discussion of disability benefits late in that article; the key difference between that and basic income is that disability benefits are received by people who are judged to be occupationally disabled, which fall into two groups:

(1) People who have worked and are actually physically unable to do so any longer (and, generally, for the same reason, inhibited in other important life functions), and

(2) People who wish not to work so much that they have engaged in elaborate frauds to be adjudicated unable to work.

And, in both cases, actually receiving money from work reduces their eligibility for payments and may jeopardize their eligibility to receive benefits at all.

I think its quite reasonable to believe that neither of those (nor the two combined) would be representative in their use of money and their actions when receiving a certain amount of money, on top of the fact that receiving money which is partially conditioned on non-work induces different behaviors (even in the same set of people) than receiving unconditional funds.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by yummyfajitas on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:08PM (#13709166)
The article discuss the fact that most of those who are consuming disability benefits are not, in fact, physically unable to work.

This is readily apparent from the fact that disability claims are strongly correlated with the economy; recessions do not cause people to become paraplegics. And this rise is in spite of workplaces and daily life becoming safer.

NPR also has an expose on rampant disability fraud, although they of course use more polite language: http://apps.npr.org/unfit-for-work/

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:12PM (#13709205)
> The article discuss the fact that most of those who are consuming disability benefits are not, in fact, physically unable to work.

That's a non-sequitur, as the distribution between group (1) and group (2) in the GP post is immaterial to the argument made there.

If you want to address the points actually made in the post you are responding to instead of throwing out irrelevancies, feel free to do so.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by bryanlarsen on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:06PM (#13709148)
But is it the possibility of starving that motivates men to work today? I don't think so. It's the drive for a mate that motivates men to get off the couch, and that won't change.
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by noonespecial on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:16PM (#13709233)
Perhaps if they weren't facing such grim futures, they'd be a bit less prone to escapism?
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by gremlinsinc on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:49PM (#13709015)
As a note to the post-scarcity society looming, the 'humans must work 40 hours or they're not worth anything' is a recent development... Working times in middle ages was much more leisurely: http://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/users/rauch/worktime/hours_w... -- Including average working days to be 150-175 depending on the century.. W/ robotics, etc...why can't we move back to that..

I think a parent should always be home with child, whether mom or dad. -- I see a rise in home schooling and learning through other ways than schools. A marriage of pre-industrialism and post-scarcity w/ the ability to spend free time coding and working on entrepreneurism, or scientific discovery sounds a lot better than working 9-6 5 days a week to make the next Bill Gates or Mark Z. rich.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by DoofusOfDeath on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:47PM (#13708999)
Apologies if I'm coming from too far behind in the conversation, but I have a question about your post-scarcity assumption.

It seems to me that in most societies, human populations continue to grow until they hit some hard resource barrier. And it's not a simple, gentle equilibrium that's reached: we usually end up with poverty and/or war as a result.

How would you reconcile my take on human nature with your expectation of post-scarcity?

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by snuxoll on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:30PM (#13709330)
The human population seems to be stabilizing actually, with dramatically decreased infant mortality most parents these days focus on one or two kids instead of three or more - this is even more prevalent in more educated populations.

Finland, for example had more deaths than births last year. I wouldn't be surprised if the population of the human race shrinks over the next century.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by sfeng on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:41PM (#13708959)
The conflict here is that humans are animals, and animals evolved to use the minimum amount of energy possible to satisfy their needs. Yes you can learn the reward of willfully working hard, but I'm not sure whether everyone, or even most people, will make that transition.
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by noonespecial on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:21PM (#13709273)
In a post scarcity world why would most people need to? The whole point is that technology is about to make it possible to satisfy everyone's needs with minimum human energy and instead of reveling in it, we seem to be planning to de facto kill all the extra people we used to need with poverty.

If 3/4 of everyone wants to watch TV and take fun drugs and our society has the wealth to allow that to happen, hooray!

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by snuxoll on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:42PM (#13709435)
Human beings also waste energy on frivolous things, recreation is not generally a trait shared by most animals - yet humans spend a fair amount of time just doing nothing productive or required for our survival.

The same is true for work, while many people are forced to take whatever job they can to survive - there's no reason they wouldn't choose to punch a clock because they enjoy it.

I wouldn't mind working less, but I love what I do, I get a sense of pride and accomplishment out of it - if it weren't required for my survival I wouldn't suddenly stop.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by massysett on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:55PM (#13709067)
So the people who get out and work every day are supposed to support the people who want to "practice a hobby." People who get out and work find this repugnant and that's why UBI is a non-starter.
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by billmalarky on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:19PM (#13709253)
>So the people who get out and work every day are supposed to support the people who want to "practice a hobby."

Only if they choose to. Everyone will receive the basic income, those who wish (and are able to) to supplement this income by working will be free to do so.

>People who get out and work find this repugnant

Working people will cease to exist as the majority in the not-so-distant future. There needs to be a solution for humans no longer being able to add value in the workplace.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by snuxoll on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:39PM (#13709411)
One should also add that a hobby can be productive. A UBI could result in a revival of the arts and crafts: painters, sculptors, woodworkers, etc - all of which could be economically and culturally productive.

I wouldn't choose to stop coding, personally - it is one of my passions, but in a society with a UBI I could see cutting hours and spending more time with my daughter, fishing, etc.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by massysett on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @05:54PM (#13710040)
Awesome. Nice of other people to get out and work so that you can go fishing.
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by snuxoll on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @06:42PM (#13710340)
No need for the hostile tone. The push for a UBI is directly tied with increasing automation in virtually all sectors, there's going to be less work to go around as we go forward - is it really fair to judge someone for being okay with taking more time for themselves when there's less for them to do?

I would go crazy if I didn't have code to write, it's not like I'll ever stop working if I wasn't forced to - but I wouldn't mind to cut back my week and spend time on my own endeavors if it wouldn't be a crushing blow financially.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by massysett on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @05:52PM (#13710026)
So my point stands. The working people are supporting the hobbyists. Even if you are not working, someone is producing your food and your clothes and shelter. That stuff does not become "free" merely because "robots made work redundant" or "everyone gets free UBI" or some other nonsense. In any society, some people carry the water while others drink it. The idea of UBI is that someone should be able to practice a hobby while others labor to feed him and clothe him. This is a fringe notion that those who work find repugnant.

Currently rich societies support many people who drink the water while carrying none. But the social contract is that they get state support because they are elderly or infirm or disabled or simply down on their luck. There is no widespread support for the idea that people are entitled to carry no water and, moreover, to live a leisurely life of hobby, merely because they were lucky enough to be born in a rich country.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by billmalarky on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @06:03PM (#13710098)
You keep referencing human labor, so you aren't getting it. There won't be a meaningful number of people working in the future because humans will add less value to the market than automation. I won't try to predict when the human unemployment "tipping point" occurs, but it will occur.

What is your proposed solution for when the market economy collapses due to demand side economics ceasing to exist?

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by massysett on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @06:11PM (#13710159)
History is full of people making ridiculous claims like this. Years ago no one would have imagined that anyone would work in a society like ours, where extraordinary efficient agriculture means everyone can eat. But people still work, because things like better healthcare and iPhones have a cost.

Human wants will expand to fill humankind's greater productive output, just as it has in the past. So I do "get it." I just think you're wrong.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @05:56PM (#13710051)
> So the people who get out and work every day are supposed to support the people who want to "practice a hobby."

No, those passively receiving gains from capital are supposed to do that, and the revenue structure supporting any sane UBI proposal should reflect that.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by ploxiln on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:26PM (#13709302)
Or, alternatively, it wants to take money out of the pot currently reserved for people best able to game the existing complex and flawed systems, and distribute it everyone fairly, including those who need it (some small number of whom currently "fall through the cracks").
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by lewisl9029 on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:45PM (#13709461)
I'm a huge fan of the concept of a universal basic income, but I don't see how it can be a replacement for social programs for basic necessities like food stamps.

There will always be people out there who will choose to blow their entire paycheck on frivolous purchases outside of their means and not have any money left over at the end of the month for food. As stupid and irresponsible they are for making that choice, a humane, post-scarcity society shouldn't just let those people just starve to death on the streets as a consequence.

As a much more charitable example, consider the case of someone getting into an accident and ending up having to spend all or most of their basic income on medical expenses. How could someone like this survive if the basic income were to completely replace all existing social programs?

So basic income will have to coexist with these existing programs. Perhaps the existing programs can be reduced in scale due to less people needing to rely on them thanks to the introduction of a basic income, but probably not nearly enough to completely offset the immense costs of the basic income program itself.

This means the overall expenditure for social programs will likely have to increase due to the introduction of a universal basic income, and I personally am perfectly fine with increasing tax rates on the rich to make that happen, but it's not going to be easy.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by wmf on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:29PM (#13708874)
Obviously if the same money is spread among more people, some people will receive less than they used to. If social security isn't enough to live on, replacing it with basic income could be worse. Eliminating bureaucratic overhead helps but it's not clear how much.
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by thedevil on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:34PM (#13708914)
I have the same concern. I've heard arguments, but none that adequately address the issue.

While I'm a fan of the idea of adopting basic income eventually, I don't see how we can fund it now without serious negative consequences.

Unfortunately the studies I've read about here on HN (including this one I'm guessing) seem to only address the positive side without actually comparing costs vs benefits.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by 3pt14159 on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:57PM (#13709080)
Every time I do the math for BI people I never get upvotes, so it never gets attention. Yes, one day in the far future basic income will work, but right now even assuming nobody that is currently working will stop working, it will cost a _ton_ of money. Especially from the top part of the tax bracket.
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by mercutio2 on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:20PM (#13709256)
Great! That's the point. People in my tax bracket should be paying vastly more in taxes.

People who lobby for basic income certainly shouldn't pussyfoot around the notion that it's fundamentally a redistributive tax.

My goal is to eliminate poverty for US citizens who don't insist on living in extremely high cost areas. Secondary goals are to enable the poor to refuse to do bullshit jobs, and undermine the deeply-held notion that wage work is ennobling.

The only way to achieve such redistribution is now, as it has always been, to tax rich people like me.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by 3pt14159 on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @08:40PM (#13710925)
Hey I'm there with you. I'd rather people in the 1% pay 80% taxes instead of 40% taxes, but the reality is that very, very, very few people in the 1% think like we do, and a good number people in the upper middle class and middle class are going to be worse off as well. It's obviously the long term solution, but it's not politically palatable yet.
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by dsr_ on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:14PM (#13708773)
Basic income would solve that problem too, by replacing the state pension programs.

(The US has very few real pension programs any more, since the 401(k) and IRA systems were put into effect and displaced them.)

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by sokoloff on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:21PM (#13708818)
I don't see this happening. Basic income will be a terribly spartan existence (I estimate not more than $650/person/month with pretty generous guessestimating).

Anyone who works for the government (including teaching & military) with retirement benefits is not going to subsist on just UBI once they stop working.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by snuxoll on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:30PM (#13708887)
This all depends on how many jobs are displaced due to automation, if 40% of our workforce ends up unemployed due to robots taking over their jobs it doesn't seem unreasonable to take 30% of the GDP to supply a BI program (which would give roughly 1/2 the median income to each person in the country if my math was right).
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by sokoloff on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:46PM (#13708989)
30% of GDP is almost double[1] the entire federal tax receipts currently. That means you're going to need to raise taxes to between 2x and 2.5x their current level in order to institute a program of that magnitude.

That does meet my bar of "unreasonable".

[1] - https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by Scarblac on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:53PM (#13709045)
He's talking about a scenario where 40% is unemployed due to automation, that's pretty apocalyptic. If that can be dealt with pretty well with only a 2.5x raise in tax levels, that sounds good to me.
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by sokoloff on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:45PM (#13709452)
Taking federal taxes to 2.5x their current levels takes the top marginal rate over 100%, and that's before any state or local taxes are added.

Mathematically, that makes no sense.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @05:09PM (#13709681)
> Taking federal taxes to 2.5x their current levels takes the top marginal rate over 100%,

You are confusing "federal taxes" with "federal income taxes" and assuming the only way to increase the latter is to multiply the existing marginal rates without changing the structure; since a one portion of the drive for UBI is to address concentration of returns in high-end income and capital gains, the natural first thing to do is to uncap payroll/self-employment taxes and tax capital income the same as labor income (both the taxes on labor income styled as "income tax" and those styled as "payroll tax". That -- alone -- more than doubles taxes on long-term capital gains.)

There's also other income that excluded from taxation or taxed favorably that is concentrated at the high-end that could be targetted.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by snuxoll on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:54PM (#13709542)
Increasing tax on company profits is the more likely way of going about this instead of targeting the income tax specifically.

This whole theory hinges on automation taking a significant bite out of the workforce, which will raise profits in direct proportion to lower costs. If companies aren't paying their employees anymore, a portion of their proceeds should go to paying back society as a whole - after all, if there's nobody to buy their product then they are dead as a company.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by Scarblac on Thursday February 23, 2017 @04:16AM (#13712624)
If fewer and fewer people work, it makes sense to tax other things than income from work. Like capital gains.
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by matchagaucho on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:48PM (#13709002)
This is not much different than the transition from agricultural to industrial age.

If 40% end up unemployed as a result of automation, then there should be a significant increase in new jobs in the automation industry.

The solution is retraining programs. Paying displaced workers UBI while they're retraining is a compassionate temporary solution, but not long-term.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by gremlinsinc on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:54PM (#13709048)
Except there won't be jobs in this future. None. There will come a day when medical doctors, lawyers, and even computer programming can be done by AI, and automation. You can't retrain a workforce for a job that doesn't exist. Robot maintenance maybe? Not when robots repair robots/themselves.. Sounds sci-fi now, but it's looming.
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by sokoloff on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:34PM (#13708917)
Do away with minimum wage laws (no longer needed and no longer desirable with a UBI program in place, IMO), and 40% of the workforce won't end up unemployed/unemployable.
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by snuxoll on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:34PM (#13709371)
I'm fine with eliminating the minimum wage in a society with a UBI, wokers will be able to compete purely on value and wages will reflect as much - but the UBI needs to actually be a livable amount and not below current poverty / minimum wage levels.
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:44PM (#13708975)
> Basic income would solve that problem too, by replacing the state pension programs.

This doesn't actually fit very well with the conceptual basis of UBI as a replacement for means-tested benefit programs, as defined-benefit pensions are not means-tested benefits.

Though its true that a number (though not all) UBI proponents have either explicitly called for replacing existing Social Security-style retirement programs, or implicitly suggested that by including the existing cost of those programs as funds available for UBI.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by koolba on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:09PM (#13709180)
Nonsense. Since when did not having money to pay existing obligations stop lawmakers from legislating new unpaid handouts?
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by MichaelBurge on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:25PM (#13708845)
This is Y Combinator giving people money, not a state actor. It is probably(or should be) unconstitutional for the US to provide basic income, though the state of California might be able to.
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by wmf on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:31PM (#13708891)
The production version of basic income is clearly government-based. YC is doing a private beta to decide whether to lobby governments to provide basic income.
Re:Hiring for Basic Income by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:06PM (#13709153)
Basic income (including its funding stream) can be implemented as an income tax with a fixed refundable credit per qualified individual [0], so its unmistakably exactly as Constitutional as federal income tax.

[0] E.g., if you decide that the UBI goes to all adult citizens and legal permanent residents, then that's the population that gets the credit.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by MichaelBurge on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:57PM (#13709575)
They certainly have the power to collect the tax money required, and the Social Security SCOTUS case(Helvering v. Davis) sets a pretty good starting point for their power to spend.

I'd argue that while they have the power to spend the money on a wide variety of social programs(per the General Welfare clause), they don't have the power to redistribute income since it doesn't have a designated purpose. Spending is an exchange of money for services or goods, while UBI would just be an exchange of money.

Even if redistribution was considered a type of spending, the case mentions specific facts that harmed the elderly(employee age limits being the main one). If these mattered to the original case, then giving UBI to young people who choose not to work should be a weaker case, which makes it reasonable for SCOTUS to disagree at least on those examples.

Social Security is a combination of a forced retirement savings plan and a delayed redistribution of income. I don't know if anyone has argued that the redistribution part alone is unconstitutional, but the forced savings part comes from the payout increasing as you put more money in. A UBI would be entirely a redistribution.

A similar argument might apply to cases where the EITC causes a net benefit to be given to someone, but: A. The government could argue that the EITC is intended to benefit the poor, which seems similar to arguing that Social Security benefits the elderly and B. I don't know if anyone has standing to bring a suit, since those cases are probably rare and the damages would be small.

Re:Hiring for Basic Income by stevens32 on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:47PM (#13708996)
What's the argument for basic income through government being unconstitutional?