News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:pfSense 2.3.3 released by zer0t3ch on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:36AM (#13704317)
Since you seem to have some idea of what you're talking about: how would you compare the BSD-based firewall distros to the Linux-based firewall distros? Personally, I'm partial to VyOS, simply because I have the most experience with it. (Or rather, its fork, EdgeOS)
Re:pfSense 2.3.3 released by trome on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @06:53AM (#13704820)
I've got a few dozen businesses with PFSense with LTE backup, and at this point I'm looking for alternatives. I've considered IPFire, and I've looked at VyOS, Untangle, and OPNSense, but I just recently realized I completely overlooked OpenWRT, which I already happen to have many positive experiences with.

Long term I'm thinking I'll move things over to ARM/MIPS based routers running OpenWRT, and where needed I'll use x86_64 boxes with OpenWRT (eg: Tor Relay at home) as when things break on OpenWRT, its a lot less bad than on BSD.

In particular, I've had issues with BSD taking forever to boot (waited 4hrs at 3am once), deciding it needed an Intel NIC firmware when it had no Intel NICs, thus causing an outage while I drove down there with a WNR2000v3 running OpenWRT, and LTE backup interface handling being poor, whereby the cellular connection will go out (and we'll send a command to the SOAP API on the modem to reconnect), but PFSense needs to cycle the interface for some reason when it already has an internal IP from the modem. Combine that with having to walk customers through any one of these scenarios every few months over the phone, and its a joyous situation.

Re:pfSense 2.3.3 released by kogepathic on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @06:57AM (#13704833)
> whereby the cellular connection will go out (and we'll send a command to the SOAP API on the modem to reconnect), but PFSense needs to cycle the interface for some reason when it already has an internal IP from the modem.

Sounds like you're using a USB based modem that runs its own software stack. We tried that, and it went terribly. Issues similar to the one you mentioned.

Life is much, much better if you buy a mini-PCIe module and use Linux utilities to manage it. We've had zero problems since dumping our USB modems (Huawei junk) and buying proper cards (also Huawei, but surprisingly not junk).

OpenWrt is nice, but the packages are limited. Also their release cycle is glacial, so we frequently end up building from trunk because we need some fixes which aren't in the current stable release (15.05.1 is almost a year old!).

Re:pfSense 2.3.3 released by trome on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @08:22AM (#13705230)
Eh, the ZTE MF96's will go a few months between reboots, and its hard to get anywhere near their price point with mini-PCIe, automating management of them would likely make more sense IMO.

Wrt OpenWRT being aged, not too worried there, I'm still running Debian Jessie over here :P

Re:pfSense 2.3.3 released by kogepathic on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @08:50AM (#13705436)
> Wrt OpenWRT being aged, not too worried there, I'm still running Debian Jessie over here

Yeah but it's a problem. Debian Jessie still gets security updates regularly. OpenWrt doesn't. The only way to upgrade the kernel and core packages is to reflash with a newer image. An annual release cycle is an issue for embedded devices you want to keep secure.

Re:pfSense 2.3.3 released by edwhitesell on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @08:44AM (#13705392)
Have you considered using Mikrotik?

I've heard about them for years, but just started using them in the last 12-18 months. So far, I've been very happy with the performance and features for the cost.

Re:pfSense 2.3.3 released by trome on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:26PM (#13708859)
I own a few Omnitiks, and they are a total PITA to work with, so no, definitely not going with Mikrotik.
Re:pfSense 2.3.3 released by deagle50 on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @09:48AM (#13705864)
If you need openVPN don't run Mikrotik. I love routerOS but openVPN over TCP is no good.
Re:pfSense 2.3.3 released by edwhitesell on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @12:04PM (#13707018)
FWIW I think that depends on the client. I use OpenVPN over TCP with Linux and Windows clients for managing a remote customer location with no issues.

However, Android doesn't work at all. I suspect it's a configuration issue, but the lack of meaningful logs makes it damn near impossible to troubleshoot.

If you happen to run an all Mikrotik routing environment, the SSTP tunneling works well. I have a customer with hundreds of Mikrotiks out in the field, each with an SSTP connection back to a cloud-based Mikrotik installation for remote management/monitoring.

SSTP supposedly works with Windows clients too, though I've never tried it.

Re:pfSense 2.3.3 released by kogepathic on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @06:59AM (#13704841)
> how would you compare the BSD-based firewall distros to the Linux-based firewall distros

In terms of being a firewall, there's no difference. Both will open and block ports as needed.

Where BSD excels over Linux is in the traffic shaping/manipulation capabilities. pf lets you simulate just about any kind of link you want (e.g. want to simulate a satellite connection with accurate latency? or want to simulate a 2G connection with high latency and high packet loss?)

So, as a static firewall, Linux/iptables is fine.

If you want to do any kind of link simulation or complex traffic shaping, BSD is far better.

Re:pfSense 2.3.3 released by 293984j29384 on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @10:00AM (#13705953)
Could you explain a bit more? I often do this on Linux using "tc" (traffic control) to simulate all types of links. What tools does BSD have that are superior?
Re:pfSense 2.3.3 released by kogepathic on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:45PM (#13708980)
It's been 5+ years since I did this testing. It's possible that the Linux ecosystem has caught up to BSD in this time.

I was using pf to simulate links with specific attributes (e.g. latency, packet loss).

Reading the documentation of tc, it seems like it would accomplish what I was doing. However the documentation I found for tc was quite old (mentioning kernels 2.2 and 2.4).

Re:pfSense 2.3.3 released by godzillabrennus on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @05:49AM (#13704577)
Pfsense is focused on offering a GUI with fantastic capabilities. Vyos became a command line only distro at one point.
Re:pfSense 2.3.3 released by zer0t3ch on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:29PM (#13729870)
> Vyos became a command line only distro at one point

Is there something wrong with that?

I'm not trying to be an ass, just curious.

Re:pfSense 2.3.3 released by xmichael99 on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @12:27PM (#13707227)
Still no DPDK support....