News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by cbanek on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @02:38AM (#13703875)
Like how having a clock doesn't necessarily make you better at time management, having a fitbit doesn't make you healthy. But it does allow you to measure things, and if you have the willpower to improve them, you'll improve them. But the device won't do it for you, at best it enables you. At worst, it gives you a false sense of accomplishment that should be checked once you get on the scale.

(Disclaimer: I love my fitbit, and it's helped me lose weight, but I find the step counter to be second to the heart rate monitor)

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by pmarreck on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @09:03AM (#13705525)
I've lost weight with FitBit Blaze in conjunction with a decent calorie tracker app which makes it easy, like http://www.loseit.com/ .

While the former is informative (extra important as I have sleep issues which of course make me hungrier, and the fitbit does a decent sleep-tracking job...), I'm sure the latter is having a bigger impact overall.

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by melling on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @05:39AM (#13704533)
Yep, like anything else, it still requires effort. I've lost weight using my Apple Watch.

https://h4labs.wordpress.com/2015/08/27/apple-watch-8-weeks-...

I'm currently using it to run 5k, a few days a week. Six months ago, I was using it to train for my first 10k.

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by KON_Air on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @06:40AM (#13704778)
It is almost as if tools themselves don't do the work on their own.
Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @07:23AM (#13704942)
I started to make a point, then went to go read the article, and found that the article is not making this point at all. It's adding evidence to the position that exercise doesn't cause people to lose weight. They did the work, they didn't lose the weight.

A case of a bad headline, it seems.

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by melling on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @09:43AM (#13705812)
I lost weight. I included my blog where I illustrated that. The problem with exercise is that you may burn 300-500 calories then eat that much extra food because you are now hungrier. Diet is still more important.

You also need to consider that when you lose 5 lbs of fat, for example, and gain 5 lbs of muscle, you weigh the same but you're definitely more fit.

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by jmelloy on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:31PM (#13709335)
You can't outrun your mouth.

It's much easier to control for your diet than exercise it away, because unless you're working out for 8-10 hours a day, you won't burn more than a few hundred calories. That's one shake at McDonald's or Starbucks dessert.

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by moftz on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @10:33AM (#13706216)
I go to the gym in the mornings before work but I don't wear my fitbit or my android wear watch when I go. It's a crossfit style gym so I'm not running miles. Neither of my devices have heart rate monitors so they really can't measure much in terms of my activity levels other than the steps I take. I stopped wearing my fitbit because of how little I used it. I have an older model that only shows who is calling in addition to the typical fitness metrics (steps, floors, miles, etc) so my android watch is much more useful. I'm not the kind of person to always be shooting for a high score so how many steps I take during the day is irrelevant to my life.
Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by cbanek on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @05:25PM (#13709811)
I also find the step count to be mostly useless, but the heart rate tracker has been gold. I used to have a Polar HR monitor (that would strap across your chest) and this is just so much better. And being able to track my heart rate has made it so that I will push myself a bit harder because I know where my heart rate is at.
Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by mattmanser on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @07:55AM (#13705084)
It’s hard for many to accept, so I’m going to state the results again: Those people who used the wearable tech for 18 months lost significantly less weight than those who didn’t.

In the IDEA trial, those who employed the technology were no more physically active than those who didn’t. They also weren’t more fit.

Let's say that again.

They also weren’t more fit.

You're ignoring empirical evidence. If what you say is true, they'd be more fit.

I've got one too, but if you accept this article as true it looks like it turns out at best it's no more than a pretty bangle, at worst makes you think you're doing more than you are.

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by Cpoll on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @11:26AM (#13706655)
The abstract doesn't give enough information, so I'm connecting the dots. This may be addressed in the text...

It sounds like all the participants were put on a program, and then some were additionally were given a smartwatch (which negatively impacted their results).

But I can't see how you can conclude from there that the smartwatch won't help for individuals that are NOT on a program.

A potential explanation is that the watch has a moderating effect: it gives you an excuse to stop exercising once you hit your daily target, the more calorie tracking you do, the less you err on the side of caution, etc. Under that hypothesis, a smartwatch is still better than no program + no smartwatch.

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by brlewis on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @05:38PM (#13709921)
You are largely correct, except the wearable tech was not a smart watch. It was a 2010-era fitness tracker one straps onto the arm. Definitely nowhere in the "pretty bangle" category. I think wearers would be less active because they wouldn't want to be seen in public with it.

A more detailed answer here: http://www.mobihealthnews.com/content/despite-reports-your-f...

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by LeifCarrotson on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @11:01AM (#13706463)
Empirical evidence on an average does not mean that an individual anecdote is false.

I can echo cbanek's finding - I've been a competitive runner for 15 years, and there's a small inflection point in my results about 5 years ago when I got a GPS watch and heart-rate monitor. I was training and racing to the best of my abilities with the tools I had before, and when I got more abilities with the watch, I did better.

I suspect the difference is that some use the device as a crutch rather than a tool.

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by ambulancechaser on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @08:18AM (#13705199)
i'm not sure where you are correcting the person you are responding to. It all seems consistent to me.
Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by mattmanser on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @09:03AM (#13705526)
He says it "enables" him, the data shows it does not. It has a negative effect on weight and no effect on fitness.

If anything, it is damaging and according to this article, you should get rid of them.

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by basseq on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @09:56AM (#13705917)
On the average, you're right. People with Fitbits still lost weight, but less than the "control" group. So if the presence of a Fitbit is the only variable, then Fitbits have a negative impact. The study wasn't set up to test that one variable, so I'd be wary drawing such strong conclusions.

Your point is that the title is misleading. It's not that fitness devices don't make you more fit. It's that they make you less fit. And that's a big difference.

Individual "enablement" could be an outlier. I'd love to see a distribution of weight loss results in this study.

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by mattmanser on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @11:03AM (#13706481)
The article title is quite gentle compared to what's actually said in the article. But that wasn't my point.

The article draws the strong conclusion that fitness trackers are useless based on a study. The author compares them to fad diets, sold to the public before they're even properly tested. Now they've been tested and they don't work.

But when I came to this comment thread, the top comment is extolling how wonderfully enabling fitbits are apart from you just gotta have will power. According to one guy.

The article flatly contradicts his stance. According to the study results, on average, even the people with willpower got no fitter.

I doubt he read the article, I doubt anyone down voting anything I said did either.

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by cbanek on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:48PM (#13709484)
First, you assume too much. I'm not a guy.

While I did read the article, I didn't read the underlying studies, mostly because they aren't freely available.

The way the studies are done though, each person has professional help monitoring diet, and a nurse. I've been through these kinds of programs before personally, and while the people are great, they are more checking in with you and making you accountable, which drives results. Obviously someone making a diet plan for you does no good if you don't follow it, just like how cardio doesn't do much for you if you aren't pushing your heart rate up.

In the article, the first study, called inconclusive, actually said that people with pedometers were more physically active.

Really, experimental method means everything. In the article, they say one group lost 14 pounds, and one on average lost 7. Over 2 years. That's honestly not a lot of weight lost (1 lb per month or less), and they didn't provide any statistics other than the average, which is typically misleading (some probably gained weight, some probably lost a lot of weight).

What you're saying is basically a study said when you measure something, you get worse at it. As if the Heisenberg uncertainty principal is at play. What I'm saying is that a tracker is a tool, and how and why you use that tool is incredibly important. Just like how you could say most people who buy a home gym don't use it, so therefore obviously buying a home gym makes you fat.

I believe I also said in my original comment, which you obviously read but missed the part where I said people could be treating this as an undeserved pat on the back.

In all of this, the experimental method is everything. Articles like this are written in a very fluffy style, making conclusions about causation that I find dubious.