Except some of those mutations can be useful – some deadly, but some could be selected for as one's environment/niche shifts. That's evolution and selection in a nutshell. Not all mutations are bad and not all bad mutations are always bad.
I just envy what I interpret as an intragenerational bolstering of genetic traits that females have, assuming the EXITS thing is truly what's going on. They don't have to wait a generation to perhaps select out the bad, they get to do it on the fly.
It seems to me that chiefly the non-suppressed X chromosome in females would see action by its workings and thus accumulate adaptations.
This scheme can lessen certain X-linked genetic disorders in women since not all cells will be affected.
In fact, the Y-chromosome has completely disappeared in some species [0].
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Y_chromosome#Future_evolution
http://www.mnn.com/family/pets/stories/why-are-male-calico-c...
There's no need to worry about the Y chromosome disappearing because it's remarkably stable. This makes sense -- males with Y mutations die out and men are extremely good at producing offspring. This only good Y chromosomes are passed on.
Nevertheless, the genes on the Y chromosome are like any other and if the Y chromosome were to disappear, natural selection would still push for a 50/50 sex ratio. The Y chromosome itself isn't necessary to make a male -- its genes can be spliced onto the X chromosome and function properly. Thus, if we saw loss of Y, we would likely see a 50/50 gender split but now based on presence of the SRY gene.
If that were to occur, we'd get into more X-SRY X-SRY situations much more often though, right? Sounds unhealthy, I'd prefer to keep the Y separate and intact for as long as possible. :)
Some of the other posters in the thread already mentioned calico cat fur coloration. The underlying mechanism is the textbook example of Barr body inactivation. You should check it out on Wikipedia.
One possible safety hatch that comes to mind is that it's possible for XX males to exist. There's only one gene on the Y chromosome which has anything to do with male development, the SRY gene, which causes the proto-gonads to develop into testes (all male development following that is the result of the testes producing androgens). During meiosis, it's possible for the SRY gene to break off of the Y chromosome on one sperm and make its way into the X chromosome on the other sperm. When this happens, it's called de la Chapelle syndrome [0].
So if the Y chromosome eventually becomes unusable, we might end up in a future where males are created by inducing de la Chapelle syndrome in vitro by splicing an SRY gene into the zygote.
The only problem is that males with de la Chapelle syndrome are sterile, but I'm sure that if we get to the level of technology where this kind of gene splicing is commonplace, we can come up with some kind of hack to get around it. It's been speculated for a while that eventually we'll develop the technology to make one egg fertilize another in vitro, resulting in a healthy XX zygote, so that's one way (though the eggs wouldn't come from people with de la Chapelle's... which means we wouldn't need to induce it in the first place... so female-only world it is).
Or nuke everything, whichever comes first. Heh.
Edit: not to knock off the downvotes, if they're due, they're due. But may I enquire as to why I am being downvoted?
In my opinion, you didn't add much to the conversation and then with that last crack you did a snarky mic drop where you totally blew it.
I like to ask questions, perhaps with a careful dash of snark if I think I can flash out with some wit, and keep the conversation going.
For example, I might reply to you,
> Which is why human engage in mate selection and are great at multiplying.
Are we really selecting mates based on any useful criteria? It seems random to me, rarely based chiefly on reproductive fitness.
... and then someone smart chimes in with a technocratic article on how we DO (for the most part) select based on X number of traits that increase the survivability of our offspring - and we roll on for a bit more and I learn new things.
I didn't mean to sound snarky, it was more of the pessimist in me. But chiefly an optimist. I trust evolution is doing the right thing. But that is indeed a weak argument, seeing as it's not supported by either more philosophy or science.
I do apologise for how it came through, in was on mobile and didn't have time to put in more prose.
I should have brought in more facts into my own argumet to spark a discussion. I'll take the critism to mind and adjust.
> Or nuke everything, whichever comes first. Heh.
is the why. Casual amusement at nuclear holocaust/extinction doesn't tend to get a lot of upvotes on HN.
Plus, it didn't make any sense: 1) a nuclear war wouldn't involve nuking everything under any plausible scenario; 2) you could direct every nuclear missile on earth at just the US (including the US arsenal) and still not manage to kill all the people in the US with either the initial blasts or the fallout, which is another way of saying that not only can we not nuke everything, but we couldn't even eradicate ourselves with nuclear war if we wanted to for some reason (much less wipe out the planet, much less wipe out all of humanity, that's all beyond far-fetched).
EDIT: Ah, wikipedia explains that the two X chromosomes in a standard-issue woman come from the mother and paternal grandmother, and then ... "Early in embryonic development in females, one of the two X chromosomes is randomly and permanently inactivated in nearly all somatic cells (cells other than egg and sperm cells). This phenomenon is called X-inactivation or Lyonization, and creates a Barr body. If X-inactivation in the somatic cell meant a complete de-functionalizing of one of the X-chromosomes, it would ensure that females, like males, had only one functional copy of the X chromosome in each somatic cell. This was previously assumed to be the case. However, recent research suggests that the Barr body may be more biologically active than was previously supposed." Which must be related to the EXITS that the OP refers to.
Being a male, I'm troubled by the fitness of the Y-chromosome over the generations. It seems to me that it can only accumulate errors and mutations. However, I suppose the same could be said about the mitochondria that come exclusively from females. This partial double-X scheme seems like a useful way of mixing up traits intrageneration and maybe strengthen healthful cell behaviors.