News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by mdip on Monday February 20, 2017 @05:41AM (#13686185)
Completely agree! The funny thing is the first thing I thought of was an old microwave I owned with a similar setup mainly because the microwave I own, today, is so awful[0].

I have a GE combination convection oven/microwave and it was clearly designed by someone who had their first experience with LSD that day. Every function requires a different, magic, set of key combinations to make it work. Want to set a timer? That's easy, press timer, turn the dial to the right time (which inexplicably increases/decreases the time in 30 second increments). OK, you've done that, now you want to start it. Press "Timer" ... nope. Press "Start" ... nope. Oh, I have to push in the dial... I didn't even know that, too, was a button. Oh, and not once, not twice, but three times is the magic number of times required to start said timer.

Starting the microwave with a specific time in mind requires hitting no less than 6 buttons, but there's one button that will start the microwave on high for 30 seconds, so everyone just uses that button and hits it as many times as is required to get close to the desired cooking length. I can hear my wife counting out loud ten beeps for a 5 minute cook time.

It's got piles of advanced, useless, features, my favorite of which is a hybrid "microwave/oven cook" mode that manages to bring in the worst of both methods, giving you soggy food, unevenly cooked that takes an eternity to cook.

Even the clock is stupid. You punch in the hours/minutes, and thinking you're done, you move on to something else. Later you go to cook something and for some bizarre reason, "AM or PM" pops up on the screen at which point nothing in your previous experience in operating a microwave prepares you to figure out why heating something up requires knowledge of whether it's morning or afternoon. Of course, nothing this microwave does requires knowledge of AM/PM, nor does it display AM or PM anywhere on the screen, but for some reason it just must know.

[0] This isn't the exact model but it looks close: https://www.amazon.com/GE-PVM9179SFSS-Profile-Stainless-Micr...

Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by delegate on Monday February 20, 2017 @07:03AM (#13686569)
Obviously whoever designed it didn't get the 'good' acid.

Had he gotten the real shit, it would have been a musical instrument... with wheels, which also microwaves... inside and outside... Because that's how you get to the aliens.

Who wouldn't want his oven to roll around the house improvising some trippy music while the meal is being heated ? While at it, why not also vacuum clean the house ? Just hit the knob a magical 4 times ..

You've got the wonder machine right there. I mean hello? Whatever happened to creativity these days ?

Experience tells me I have to disclaim this: yes, of course it's a joke.

Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by DonHopkins on Monday February 20, 2017 @09:22AM (#13687426)
If you happen to run across some really good acid, of even if you're feeling sober and playful, try putting a York Peppermint Patty in the microwave until the alien hatches.
Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by mdip on Monday February 20, 2017 @03:45PM (#13690744)
OK, you got me there -- just sent milk from my cereal out my nose.

For real! It would also be the only microwave on the market that no matter what's cooking, it will make your kitchen smell like the color blue.

Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by rubberstamp on Monday February 20, 2017 @01:03PM (#13689411)
Should I take acid to be able to write like you? Its so hilarious
Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by kogepathic on Monday February 20, 2017 @08:14AM (#13686907)
The Sharp designers of my microwave [0] couldn't even design the clock to keep accurate time. The built-in clock is fast. It will gain about 3 minutes per week.

I'm honestly not sure how they managed to screw that up. 32.768kHz crystal was too expensive? Or just too incompetent to keep track of time correctly?

[0] https://www.amazon.de/Sharp-Mikrowelle-Grill-Kompakt-Mikrowe...

Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by mdip on Monday February 20, 2017 @03:50PM (#13690777)
Oh, good point - you made me remember the mystery we solved at my old office.

We were convinced that the microwave was a low wattage unit because it would require you to cook things about 25% more than whatever the package said. It turned out that the digital timer was fast. We started the thing for a minute against a stopwatch app and it was off by more than 10 seconds.

This thing didn't even have a clock -- it was basically designed to do two things: (1) Bombard food with microwaves and (2) stop bombarding said thing after a specified period of time. It did one of those things about as poorly as it could be done.

Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by paulmd on Monday February 20, 2017 @11:46AM (#13688692)
The worst part is you don't even need a crystal for that. Anything that's connected to line power has a built-in 60 Hz oscillator that is adjusted so that it will never gain or lose more than a few seconds...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_clock

My car's clock is also awful about this - it loses something like 3 minutes per month. But at least there you can blame it on the unknown and varying voltage that the battery and alternator provide...

Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by mdip on Monday February 20, 2017 @03:59PM (#13690843)
Do you drive a Ford Fusion with the Sync radio, by chance? The stereo in my Fusion does this -- about 2-3 minutes/month slow, so after a few months I start thinking I'm on time for things when I'm actually a few minutes late.

The older Ford Fusion Sync radios (Microsoft variety) are a perfect example of how not to do a UI. I wanted it because my previous car had Bluetooth pairing and I got used to using my phone for music/entertainment and wanted my new car to have the same experience. Of course, being the MS variety of Sync, it has the buggy Bluetooth implementation, so one out of three times I get in the car, my stereo fails to connect. Thank GOD it's got voice commands because I have no idea what combination of buttons is required to actually switch to the Bluetooth input (which is required to be done every time you start the car again regardless of whether or not you were previously on that input). As long as everyone is silent when I hit that magic button to issue my command, and as long as I tilt my head upward toward the mic and speak very clearly, about half the time it switches the input correctly.

Who the hell thought it would be a good idea to make a car stereo so complicated that it pretty much guarantees you're going to take your eyes off the road for long periods of time trying to figure out how to change the station when One Direction comes on (I feel the same way about newer cars that just have the "iPad Screen" style interface -- no tactile anything).

Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by dri_ft on Monday February 20, 2017 @06:25AM (#13686415)
Holy christ. Horrifying. I can't understand how microwaves are all so bad. Where are the good ones? Isn't it less work to make a simpler (better) interface than the baroque ones we end up with?
Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by tim333 on Monday February 20, 2017 @07:12AM (#13686611)
Trad two knob microwaves are still available and usually the cheapest eg http://www.argos.co.uk/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/Browse?s=Pr...

so I blame consumers for buying the ones with the silly buttons.

Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by iofiiiiiiiii on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @07:36AM (#13695010)
I used to buy the cheap 2-knob ones but they are the cheapest for a reason. After light use, the knobs would inevitably disconnect from the internals. The shop replaced it for free but my time is more valuable than a microwave, so replacements are not really satisfactory.
Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by summarite on Monday February 20, 2017 @02:13PM (#13690000)
It's when people buy for features rather than use. If given the choice most people are likely to buy the one with the longest spec sheet - don't want to miss out on that meat vs vegetable defrost difference! And it's the same price. And it has a few more buttons but I'm not stupid...

On the other side, there's probably a demand on the "designers"to keep inventing and adding new features while keeping it as cheap as possible to produce. And each version is just slightly different from the previous one, so best not to redesign the wiring/programming, just add the new feature in the technically easiest/cheapest way!

Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by mdip on Monday February 20, 2017 @04:06PM (#13690885)
You're completely right. In my case, I bought this model because my wife likes to cook and we only had one conventional oven (a gas oven, as well, which cooks differently[0] than an electric one). We decided on it because it would give us a "sort of" second oven for the various times when that's needed. In retrospect, we almost never use the other capability -- not because of a combination of two things - (1) we're too lazy to get the manual out to see what particular incantation needs to be performed to make the "oven" feature work and (2) it takes almost twice as long to pre-heat than any other oven we've ever owned so if you don't plan in advance and start pre-heating it before you actually decide what you're going to cook, the main oven is often free by the time the thing pre-heats.

It goes to show, though, when you jam in a bunch of features into a device that isn't really meant for those features, the added features are often not implemented well enough to make them very useful.

The one redeeming factor this microwave has is that the entire interior is stainless steel. Everyone who uses our microwave does a double-take when they open it seeing all that metal. It's super easy to clean, but that's about it.

[0] Natural gas ovens are less dry than electric ovens, so baking in them results in very moist results but also often requires cooking things longer. I bought it, though, because they're really simple devices that will basically last forever, having only really the $20 ignition element fail about once every decade.

Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by webmaven on Monday February 20, 2017 @02:51PM (#13690315)
Yeah, the industrial designers can't really crank up the watts on the magnetron or otherwise mess with the specifications, most of what's left is fiddling with the UI to enable ever more elaborate combinations of timing and power (most of which aren't very useful).

My favorite peeve is that cheap MW ovens often don't let you add time while the oven is running when the affordance is already right there (just push the +1m button you used to set the time again). You only get that feature if you buy a more expensive and complex model.

Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by coldpie on Monday February 20, 2017 @08:48AM (#13687134)
Honestly the cheaper ones are just fine. As you add more features, you add more complexity. Mine was like $50 and the interface is great. If you want to set the power, mash that key a few times until it gets to the desired level. Then press Start to go for 30 seconds, keep pressing Start to add 30 seconds to the running timer. If you need a specific time, you can type that in with the number keys, but I almost never do that. That's it. It's a microwave. Fifty bucks. Bought it at Macy's. Cool.
Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by khedoros1 on Monday February 20, 2017 @12:46PM (#13689247)
I had one that the first 6 numbers would cook for that many minutes, and the "start" button usually acted as an "add 30 seconds" button. You could also program a time, but like you, I almost never did that (mostly just if I was using the timer mode, which didn't have the same quick shortcuts).
Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by Joeri on Monday February 20, 2017 @11:45AM (#13688678)
The sharp r-9xx series still have dial knobs for power and time, as well as all the fancy features. Easy stuff is simple, complex is possible. They cook evenly and last for ages.
Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by RachelF on Monday February 20, 2017 @05:20PM (#13691522)
Like many products, microwaves are designed to sell, not to be used.

The consumer in the store thinks that better product has more buttons and features, not thinking how they would be used.

Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by ismail-khan on Monday February 20, 2017 @07:12AM (#13686612)
The buyer is usually not the end user.

For example, a landlord is biased towards purchasing appliances that looks complex so they can show off all the extra "features" to clients.

Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by wattt on Monday February 20, 2017 @09:03AM (#13687258)
You mean real estate agent. Landlords generally get the cheapest shit because otherwise it cuts into the bottom line.
Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by jdavis703 on Monday February 20, 2017 @12:29PM (#13689090)
Depends on what you're renting. Also they usually splurge on things that look fancy like microwaves, and cheap out on hidden things like recessed lighting that is "secured" with aluminum screws.
Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by annnnd on Monday February 20, 2017 @09:39AM (#13687575)
$500 for a microwave??? What does it do, fly?

I have an old microwave with two buttons and it works great. Kids can use it too.

Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by GFischer on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:45PM (#13697590)
You reminded me, mine has an anti-kids "feature", which is that it can't be turned on unless you set it up, press the start button, then open the door, close the door and press the start button again.

I don't have kids and I haven't found a way to disable it, it looks silly opening and closing the door twice every time I want to use it, but I've automated the habit.

Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by mdip on Monday February 20, 2017 @04:11PM (#13690925)
Unfortunately, it does a whole bunch of things other than microwave (it's got a full, electric, convection oven and a hybrid convection oven/microwave capability). It does all three of it's major functions very nearly as poorly as they could be done.

This was also purchased in 2005 or so, and was a relatively new idea at the time that, thankfully, didn't take off terribly well.

Re:Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used? by antocv on Monday February 20, 2017 @06:28AM (#13686435)
I would not stand that in my housing unit, sell it on craiglist or similar, buy a used older model.