Re:Hacker News Upvote: Add to Cart
by austenallred on Saturday February 18, 2017 @05:33PM
(#13677063)
I'll email you.
For what it's worth, I don't think HN is in any immediate danger, nor do I know of any active, large-scale vote manipulation happening currently. But to say something like "vote manipulation on HN does not work" is a very bold claim.
Ok, I look forward to it. Edit: still waiting!
I understand that HN's ranking algorithm isn't 100% disclosed because people post startups here and this forum needs to be a fair environment. I say this to make clear that I do get the security ramifications of revealing too much.
But it sounds like you have a bit of understanding when it comes to this topic, which I'm very interested in understanding more about generically speaking. I've always been curious how vote manipulation detection _actually works_, and the kinds of things that can be done to combat vote hacking of various kinds.
I say this as someone vaguely considering the idea of making a small HN-like forum at some point (still figuring out the why and how).
What makes you sure? If you know something we don't, we need to hear it—the community relies on us to get this right. It's also personal: I've poured countless hours into combating vote manipulation, and if you know my code isn't working, you bet I want you to spell out how.
The upside of a public discussion outweighs the downside because (1) if you tell us things we don't know, we can start investigating for them—it's what we don't know that's worrisome; and (2) community members might respond with valuable knowledge of their own. That's also why we haven't buried the OP (which, in case users are wondering, we do know about and have lots of data on).