FYI I really appreciate the way you moderate dang, thanks for all the hard work. You're clear, transparent, informative and paitent. It really makes all the difference.
Thank you!
Re:Hacker News Upvote: Add to Cart
by CodeWriter23 on Saturday February 18, 2017 @05:54PM
(#13677152)
I feel like the example you provided vs. the person's detached comment is splitting hairs over a stylistic issue. In the detached comment, ErikVandeWater is precisely asking for what he wants. In a community heavily weighted with engineers, I think this behavior should be expected, and not penalized.
I understand, but we have a lot of experience with "stylistic issues" triggering destructive flamewars on HN, and there were signs of that in this case.
In face-to-face conversation, most good-faith signals are sent with tone of voice and physical expression. We don't have those channels in text so it's necessary to encode them some other way.