News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hacker News Upvote: Add to Cart by minimaxir on Saturday February 18, 2017 @04:09PM (#13676697)
> I just don't have the time or the money to shell out and buy IPs.

You need a Hacker News account to upvote, and obviously having a large number of new accounts upvote something would trip a voting ring detector.

> Furthermore, if you produce something solid, all you'd really need is the first <10 upvotes to get on the front page and let it catch on "organically."

Much easier said than done. The median score of a HN submission is 1-2 points last time I checked. (the discoverability of HN submissions on /newest is an issue, but that's another topic)

And if it's actually solid, it's not the market for vote brigading.

I agree manipulation does happen, but it doesn't mean it works and instead silently penalizes the submission to death.

Re:Hacker News Upvote: Add to Cart by austenallred on Saturday February 18, 2017 @04:14PM (#13676721)
> You need a Hacker News account to upvote, and obviously having a large number of new accounts upvote something would trip a voting ring detector.

Correct, but what if I gave myself a couple or few months to prepare accounts? Do a search on blackhatworld (or another spam forum) for "aged accounts" and you'll see that you can generally buy them in tiers - the older they are the more expensive they are.

I'm not saying it's worth it or I think it's something people should do, but saying it's not possible or doesn't work is absurd.

Re:Hacker News Upvote: Add to Cart by clickbait on Sunday February 19, 2017 @09:49PM (#13683874)
I think it'd be fairly obvious that something suspicious was going on if a large number of dormant "aged accounts" just happened to login for the first time in months to upvote a specific thread.
Re:Hacker News Upvote: Add to Cart by elastic_church on Saturday February 18, 2017 @04:52PM (#13676912)
Except this is why there is an economy of aged accounts....

It directly affects the cost of the promotional service