Are we supposed to have no regulation and no taxation on businesses because otherwise some other state/country can offer them a better deal? Or do we need to have stronger regulation across country borders/policy that prohibits these loopholes. Maybe we should tax a US company more if they choose to produce products in another country to get around regulations that we have in the US.
Clearly there are more to countries than tax rates and regulations. However, the parent poster relates an anecdote where one country with less restrictive regulation is chosen over another, all other things being equal.
So to answer your question, if a country has a superior market or the right labor pool, then it will succeed despite higher tax rates or restrictive regulations, to a point.
Despite a zero corporate tax rate and few regulations, Somalia still hasn't posed a threat to Europe and the U.S. as a corporate headquarters. The "race to the bottom" is bounded by other factors besides tax rates and regulation. Rule of law, enforceability of contracts, access to a skilled labor pool, access to markets, etc. are more important.
Interestingly enough, these factors are a correlated to sufficient government revenue and regulation to uphold contracts and satisfy labor.
Here is why: as a business owner I face a 40% tax rate at the corporate level and then 35% on personal income. I am thus highly incentivized to keep profit in the business and reinvest it or look for growth opportunities rather than distribute it to myself and our other shareholders.
Now imagine you are Sam Walton of Walmart. You stumbled upon a fantastic business model that prints money (or your Apple sitting on $250bn in cash). On the margin you will always opt to reinvest the money in the company or at least let it sit there unspent (i.e. Apple/Google/Msft) if the alternative means paying an incremental tax on it. So what do you do? Grow grow grow.
Anyway just wanted to share my thoughts. I am not trying to be controversial... I believe that long term sustainable health of an economy is predicated on the health of small businesses. I genuinely believe double taxation may have a potentially perverse incentive and negative outcome on a society simply by the way it alters my own decision making and incentives.
I would like to see a similar model explaining what labor law accomplishes and how you know when the laws are being too strict. The problem is that the obvious answer ("so workers don't get exploited") isn't very satisfying: there's sort of an inherent barrier to not paying enough, which is competition for workers[2]. You would need to explain labor law as filling some role that isn't a simple matter of competitive compensation.
[1] My post on the importance of having a model that identifies both a Scylla and a Charybdis: http://blog.tyrannyofthemouse.com/2015/12/the-scylla-charybd...
[2] The typical argument is like, "look at [obviously poorer time]. They paid [obviously bad wage]. Now [after years of accumulation of capital] we mandate they don't do that, and stars above! They get good wages now." I don't find that satisfying.
Collusion among employers to keep wages down still happens. The combination of minimum standards plus anti-collusion laws function as a belt-and-suspenders approach to the problem (labor law has other purposes, too; so does anti-collusion law.)
A) That would justify anti-conspiracy countermeasures, not general "you have to pay them more" laws.
B) It would rather dubiously require a conspiracy along the rather huge number of low-skill employers. I can accept a conspiracy between McDonald's and BK, but across numbers indistries and localities?
I believe in the principle that the unintended consequences of any policy usually wind up outweighing the intended ones.
I love the story:
> The term cobra effect stems from an anecdote set at the time of British rule of colonial India. The British government was concerned about the number of venomous cobra snakes in Delhi.[3] The government therefore offered a bounty for every dead cobra. Initially this was a successful strategy as large numbers of snakes were killed for the reward. Eventually, however, enterprising people began to breed cobras for the income. When the government became aware of this, the reward program was scrapped, causing the cobra breeders to set the now-worthless snakes free. As a result, the wild cobra population further increased. The apparent solution for the problem made the situation even worse.
Basic income does the same thing for the distortionary minimum wage.
It's not as if the permatemp phenomenon isn't a problem right here in the United States, where it's generally pretty easy to fire people.
Sharks are welcome to have an opinion on the food chain, just be aware of their position when evaluating it.
There's good evidence that minimum wages can be used to nudge up bottom tier salaries without very much impact on employment rates. For use-cases that tend to suffer most (eg youth employment), most EU countries have exemptions.
Labour laws which try to force longevity come with some costs that aren't very easily mitigated. "At-will" employment sounds very aggressive but forced employment sounds bad too.
I think compensation packages (based on years in employment) should replace no-firing laws. This will keep a softer incentive in place, but avoid making hiring people so risky.
I've seen this sort of thing backfire a lot in Europe where well intended regulation causes far more harm (both to individuals and the economy of the country) than good.
Was in a meeting not too long back where major investments were being discussed and the places to invest where on the table (with jobs at stake). Long story short some regulatory monkey was saying "this ref prevents this, you'd have to do that" and such for a location in Europe at which point the execs in the room basically just said "fine, we just won't invest there... if they want to have silly practices we'll just put the jobs elsewhere." And they did.
I'm no Republican but the concept of regulations killing jobs and hurting the people they intended to help is a very real thing.