News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What is Indemnification? by crdoconnor on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @09:31AM (#13643694)
>I was once asked to sign a software development contract that would have made me "responsible for estimated loss of profits".

I usually walk away completely at that point. Something like this is a red flag that you're dealing either with shysters or people who don't read what their lawyers give them. Both imply you're going to have a bad time.

Re:What is Indemnification? by chrisbennet on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @09:41PM (#13649282)
If a person was asking for the crazy things I see in contracts, yes, I'd agree with you since it shows intent.

If you treat companies like that, you miss out on opportunities since the crazy stuff in the contract is negotiable and the guy you're negotiating with didn't write the contract and won't mind you crossing out the bad parts that keep both of you from a mutually beneficial deal.

Companies are made of various factions who's goals may only be loosely aligned with the company's goals.

The lawyer drafting the contract is trying to protect the company. If you weren't rewarded for making the company lots of money, only punished if the company gets sued, how would you write a contract?

Re:What is Indemnification? by crdoconnor on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @06:13AM (#13651176)
>If a person was asking for the crazy things I see in contracts, yes, I'd agree with you since it shows intent.

Usually somebody did. And, if the person who hands you the contract acts surprised about its contents that isn't good either. It demonstrates a dangerous lack of control.

>If you treat companies like that, you miss out on opportunities since the crazy stuff in the contract is negotiable and the guy you're negotiating with didn't write the contract and won't mind you crossing out the bad parts that keep both of you from a mutually beneficial deal.

This is exactly what I used to think when I encountered a guy who apparently hadn't read his contract, acted surprised about its contents and he was happy to change it.

He later ended up not paying me as he ran out of money without noticing. Apparently he not only neglected to read his contracts, he neglected to read his bank statements.

So far he's the only person who acted surprised about the contents of his contract.

>The lawyer drafting the contract is trying to protect the company.

Egregious fuck-you clauses can actually hurt the company's standing in court since a judge may decide the rest of the contract shouldn't be enforceable (at least under UK law).

Either way, unless the client is exceptional in all other respects or you really need them it's usually worth walking away.

Re:What is Indemnification? by chrisbennet on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @08:57AM (#13651992)
I'm not sure I agree with you (at least not yet) but I upvoted you for sharing your experience/data points. My own view/thoughts on this is are shaped by an extremely small sample set so I could be wrong.
Re:What is Indemnification? by pc86 on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @09:37AM (#13643741)
I hate to burst your bubble but most people don't read what lawyers put in front of them, especially if it's their own lawyer.