Anyway, the point should be you want to get people who are skilled. Maybe/maybe not that means English fluency. But, that's another matter.
It seems most abuse[0] happens due to random Indian body-shops. Since Trump is so carte-blanche maybe he can just blacklist the ones we know to be obvious abusers.
Maybe a better answer is to require all H1-Bs be actual full-time employees of the company, rather than being under contract through a third party?
[0]I define abuse as using H1-Bs primarily for cheap labor vs skilled labor.
The comment was in response to a lot of "citizens first, immigrants only if they don't hurt our current citizens at all" arguments here. By proposing that visas may be, or at least could be, a form of foreign policy I believe helps to dispute that point in general, highlighting higher goals than plugging talent shortages that may or may not exist.
I haven't seen H1B visa's used like this in my personal experience. At the last company I worked for they were mostly used to fill our testing team with people from India.
Maybe they were all guinness, the problem was all but one of them could speak/write english fluently.
I can also look at my boyfriend's current employer who recently took a trip to india in order to hire a team of indians "on the cheap" only to fire all but 1 within a month after they didn't really get anything productive done.