Re:Post-Detection SETI Protocols and METI: The Time Has Come...
by pmoriarty on Saturday February 11, 2017 @07:28PM
(#13625786)
They don't even need to have a long lifespan. They could have the same or even shorter lifespans than humans but use generation ships, or go in to some kind of stasis, or they could send out robotic drones or von Neumann probes.
Re:Post-Detection SETI Protocols and METI: The Time Has Come...
by YeGoblynQueenne on Saturday February 11, 2017 @07:34PM
(#13625807)
Yes indeed! Or they could be a BSG-like space-nomad armada drifting in look for a new homeworld. Or a Borg-like space-faring colony.
Those are just silly popular Sci-fi series scenarios and already they do to "You Need FTL to Attack the Earth" what the Vehrmacht did to the Maginot line.
We can't be debating SETI's happy-go-lucky talk-to-aliens plans at that sort of level. These guys need to be reminded, we may be alone in the universe but they're not alone on this planet. Even if there was no risk at all, unilaterally deciding to try and contact an alien species on behalf of all humankind is insanely irresponsible.
Re:Post-Detection SETI Protocols and METI: The Time Has Come...
by grzm on Saturday February 11, 2017 @07:21PM
(#13625751)
and a life span that makes it reasonable to undertake the journey from your home-world to the Earth.
You can even relax this requirement if you're willing to consider generation ships: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generation_ship
You don't need FTL travel to get here. All you need is interstellar travel at sub-luminal speeds, and a life span that makes it reasonable to undertake the journey from your home-world to the Earth.
Say, a species with a lifespan of ten thousand years living in a planet 10 light years away, that can travel at half the speed of light- it would take them 20 years to travel here and 20 to go back. For us, half a life-time. For them, just a short hop. And probably totally worth it if there was a habitable planet at the end of it.
Can we really say what is the expected life span of intelligent species with technological civilisations on planets in a 10 light years radius from us? Like hell we can.
Note also that with that kind of speed they'd be here within the lifetime of most people currently alive (even taking into account the 10 years it would take for SETI's message to reach them). Even with a quarter of the speed of light, many of us would be still around. We're not even talking geological time scales here. We'd have plenty of time to reflect on our foolishness. That's no way to go extinct, cursing at your species' stupidity.
If you won't listen to prof. Hawking at least listen to Hawkwind: Space is deep. Don't go fucking with it.