News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Posix Has Become Outdated (2016) [pdf] by nickpsecurity on Saturday February 11, 2017 @11:32AM (#13623286)
I would not if the goal of a standard is uptake by OS and application developers. Wide usage of a product = popularity. It didn't achieve the popularity it sought. This is independent of what businesses like Microsoft were doing.

Microsoft's strategy was to create a permanent dependence on them for long-term profitability. They had too many tactics for that to cover here. Once open standards proliferated, they subverted them too with proprietary extensions under "Embrace, Extend, Extinguish" strategy. Companies buying into their solutions and using non-standard features paid the price.

Regardless, people still created apps that worked on such proprietary platforms and UNIXen via portability frameworks or libraries. Some products using them became quite popular (eg Apache, Netscape/Firefox) with some of the frameworks themselves becoming popular (eg Qt, GTK, wxWindows, Tk). POSIX's got into enough stuff that it was a default many picked up. Whereas, these others people went to willingly even when POSIX was available with even more portability. That's why they were objectively more successful on portability.

Re:Posix Has Become Outdated (2016) [pdf] by AsyncAwait on Saturday February 11, 2017 @04:20PM (#13624865)
> It didn't achieve the popularity it sought

By what metric?

POSIX was never trying to be the universal interface for all kinds of applications, just some sane common interface for UNIX vendors, all of which do implement POSIX to a large extent these days.

You could perhaps make the argument that by the time POSIX saw enough adoption, software development evolved and that nowdays there are lots of interfaces that are not part of POSIX/not portable, but that's a slightly different issue.

Re:Posix Has Become Outdated (2016) [pdf] by nickpsecurity on Saturday February 11, 2017 @06:15PM (#13625439)
That's close to my argument. There's kind of two conversations going on in these threads: UNIX portability and general portability. POSIX is fine on former but worse on latter since it wasnt designed for it (among other things).
Re:Posix Has Become Outdated (2016) [pdf] by geezerjay on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:07PM (#13623466)
> I would not if the goal of a standard is uptake by OS and application developers.

That point is moot, as those platforms were designed with the express purpose of being particularly hostile regarding interoperability while forcing other corporate products as alternatives, in a well-known lock-in strategy.

Re:Posix Has Become Outdated (2016) [pdf] by nickpsecurity on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:32PM (#13623609)
"those platforms were designed with the express purpose"

They were designed with the purpose of giving users a way to get things done that was profitable to the company. The first part along with lock-in techniques are why most of the desktop market is Windows with a large chunk of the server market. That means the kind of portability that matters to people wanting to maximize benefit to users or profits to the company better include a Windows version. There are portability alternatives to POSIX that allow that usually with other benefits on top of it. Far from moot...

Re:Posix Has Become Outdated (2016) [pdf] by geezerjay on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:50PM (#13623731)
> They were designed with the purpose of giving users

No, they actually weren't.

The "users" don't have any say whether Windows complies with any standard, or even if Microsoft breaks all of them to try to force the world to submit to their "vendor lock-in" business strategy.

Trying to pass off the consequences of vendor lock-in policies as technical arguments is somewhere between absurd and disingenuous.

Re:Posix Has Become Outdated (2016) [pdf] by nickpsecurity on Saturday February 11, 2017 @06:13PM (#13625431)
You said the only purpose of what Windows did was locking in people. I said it was to provide software that let people accomplish what they want while making profit sustained by lockin tricks. Are you saying Microsoft never intended people to use Windows API or software to accomplish their personal goals? That there is zero benefit to users of Windows in consumer or business space?