News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China Central Bank Said to Call Bitcoin Exchanges for Talks by Animats on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @03:26PM (#13601699)
China has export controls on money transfer, but they leak. They're not intended to be airtight; anyone in China can take about $50K in yuan to Hong Kong once a month and exchange it for euros or dollars. (Sending all your relatives to Hong Kong once a month to do this is a thing.) A big question for the last year was whether the PBOC was going to loosen or tighten exchange controls. Around the end of November, the decision came out: tighten.[1] Too much money is fleeing China. China flight capital drove the London and Vancover real estate booms, among other things. The PBOC wants to slow down the money drain.

Bitcoin is one of the leaks. It looks like the PBOC is taking a harder look at Bitcoin exchanges. It's a way to convert yuan to dollars or euros. Buy Bitcoin in China with yuan, sell elsewhere for dollars and euros. This is currently the main use case for Bitcoin. (Face it, retail use of Bitcoin went nowhere.)

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/29/business/economy/china-ti...

Re:China Central Bank Said to Call Bitcoin Exchanges for Talks by contingencies on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @07:03PM (#13603433)
Face it, retail use of Bitcoin went nowhere.

In physical retail, sure. I live in China. I've done consulting work for US companies, been paid in Bitcoin, and used the money to purchase and ship antiques from Europe (via Skrill). I was pleasantly surprised that it was possible (without furnishing stupendous quantities of documentation to US-encumbered Bitcoin exchanges) and feel the user experience has in many ways already surpassed credit cards.

Re:China Central Bank Said to Call Bitcoin Exchanges for Talks by BoorishBears on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @08:48PM (#13603945)
Not to be rude, but how does that address the parent post's point?

Your example is extremely niche. I don't see how one could reasonably claim bitcoin has any involvement whatsoever in mainstream online retail. It really has gone nowhere on the scale of "somewhere" assuming "somewhere" is anything past niche exchanges (and contraband)

Re:China Central Bank Said to Call Bitcoin Exchanges for Talks by contingencies on Thursday February 09, 2017 @08:14PM (#13612540)
Get out of your bubble. 1.4 billion people live in China. A similar number live in India. That's a huge percentage of people on the planet. These people cannot easily access the US-dominated credit card system at all, or if they can only with significant restrictions. For example, a foreign friend of mine with a credit card issued by a Chinese bank explained to me this week that he cannot use it online because the bank has conjoined his first and last names. Bitcoin gives them a method of cross-border settlement that is actually available and effective.
Re:China Central Bank Said to Call Bitcoin Exchanges for Talks by BoorishBears on Thursday February 09, 2017 @09:54PM (#13612908)
I'm from Ghana and visit all the time. I lived in 3 countries for at least 2 years each by the time I was 10. Please don't insult me by claiming I live in a "bubble"

Bitcoin does not end up being a solution to problem you described in the slightest. The "US-dominated credit card system" and websites that take Bitcoin very rarely overlap.

The whole point I made was that the credit card system is still dominating major online retailers and that Bitcoin has existed almost completely outside of those retailers.

Re:China Central Bank Said to Call Bitcoin Exchanges for Talks by drcode on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @03:59PM (#13602030)
> This is currently the main use case for Bitcoin.

While this is a reasonable possibility, there is very little hard data to confirm that the use of Bitcoin being used in a significant way to circumvent Chinese capital controls... the evidence for this is very circumstantial.

Re:China Central Bank Said to Call Bitcoin Exchanges for Talks by modeless on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @04:25PM (#13602269)
Additionally, news reports so far, and actions taken by exchanges, suggest that PBOC's main concerns have been fraud risks, security, leveraged trading, and volatility due to zero-fee trading. No mention of capital controls.

It's certainly possible that they are concerned about circumvention of capital controls too but that is speculation not supported by any evidence yet (e.g. public statements by PBOC or the exchanges they met with).

Re:China Central Bank Said to Call Bitcoin Exchanges for Talks by Animats on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @05:06PM (#13602629)
Forbes says it's being used that way.[1]

[1] http://www.forbes.com/sites/laurashin/2017/01/05/the-2-facto...

Re:China Central Bank Said to Call Bitcoin Exchanges for Talks by random_rr on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @05:18PM (#13602728)
Well... Lauren Shin says it's being used that way.

Please note that she is a Forbes Contributor - a blogger, in other words.

> Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are their own.

Re:China Central Bank Said to Call Bitcoin Exchanges for Talks by moomin on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @06:37PM (#13603275)
I'll observe that the number of capital control circumvention mechanisms for which there is hard evidence can be counted in zeros. If you can prove it, so can the government, and then they can either sue, lock you up or legislate, depending on mood. And then you're back to zero again.
Re:China Central Bank Said to Call Bitcoin Exchanges for Talks by rahimnathwani on Thursday February 09, 2017 @12:47AM (#13604958)
"anyone in China can take about $50K in yuan to Hong Kong once a month and exchange it for euros or dollars. (Sending all your relatives to Hong Kong once a month to do this is a thing.)"

You're not allowed to carry that much cash (in any currency) past customs in China. IIRC the limit is something under $10k USD.

"Buy Bitcoin in China with yuan, sell elsewhere for dollars and euros."

But you still need a willing counterparty. The only people who would be naturally long bitcoin and short RMB would be Bitcoin are miners, who need RMB to pay electricity bills :)

So if there were no China-based miners, I don't think this would work.

Re:China Central Bank Said to Call Bitcoin Exchanges for Talks by engenuity on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @06:09PM (#13603086)
I don't know a lot (or anything) about bitcoin, but I do know a lot about China, its capital flight issues, and the PBOC's policies.

Your first paragraph is riddled with so many errors and bad conclusions, that I can only assume your 2nd paragraph must be just as poorly reasoned and informed.

[dead]
Re:China Central Bank Said to Call Bitcoin Exchanges for Talks by rahimnathwani on Thursday February 09, 2017 @12:50AM (#13604969)
"Right, $50K/year, not $50K/month."

If a Chinese citizen wants to convert up to $50K/year, they don't need to leave the mainland to do it. They can just go to their local bank.

So it's unrelated to trips to Hong Kong.

engenuity's response may not have been polite, but at least he/she was attacking your message and not you personally. Your response (calling out the recency of their account and their level of karma) in an unnecessary ad hominem attack.