Re:Newzbin (paid usenet search engine) closes due to legal a...
by benologist on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @08:53PM
(#1359697)
Google linking to illegally distributed material is incidental - the only similarity is that TPB/etc linking to legally distributable material is also incidental.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Newzbin (paid usenet search engine) closes due to legal a...
by chc on Wednesday May 19, 2010 @12:22AM
(#1360100)
You're comparing Usenet to The Pirate Bay? One is one of the oldest communications standards on the Internet and the other one is The Pirate Bay.
Re:Newzbin (paid usenet search engine) closes due to legal a...
by aw3c2 on Wednesday May 19, 2010 @12:40AM
(#1360125)
He is comparing torrent indexing sites to usenet indexing sites.
Re:Newzbin (paid usenet search engine) closes due to legal a...
by chc on Wednesday May 19, 2010 @01:37AM
(#1360217)
Is there evidence that there was any effort on the part of Newzbin or its users to focus the site's resources on illegal material? My impression of the service was that it indexed a large swath of Usenet impartially. Compare this to The Pirate Bay, whose users ask it to track illegal content more often than not. Unless you have evidence that Newzbin specifically targeted illegal material, he is equating Usenet with pirated media.
Re:Newzbin (paid usenet search engine) closes due to legal a...
by benologist on Wednesday May 19, 2010 @02:17AM
(#1360265)
Well there's the bit where a court found them to be guilty of doing just that.
Then there's the bit where as a messageboard it's long been superceded by forums and other forms of communication.
Then there's the bit where according to wikipedia over 5 terabytes a day of binaries get posted, and although I have no evidence somehow I don't think that's linux isos.
Then there's popular culture which constantly touts it as some kind of exclusive club 'the man' mustn't learn about because that way it'll stay 'safe' to use.
Re:Newzbin (paid usenet search engine) closes due to legal a...
by chc on Wednesday May 19, 2010 @11:25AM
(#1361207)
A court did not find them guilty of doing just that. A court found them guilty of knowingly profiting from copyright infringement. If I sell off my grandfather's estate, which I know to include a fake Rolex, I would also have knowingly profited from copyright infringement, but I don't think you would say that an estate sale is also equivalent to The Pirate Bay.