Just speaking for me personally, I was musing on it long ago [0] and I'd like to suggest three starting points:
1. Trolling always means the user is, in some way, not sincere or not honest in their interactions.
2. Trolling is always about triggering or goading victims into a reaction.
3. Trolling is not the same as humor, trolling can incorporate humor, but only in a "mean-spirited" way.
[0] https://www.reddit.com/r/funny/comments/p7u3k/troll_level_ma...
Well, those aren't alternatives, I'm saying that "trolling" requires all three.
> Trump as the ultimate troll
You want to bring politics into this? Ah well, I guess people can minus-click the thread.
Whether Trump is a troll or not depends on whether he's telling the truth -- or thinks he is at the moment it comes out of his mouth. Personally, I don't think he's a troll, his internal dysfunction is on some other existential tier.
> as a way of antagonizing the virtue-signaling left. Of all the Republican candidates he was the most leftfield
I'm going to assume that "leftfield" is 100% sports-jargon and in no way a veiled back-reference to "the left" politically.
> Whether Trump is a troll or not depends on whether he's telling the truth
Does it, though? It could equally apply to someone who feigns ignorance of the truth. For example, someone starts talking about a topic. You're an expert in the topic but disagree with his assessment. You pretend not to be an expert and ask questions. He thinks he's helping you understand while in reality you are goading him into overstating his position and proving him wrong. There may be some deception as to your level of knowledge but the underlying argument isn't necessarily untrue.
Unintentional trolling would contradict that.
As I mentioned in the ancient link, there's no such thing, because I consider that a contradiction in terms, much like "accidental assassination" or "unperturbed terror". You only see the words together when the author is going for rhetorical effect:
> No matter how moronic, argumentative, or misinformed a person might be, they cannot be a troll if they are trying to be honest and their motives are straightforward.
There are many other unflattering labels you can use for the kind of person you describe, but "trolling" implies and requires intent.
> In this paper, similar to the latter studies, we adopt a definition of trolling that includes flaming, griefing, swearing, or personal attacks, including behavior outside the acceptable bounds defined by several community guidelines for discussion forums [22, 25, 35].
You may have missed part of the relevant section there.
Is this the definition you would use for "trolling behavior"? It's not what I was expecting, and greatly changes my understanding of what the study is looking at compared to the title.