Re:Why real time feedback is a terrible idea
by makerleader on Friday February 03, 2017 @04:18PM
(#13563416)
I totally agree with stepping back, analyzing for a period, and figuring out the best approach; I just think if a managers first inclination is to derive pleasure from harshly criticizing someone there is something really wrong with the environment/leadership/their personality.
Re:Why real time feedback is a terrible idea
by jevanish on Friday February 03, 2017 @07:51PM
(#13564827)
Cool. I think we're generally in agreement then. For many (most?), leadership is an unnatural act you have to learn, so it takes time not to shoot from the hip on this stuff. And for anyone, no matter how golden their heart, it's easy to get caught up in a moment if you don't do the step back you suggest.
The larger point is to encourage the step back and a broader discussion, and to share some of the data showing that people actually don't want piles of feedback on every little thing every day.
It's also the point to emphasize that waiting to have a real conversation about it is best no matter how polished you are. You can be a perfect communicator, and taking the time to hear their side, go over examples, and talk about next steps ensures the feedback is actually meaningful (i.e.- leads to positive change). Firing that off a note in a "Real Time Feedback" system does none of that.
I'll bet on the leader that picks their moments for feedback and is deliberate and detailed, over someone reliant on their exact eloquence in the moment every time.