News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rands in Repose: The Shop I Want by dkarl on Monday May 17, 2010 @07:38PM (#1355963)
All he wants is better salesmanship. He wants someone to tell him why he wants something so that he'll actually enjoy owning it. A desk becomes more than just a desk. Shaving cream becomes more than just shaving cream.

Looking for reasons to not just buy el-cheapo shaving cream. Is there anything out there worth spending a little money on?

The best shaving cream isn't worth spending money on until somebody sells you on it.

Here's another idea: if you don't get pleasure or a feeling of discernment out of your shaving cream, maybe you should accept that. If the Ikea desk makes you just as happy as the Stow Davis desk, maybe you should accept that, instead of yearning for a salesman to help you believe you have better taste. It's moralistic and a downer, but looking for ways to get more satisfaction out of your purchases is a sickness.

Example: I don't have a very sensitive palate for wine. Therefore, I don't spend much on wine and don't pretend to know anything about it. When my friends talk about wine, I sit back and wait for the subject to change. Part of me feels like I'm missing out, part of me feels like an inferior yuppie -- which I suppose I am. It would be so easy to fake it. Fooling myself would be almost as easy as fooling other people. I could read reviews of every wine I buy and parrot what they say about bananas, strawberries, and barnyards. I would enjoy myself immensely, and people would like me better because I would be more fun. High-end wines would provide another way of buying excitement and validation. I could transmit that excitement and validation to other people. I could even make them feel loved by my careful attention to the wine I served them. My conscience, my intellectual integrity, is the only thing holding me back from these benefits.

Wait, you say -- wouldn't the pleasure be genuine? Sure. It would. So why pass up an opportunity to manufacture pleasure? Aren't I just stealing happiness from everybody to gratify a moralistic urge that has no valid moral basis? If it's one kind of empty self-indulgence versus another, shouldn't I pick the one that provides happiness to myself and other people?

This is a serious question, and I can't claim to have an answer that is much better-founded than my simple engineer's (or prude's) instinct that there must be a catch. However, I can name a few things that would be wrong about it.

First, I would be financially supporting wine prices that could, for all I know, be completely fraudulent. Unless I can be confident I can tell the difference between a $12 wine a $60 wine, my spending $60 just creates an opportunity for unscrupulous folks to make money by overpricing wine. That might not hurt me, but it would hurt real connoisseurs.

Second, I suspect that I would get more pleasure out of real appreciation than out of an illusory appreciation, as my "appreciation" of wine would be. The excitement, validation, and pleasure in tasting would all be genuine, but the taste itself would not be stimulating. I would, at best, be imagining novel sensations based on the descriptions of people with more sensitive palates. Nothing would exceed my imagination. I would be investing time, thought, and money into a cognitively incestuous and sterile experience. Aesthetic masturbation, if you will. Wouldn't I be better off concentrating on areas where I have the capacity to be truly surprised and stimulated? Wouldn't Rands be better off ignoring desks and focusing his attention on something he has legitimate taste for, instead of asking a salesman to manufacture an illusory appreciation for a Stow Davis desk?

(After all, you've been exposed to various kinds of furniture all your life, and if you still need a pep talk from another person to care deeply about the widely admired qualities of a certain desk, then you're simply blind to it. It's okay. Everyone has domains of insight and domains of blindness, and to elevate wine and furniture over other domains is just snobbery.)

Third, you should be careful what you do with your money. My bank balance affects how much I invest in truly worthy causes. Every year I sign up for recurring charitable deductions from my paycheck. When I decide how much to sign up for for the next year, the state of my finances has an effect on how much I feel comfortable comitting to. I also lend money to friends and family when they need it; again, my bank balance affects how much I'm comfortable giving. Basically, I'm a selfish, risk-averse person, and my willingness to be altruistic is heavily dependent on my own security and comfort. It's easy to give away excess. Looking for expensive new ways to turn my excess into pleasure is another way of saying, "I'd better find something better to do with this money than give it to the EFF/Doctors Without Borders/<your favorite charity here>!" If you're really miserable and money is all you have going for you, then converting money into happiness should be your top priority (though buying stuff is probably not the best way.) If you're already reasonably happy, then go ahead and buy what you enjoy, but don't look at every expensive toy and think, "Oooooh, I want to learn how to appreciate THAT so I can enjoy BUYING and HAVING it!" You already know a million ways money can buy happiness; if you've exhausted all the ones that apply to you, then maybe you should spend the money on somebody else.

I know Rands is exploring this issue from the consumer side for the sake of working the sales side. That doesn't make it any better. If you wouldn't feel right doing it yourself, how could you feel right making money by persuading other people to do it?

Re:Rands in Repose: The Shop I Want by mquander on Monday May 17, 2010 @07:50PM (#1355982)
I totally agree. I'm absolutely with Rands here:

You can have an opinion. It sounds like work, but it’s really not. An opinion is not the definitive view or judgement regarding a thing; it’s you staring at that desk and saying, “You know, I like the look and the feel of those brass handles. I also like the drawers that squeak just a bit when you open them. It speaks to the character of the whole desk.”

It’s not that I want a Stow Davis desk, it’s that I want to find that desk. I want to go to seven different antique shops and spend a weekend developing an opinion about the state of antique desks. I want to find someone who knows the entire history of Stow Davis desks and won’t fucking shut up about them.

Half the fun of having an opinion is the quest to find one, but the everything problem remains. You don’t have the time to have an opinion about everything...

But then he makes this totally ridiculous leap:

...but someone has the time.

So what? What good is it if it's someone else's opinion? Why would you want someone else to feed you their opinion on shaving cream, even if they've got a really objectively great opinion? It's not as if it actually makes any goddamn difference what shaving cream you buy, unless you believe it does. Ditto for desks, and so on.

I have an opinion on lots of stuff like that, but it's because I'm an opinionated little fuck. I don't think it's really a state to aspire to. Rands, on the other hand, apparently values being this complicated, networked, shopping consuming machine, and to what end? I don't understand.

P.S. Rands, you could, you know, try different brands of shaving cream until you find one you dig, like a normal person.

Re:Rands in Repose: The Shop I Want by derefr on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @01:14AM (#1356585)
Er... nothing makes any difference. We die, and then everything we have done gets washed away by Alzheimer's, worms, and the rain. However, if we care about things—other people, for instance, but shaving cream's as good a thing to care about as any—then we can spend our lives happier for the choices we have made. Rands wants people to give him reasons to care about more things, so he can make more choices and therefore define himself more clearly. He's not asking for someone to pick the best shaving cream, and then just say "here, use this one, it has 10^23 utilons subjective to your experiential context"—he's asking for reasons to care about liking particular shaving creams at all. It turns out the best way to solicit those reasons—the dimensional parameters that define the space of shaving cream quality, so to speak—is to get someone to sell you a few particular creams, and explain why their "earning five stars on the Bugnatti face-feel scale" or "resisting incursive facial bacteria" facts are important. Those lessons learned, you can then pick your own shaving cream, "like a normal person"—but you'll know why, not just how, to choose.

The best analogy I can think of is to music. Have you ever met someone who just didn't care about music, at all? Didn't you feel like something was missing from their lives? Do you think you could get them to care about music by showing them a bunch of music-theoretical math and physics? Or would you just say "this is my favorite band; they do X and Y really well", and expect them to explore outward from there, now listening for other bands' Xs and Ys, and eventually forming their own opinions of what makes a good band?

Now, for "music", replace with every single possible other interesting thing in this world.

Re:Rands in Repose: The Shop I Want by mquander on Thursday May 20, 2010 @01:19AM (#1363307)
I appreciate what you're saying, and if you interpret Rands' post as some rational, utilitarian statement of preference in which he claims to actually care about learning the particular distinguishing virtues of shaving cream, and desks, and presumably a thousand other consumer goods, then I suppose I can't tell him he's wrong about his strategy.

Rather, I'd choose to be even more presumptuous, and tell him he's wrong about what he wants. I think that few people are genuinely destined to love careful research into what kind of socks you prefer at the moment and which coat hangers are the most durable. It's an awfully crowded and indistinct way of defining yourself. To the extent that people like doing those kinds of things, I think that they are easy escapes which tend to take the place of more ultimately fulfilling endeavors (I'm guilty of this.) I think that it's a dumb waste of time to find ways to spend even more effort on such tasks, providing marginal benefit, and yielding what I wager is only a brief satisfaction.

Re:Rands in Repose: The Shop I Want by PowerLlama on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @12:14AM (#1356449)
You're not taking into account that what he has now is just outright bad (in his opinion), or he just doesn't like the choices available to him. I've bought plenty of shitty products and have gone out looking for something better.

And you're also equating dollar value with quality and personal value, which isn't always the case. I've had plenty of wine lovers tell me which cheap wines taste the same as expensive ones, and spent enough time in garage sales and thrift shops looking for interesting things.

Sometimes a desk is more than just a desk.

Re:Rands in Repose: The Shop I Want by megablast on Monday May 17, 2010 @11:34PM (#1356365)
It looks like he wants the old days, where salespeople in shops new everything about a product. They new the customer by name, because they had been coming there since they were young. And there were only 5 fridge types anyway.

Unlike the present, were you walk into a computer shop and the seller doesn't even know the difference between dual core and dual processor.

Those days are gone.

Re:Rands in Repose: The Shop I Want by nickcampbell on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @12:19AM (#1356461)
It's not opinions that Rands or other consumers are looking for. What consumers are looking for is a story to tell. It's the story you tell to a friend about the new desk. Or, the ability to explain to a coworker about why this new shaving cream works way better than the old one. It's stories that people are buying and it's a story that Rands really wants.

A moment in a store with a salesman does not make the sale. It's the countless times he will get to tell the story that is valuable.

The cheap IKEA furniture is cheap, simple, well designed and functional. But almost everyone knows that story. The story of IKEA furniture is always how inexpensive it was. Not a great story and definitely not unique. A vintage desk or a high end pair of speakers however has a whole beautiful story behind it to tell. The rare wood, the kevlar drivers, the quality, the craftsmanship.

Ever ask anyone about where they got a cool vintage T-shirt they were wearing? You will usually get two stories. Either "I got it at a thrift store" which is boring. Or, hopefully you will get something like, "This? I got this Huey Lewis and the News shirt at my very first concert ever. It was 85 and my dad took me..." . They are both wearing the same shirt. The only difference is the story.

Re:Rands in Repose: The Shop I Want by jodrellblank on Monday May 17, 2010 @10:44PM (#1356235)
Second, I suspect that I would get more pleasure out of real appreciation than out of an illusory appreciation, as my "appreciation" of wine would be.

But if you did try to become a wine fanatic, you would train your palate and your ability to distinguish wines would actually increase, not just imaginatively increase, wouldn't it?

It's not literary criticism where you interpret what someone says and there's no right answer; wine does actually have taste and you can taste it yourself, without relying on an authority to tell you what it tastes like.

And anyway, why would you get more pleasure from real appreciation than illusory appreciation?

Wouldn't Rands be better off ignoring desks and focusing his attention on something he has legitimate taste for

If you follow the Barry Schwartz and Dan Gilbert TED talks, Rands would be better off if there was one shop and it stocked one shaving cream and didn't accept refunds.

my spending $60 just creates an opportunity for unscrupulous folks to make money by overpricing wine. That might not hurt me, but it would hurt real connoisseurs.

No no no, real connoisseurs who could tell the difference would be able to tell the wine was overpriced. And if there isn't really anything to wine tasting, then they wouldn't notice and therefore it wouldn't hurt them - it would, must, be what happens now. And in either case the sellers aren't unscrupulous folk, they are making money providing the exclusive expensive wine experience that connoisseurs will pay money for, even if the wine is nothing special.

It doesn't hurt art collectors to pay more for a painting when the painter turns out to have been the brother of Richard the Lionheart. That's the sort of thing that doesn't change the picture in the slightest but does make it more valuable art and the sort of thing art collectors want.

It's easy to give away excess. Looking for expensive new ways to turn my excess into pleasure is another way of saying, "I'd better find something better to do with this money than give it to the EFF/Doctors Without Borders

Unless you are an extremely frugal minimalist you already implicitly do spend money on things which do less for the greater good than a good charity, so arguing about quite where you draw the line to 'excess' is a bit irrelevant - you could likely afford a very fancy shaving foam and still have 'excess' enough to donate to charity, and it wouldn't take much change in income to enable you to afford an antique desk and still do the same.

Re:Rands in Repose: The Shop I Want by dkarl on Monday May 17, 2010 @11:17PM (#1356327)
real connoisseurs who could tell the difference would be able to tell the wine was overpriced

As long as people like that are the ones buying most $60 wine, then wine sellers have an incentive to be honest. If people like me are buying lots of $60 wine, then there's going to be lots of plonk selling for $60, forcing connoisseurs to be more careful and less adventurous.

Unless you are an extremely frugal minimalist you already implicitly do spend money on things which do less for the greater good than a good charity, so arguing about quite where you draw the line to 'excess' is a bit irrelevant

I may gladly give in to consumer desires, but I don't feel sad when my consumer lust is not excited. I don't send out a plea saying, "Somebody, please get me excited about shaving cream. I want to spend a lot on it and feel good about it." That's like a porn fiend who has satiated himself but remains at the computer looking through porn, trying to find something that will make him horny again. That goes beyond fulfilling desire; it's addiction.