News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rands in Repose: The Shop I Want by derefr on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @01:14AM (#1356585)
Er... nothing makes any difference. We die, and then everything we have done gets washed away by Alzheimer's, worms, and the rain. However, if we care about things—other people, for instance, but shaving cream's as good a thing to care about as any—then we can spend our lives happier for the choices we have made. Rands wants people to give him reasons to care about more things, so he can make more choices and therefore define himself more clearly. He's not asking for someone to pick the best shaving cream, and then just say "here, use this one, it has 10^23 utilons subjective to your experiential context"—he's asking for reasons to care about liking particular shaving creams at all. It turns out the best way to solicit those reasons—the dimensional parameters that define the space of shaving cream quality, so to speak—is to get someone to sell you a few particular creams, and explain why their "earning five stars on the Bugnatti face-feel scale" or "resisting incursive facial bacteria" facts are important. Those lessons learned, you can then pick your own shaving cream, "like a normal person"—but you'll know why, not just how, to choose.

The best analogy I can think of is to music. Have you ever met someone who just didn't care about music, at all? Didn't you feel like something was missing from their lives? Do you think you could get them to care about music by showing them a bunch of music-theoretical math and physics? Or would you just say "this is my favorite band; they do X and Y really well", and expect them to explore outward from there, now listening for other bands' Xs and Ys, and eventually forming their own opinions of what makes a good band?

Now, for "music", replace with every single possible other interesting thing in this world.

Re:Rands in Repose: The Shop I Want by mquander on Thursday May 20, 2010 @01:19AM (#1363307)
I appreciate what you're saying, and if you interpret Rands' post as some rational, utilitarian statement of preference in which he claims to actually care about learning the particular distinguishing virtues of shaving cream, and desks, and presumably a thousand other consumer goods, then I suppose I can't tell him he's wrong about his strategy.

Rather, I'd choose to be even more presumptuous, and tell him he's wrong about what he wants. I think that few people are genuinely destined to love careful research into what kind of socks you prefer at the moment and which coat hangers are the most durable. It's an awfully crowded and indistinct way of defining yourself. To the extent that people like doing those kinds of things, I think that they are easy escapes which tend to take the place of more ultimately fulfilling endeavors (I'm guilty of this.) I think that it's a dumb waste of time to find ways to spend even more effort on such tasks, providing marginal benefit, and yielding what I wager is only a brief satisfaction.