News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by gravypod on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:49AM (#13551960)
No matter how removed someone is from your field of expertise you should be able to consisely make a case for why you aren't at fault and why. You should also be able to demonstrate using basic logic that the simplest components of two source trees (something that is extremely basic) can show resemblance to another extremely basic component. For example the similarity of example code.

How many example source files have you downloaded that demonstrate a graphics library by drawing a cube. I bet they share a decent amount of similarity across most engines. That doesn't mean they are copies.

It is through logic like this that our courts are meant to function.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by Filligree on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:51AM (#13551976)
Why?

Why is there an assumption that you can explain anything to anyone? There is no law of nature stating that the maximum complexity anyone can invent is smaller than the complexity the average person can understand.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by gravypod on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:01PM (#13552082)
I'd say there are very few people who are doing things so out there that they cannot explain what they are doing.

We aren't that special. We aren't magical unicors who work in all corners of our galaxy. No we are programmers, PhDs, mechanics, engineers. Our jobs share a lot in common with each other and can be easily broken down to their base components.

That's the job of a programmer like Carmack. To break things down into their simplest form and represent them clearly and consisely.

Frankly for him it's exactly what he's paid to do.

> There is no law of nature stating that the maximum complexity anyone can invent is smaller than the complexity the average person can understand.

Unless you think you, or this hypothetical person, is so unbelievably smart that they can operate on a plane so far above that of the common man that they can't explain what they do up there. Then I can see how you can think that way. I personally don't belive that is the case.

We as programmers don't do that and very few people do. For example, lets ask this question:

How do you advocate for funding for the job you do? You need to market yourself. How do the people you market to market to their bosses?

It's not PhDs all the way down the same way it's not turtles all the way down. There is a simple, consise, and understandable explination for every activity that humanity has done since the beginning of time. Wheather I know how to formulate it is one thing but one must exist.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by abraae on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:40PM (#13552530)
Spoken like an intellectual (not an insult - an observation).

Could John Carmack explain binary space partitioning in an interesting way that made Joe Average feel like he got it? Most likely yes.

But would Joe Average really "get it"? Could he make a meaningful judgement as to whether some other piece of software implementing BSP was more or less a copy of some other piece? (just using BSP as an example - not a good one)

I sincerely doubt it. As the saying goes, a little knowledge is dangerous.

Look at the number of people who claim that global warming is a myth because they saw a snowstorm last week.

Its fashionable, and feels liberal, to claim that we're all much the same, but we're not. John Carmack is what many would call a genius, who can conceive of things that are simply beyond the ken of the bulk of society.

Sure those people have other skills and virtues - but epecting them to make rational decisions about complex technical matters while two opposing sets of attorneys bark at them is...ridiculous.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by bshimmin on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:50PM (#13552655)
a little knowledge is dangerous

The quote from Alexander Pope is actually "A little learning is a dangerous thing". People often get this wrong, which is probably a tiny bit ironic.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by abraae on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:56PM (#13552735)
Touché! I stand mortified and corrected.
Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by marcosdumay on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:32PM (#13552413)
> I'd say there are very few people who are doing things so out there that they cannot explain what they are doing.

So, those very few people out there are basically fucked up with no recourse? How few are they?

Anyway, yep, we are normal people. Normal people that spent a decade or four learning something very specialized. Now, why should we take for granted that people that never learned anything in our specialty can understand anything we know in a week?

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by ctdonath on Thursday February 02, 2017 @01:14PM (#13552903)
That's the job of a programmer like Carmack. To break things down into their simplest form and represent them clearly and consisely.

To machines and to fellow experts, yes - but not to the general population, and not to people who may be persuaded to jail him, or fine him at tremendous expense, if he doesn't adequately explain it while someone else is being paid big money to obfuscate his explanation.

This isn't advertising or fundraising. This isn't helping people understand who have an ulterior motive for understanding. This is a hostile environment trying to convict him, an environment that leverages ignorance.

And the complex topic at hand isn't sufficiently explained to ordinary people in a matter of hours, he'd have to put them thru a complete "high school thru post-doctoral education" process and bring them up in the vicinity of his level as an "among the greatest of all time in the field". When learning about a particular topic, I was directed to keep notes in a safe-deposit box precisely so if I was ever criminally charged for related reasons, I could literally put the entire jury thru the full education on the subject - and that would take about a month of courtroom time. I can't imagine Carmack's lawyer arranging to put a jury of commoners thru arithmetic-to-post-doctoral-rendering to "explain what he's doing".

I've heard it said that the simple (in rules) game of Go can be so complex that it takes mastery of seventh-level skills just to comprehend what ninth-level skills are doing. You can't just take someone who barely learned the rules and explain, in a short time, what the grandmasters are doing to win.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by dagss on Thursday February 02, 2017 @01:20PM (#13552972)
The point is not whether it can be understood. The point is that if two sides both make convincing arguments, how do you pick which one is correct? Without knowing the subject matter yourself, as a human one will usually fall back to confidence and charisma. Your brain unnoticeably substitutes "which one is correct" (which is hard / impossible to answer at a dumbed down level) with "who do I trust" which is ruled by charisma and confidence more than anything else.

The wrong projects get funded all the time. In the legal system one should do better.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by deong on Thursday February 02, 2017 @01:39PM (#13553153)
The problem is that there's an adversary who, in practice, is not attempting to lead the jury to the correct conclusion, but lead them to a conviction. And that adversary will be equally able to explain in an understandable way why, despite your explanation to the contrary, you in fact are guilty of the charges.

The system works when juries are able to differentiate between expert witnesses, and that may very well require more expertise than just applying everyday common knowledge to two competing expositions.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by seanp2k2 on Friday February 03, 2017 @06:15AM (#13559047)
In this case, I do believe that Carmack is so intelligent and so far removed from a random citizen when it comes to graphics engines that it would take probably thousands of hours for a normal person to actually understand what was happening here, if they even cared, which they would not. "So let's start with a voxel"... [much time passes] "so for the sake of making the rendering pipeline efficient, its common to ..."

Without any sort of grasp on the range of solutions for the piece of this system in question, I find it absurd that a normal citizen would be tasked with ruling on this.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by RobertoG on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:17PM (#13552238)
My personal impression is that when people of average intelligence can't understand something is because the concepts that make that thing are outside their expertise, not because they are not able to. They are missing the parts, so, understanding the total is impossible.

People of exceptional intelligence is able to learn new things and think through a problems easily, but what makes a real difference is if you already own the building blocks of the new idea or not. A transpiration vs. inspiration kind of thing.

Anyway, I think the argument is that you should be judge by average and impartial persons (a jury or a judge) because, otherwise, you are not in a egalitarian society.

Somebody could argue that an egalitarian society is not efficient, but history teach us where that finish: there is always people on the ready to declare themselves above the others. So we have to aim to some kind of balance.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by fjdlwlv on Thursday February 02, 2017 @01:11PM (#13552873)
You think the average person could meaningfully review graphics rendering code?
Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by EdHominem on Thursday February 02, 2017 @02:29PM (#13553689)
That's not the part they most need to be able to do. They merely need to be able to understand an argument without getting distracted by tricks.

The actual analysis of the code is something that they could then listen to expert findings about.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by RobertoG on Thursday February 02, 2017 @06:54PM (#13556250)
I'm saying that you can teach the average person to swim if you teach them all the proper techniques, in the proper order, before the competition.

I'm not saying that you can do the average person perform like a world-class champion.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by jjawssd on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:05PM (#13552119)
Because the verdict boils down to something simple: guilty or not guilty. To get to that conclusion requires the distillation of complex circumstances into a simple binary outcome.
Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by ctdonath on Thursday February 02, 2017 @01:19PM (#13552961)
The problem is that making a mistake on that outcome isn't a matter of disinterest or lost sales, it can result in destroying lives.
Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by Retric on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:03PM (#13552101)
Do you have an actual example of this?

Contracts get really complex in the same way programs get complex. But, juries have mediated contract disputes for a very long time.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by geofft on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:20PM (#13552272)
Only because judges get to tell the jury what certain phrases in the contract mean, because judges are experts at understand contract complexity. We don't actually expect juries to learn contract law; the judge interprets the relevant parts of the contract for the jury, and tells the jury to decide whether it was broken.
Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by Retric on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:25PM (#13552328)
Meaning what? Jury's can decide complex issues if there is a neutral expert on complex topics?

If anything that sounds like a complaint about expert witnesses not juries.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by maxlybbert on Thursday February 02, 2017 @02:07PM (#13553469)
A judge can appoint a special master for situations like this. For instance, Lawrence Lessig's role in the Microsoft antitrust trial. However, as far as I know, juries don't have the option of asking a special master's opinion, because there is a big risk juries would just defer to the special master instead of actually trying to judge the case.
Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by erikbye on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:05PM (#13552113)
Average Joe does not know what source code is, nor is he able to tell one piece of source code or one programming language apart from another, it is all gibberish to probably the majority of the jury.

Hell, a few years back most Americans did not know that McDonald's was unhealthy, they had to be told this...

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by bshimmin on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:20PM (#13552270)
Let me share a conversation I had with a family friend a bit ago:

she peers over my shoulder at my monitor, which has (let's say) a screenful of some Ruby on Rails app in Sublime Text

Her: "Is that... code?"

Me: "Yep, that's right. It's the code for a web site."

Her: "Wow, your code is so beautiful!"

Me (surprised): "Really? What makes you say that?"

Her: "All those lovely colours! I didn't know you were so artistic - did you do the colours yourself?"

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by erikbye on Friday February 03, 2017 @03:02AM (#13558458)
Right.

Actually had something similar happen. An acquaintance of mine glanced at a monitor with Sublime and Monokai theme (don't like it, just happened to be on) and went "Wow, that looks really heavy [as in complicated], cool colors too!" Obviously it was nothing "heavy", just code, but all code would have looked complicated to him.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by DiabloD3 on Thursday February 02, 2017 @04:39PM (#13554946)
That is terrifying.
Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by josu on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:26PM (#13552344)
To further your point, the expert had to use Harry Potter as an analogy. In my opinion, analogies should be banned from courtrooms. They are fine for casual discussions, but they are often misleading.
Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by omegaham on Thursday February 02, 2017 @01:01PM (#13552783)
I disagree, as precedent is hugely important in interpreting the law. You link the existing situation to precedent with analogy.
Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by erikbye on Friday February 03, 2017 @03:55AM (#13558639)
Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by abraae on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:44PM (#13552583)
Slugulus Eructo!
Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by nitwit005 on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:07PM (#13552149)
How much time does it take to understand something with sufficient depth to make a sound judgement?

It would be nice if the answer could somehow always be a short expert witness testimony, but the reality seems to be that in some areas it's months or years of study.

In your example, you'd have to explain what source code is, what a graphics library is, methods of representing and comparing source code, and how the applicable laws are supposed to function. Sure, you could probably give them a vague impression in a short time, but not enough to decide something complex.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by toufka on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:20PM (#13552280)
That's precisely why the experts are asked their opinion. And a jury takes that opinion into account.

"Dr. Soandso, do you believe, based on your experience, that such an action would constitute a flagrant abuse? Of a kind that is unprecedented? And such an action would damage the reputation of many, you say? And were such an action to take place it would cause harm to the industry for decades?"

The jury needn't be an expert to make sound judgements. Expert witnesses do actually need to socially regarded as experts, and lawyers on both sides of this adversarial system should do everything they can to undermine those experts who are not impartial. And if each player in that system does their job well a layman should certainly be able to make a reasonably founded decision.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by sqeaky on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:54PM (#13552703)
But then aren't you just expecting the Jury to trust the expert?

How does the Jury tell two experts apart, while one says Yes and the other No?

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by fjdlwlv on Thursday February 02, 2017 @01:12PM (#13552887)
Which one has a nicer looking face is more honest.
Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by nothrabannosir on Thursday February 02, 2017 @01:40PM (#13553169)
This thread is now so far removed from the original article, it has gone full circle.

The article is, literally, about this not working.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by pedasmith on Thursday February 02, 2017 @03:25PM (#13554300)
Not how it works; that's leading the witness, and just because you are an expert in one field (comparing code) doesn't mean you are an expert in another (assessing the value).

I've actually been in this exact situation as an expert witness. The defendant had written code in language "A", sold it, then wrote similar code in language "B". The question was whether code "B" had been written while looking at code "A".

The answer was yes, and I could prove it. Code often has a history that's apparent (e.g., you throw in an if statement to catch a weird input, and you add a comment like "fixing the wheelabrator-fry issue from december"). New code won't have the same history, and therefore should not have the same structure. If it does, the code must have been copied.

That's especially true if there are dated comments in the code.

What I wasn't asked was the economic value of the copying. Other experts handled that; I was just an expert in the two languages.

BTW: the final assessed value was much less than the cost of the trial. And I felt sorry for the defendant; most of the code had not been copied.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by angersock on Thursday February 02, 2017 @06:27PM (#13556029)
New code won't have the same history, and therefore should not have the same structure. If it does, the code must have been copied.

This seems a little weird--what if the author just remembers to, for example, make sure and handle those edge cases when starting again?

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by pedasmith on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:09PM (#13561300)
With a word for word identical comment, including a space before the final period?
Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by grovegames on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:20PM (#13552277)
If this were true of human nature, we would not have creationism.
Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by sqeaky on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:23PM (#13552308)
> demonstrate using basic logic that the simplest components of two source trees (something that is extremely basic)

If you think that is "extremely basic" I think you may be overestimating how poorly 1 in 12 people understand computer related concepts. I suspect it is far more, but I am biased.

Before software development I worked tech support. I have heard some nightmarish misunderstandings. I have had people who literally thought files in the computer were tiny pieces of paper (and just magnified or something, this person's view was not logically coherent). When explained otherwise many met my explanation with conspiracy theories, disbeliefs, explanation of the physical impossibility of solid state transistors and sometimes, the very best of times, interest and a promise to do extra research on the the off chance I might be right.

I have conversed with many, perhaps hundreds who literally could not understand the concept of a file. They knew that inside the magic box was 1s and 0s. In general they even had the vaguest idea that electrons or magnetism somehow stored those 1s and 0s, but the idea they could be organized into a into units smaller and more discrete that "the magic box" was so alien and unacceptable to their world view that they could not or would not accept it. Many simply didn't want to know, but a few brave souls tried and sometimes got themselves in to great trouble needing many help tickets to undo the results of their learning experiments.

There were several people who thought there computers were terminals to some server somewhere and could not accept that their information was stored locally. No amount of explanations that the C: Drive was a device in their computer could shake the notion that Earthlink or whoever else I was working for had the files. These people wanted so badly to believe their lives where so simple (or whatever they wanted to believe) that they could not possibly have a device the size of a laptop that was powerful to hold the contents of a bookshelf filled with novels and reference material. Maybe these people were just too confused about where facebook (myspace back then) posts went and could not compare that to where ms word documents went.

Then there were people who could never learn to navigate file tree. People, hundreds and hundreds of people, who could save and open documents, but when they accidentally clicked and dragged a document lost the moved document forever despite it just being in the wrong subfolder. These sad people would often have 10 versions of a document sometimes in the same folder with subtlety different names and they could never quite understand what they were looking when presented with the list of files produced by their misguided instruction. At least one such person is in my immediate family, I no longer do tech support for only because she has medical conditions that prevent computer use entirely, but after 15 or so years she never gained and understanding of file tree.

You want to explain to a group of 12 with no guarantee of prior knowledge how two files trees can be alike, yet not be so similar as to be copyright infringement. I commend you for your effort, I consider it a heroic task, and entirely possible if the 12 people all take to your explanation. I think it is more likely to fail entirely for some amount of those people.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by Retric on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:58PM (#13552744)
The simple approach would be to take pictures of several houses that look very similar and show they are not copies of each other. Have an architect show why some elements where similar between houses because of similar choices and constraints.

Then show how what the two programs do are similar in they both sit between a game and computer hardware. Further, demonstrating they both share similarities with some other piece of software that does similar things.

Finally, show several core differences between each software.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by sqeaky on Thursday February 02, 2017 @01:04PM (#13552813)
Sticking with my examples of people who fundamentally cannot understand files, how do you explain the core differences of two file managers?

I presume the VR software is an order of magnitude more complex than files and file managers.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by Retric on Thursday February 02, 2017 @01:11PM (#13552881)
They don't need to understand files, just the connection with [code] > computers running a program vs. [architectural drawings] > people making a house.

Architects don't build houses they design them in the same way computer architects don't build programs they design them. The analogy is a little fiddly as programmers > compilers also works like Architects > construction workers. But the line of thinking is not that hard to follow.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by sqeaky on Thursday February 02, 2017 @01:32PM (#13553094)
It seems you are asserting that people who don't understand anything about the core concept can make reasonable decisions based on contrived analogies. Perhaps you are right, but I don't think so.

When both sides put forward equally convincing analogies and few, if any, of the jurors know what is actually going on then how do they choose which analogy to believe?

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by Retric on Thursday February 02, 2017 @01:53PM (#13553303)
That argument sounds better in the abstract. In practice both sides get to cross examine these experts and they are going to attack the weak points in the arguments.

Another consideration is in very close cases a random outcome is not necessarily a bad thing. Programmers like binary logic, but court cases are impacted by things like what someone thinks someone else was thinking. Being 'correct' in every case is less important for society than avoiding outright corruption and lawlessness.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by sqeaky on Thursday February 02, 2017 @03:52PM (#13554535)
I agree that cross examination helps. I agree lawlessness is bad. However, what you you are proposing is pseudo-random solutions instead of lawlessness, which doesn't seem much better. Picking any subset of trials and saying it is okay for them to be wrong could mean setting wrong precedent for years to come. It can also mean bad outcomes and suffering for many and disproportionately poor people.

If the jurors don't understand the fundamentals of what they are deciding how will they interpret cross-examinations? Certainly not on the merit of the argument, because they simply can't.

If it just comes down to who can sound more confident while making their side of the argument then justice goes to whoever can afford the best lawyers. Which largely seems to match the system we have.

It is not a very good but it is better than lawlessness, but only just so.

Though we get more nuanced each time, I fear our debate has started running in circles. Thank you for making reconsidering some of my opinions.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by Retric on Thursday February 02, 2017 @04:51PM (#13555075)
I mean if a group of experts might chose A 55% of the time and B 45% of the time then a 50/50 random outcome is not a real issue. A few places have elections where in case a tie they do a coin flip. The important thing is to remove bias not get extreme accuracy.

As to our court cases being biased for the wealthy that's a little more systemic than just highly technical cases. Even in clear cut cases having a competent legal team can make a massive difference, IMO the overall system was designed that way.

The problem is how to change things. If doctors made up the jurors in malpractice cases you would see much stronger bias. I would much rather have random people than wall street bankers judging wall street bankers or even worse FBI agents judging other FBI agents.

That said, I am open to the idea of civil suits allowing for more restrictive juries if both sides agree. If nothing else it may allow for shorter trials. Which is something I only considered though this conversation. So thanks.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by sqeaky on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:33PM (#13555528)
Clearly we aren't running in circles!

I agree that those coinflip cases exist, but if cases are so close a coinflips (or elections) can decide them then why do sums like $500 million depend on them as in the article?

A system which promotes charisma instead of factual accuracy doesn/t just result in muddy grey areas where things were already close. Things like climate change, which pretty much all experts agree on, are grey areas to many people. Charisma is how we get trump instead of any other politician.

Every year that passes I am less in favor of the idea of democracy than I was the year before. The aggregate of a great many untrained people is generally stupid. Its just better than any system reliant on experts we have devised so far. This seems to be caused by the corruption of our method of choosing experts. Once we a get a reliable system that empowers experts I will be behind wholeheartedly.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by seanp2k2 on Friday February 03, 2017 @06:22AM (#13559071)
The problem in your last sentence is the trick, one which humanity has yet to solve in any sort of sustainable way. Maybe strong AI can finally save us from ourselves.
Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by sqeaky on Friday February 03, 2017 @11:40AM (#13561035)
Even that that pushes the trust problem one step further. Presuming making a Benevolent and Obedient AI leader is possible, how do we trust the people making it?

If western industry creates the super AI and somehow Google, MS, Facebook, Amazon, Apple and western society in general trust it why should China and Baidu?