Donald J. Trump is calling for a
total and complete shutdown
of Muslims entering the United States
until our country's representatives
can figure out what is going on. [1]
That's why the current order has set duration of 90 days, and it's announced that subsequent immigration from the affected seven countries will be allowed, subject to tougher vetting.[1] http://www.cbsnews.com/news/donald-trump-calls-for-total-and... - first hit in Google search.
Trump had no idea what he was doing when he made that quote, has no idea now. What better idea in 90 days? Cancel this order? Meanwhile his actions are increasing the risks to the US. This is all about posturing and victimising a minority that's easy to demonize and nothing to do with security.
That's not what the order states, and I SEVERELY doubt you have read it.
http://on.wsj.com/2kGbSdj so we are all on the same page here. There is literally one country mentioned in the document - that country is Syria. The other references are to other documents that group countries that I can't find.
I think if you read the executive order, you'll have much better framing for what it actually says, and why.
The narrative is that America is under siege, and that we are in grave danger of terrorist attack. The only way to stop is to take extreme executive action, and to frame our national security policy around fighting ISIS.
Consider, as an example, the hasty nature of this executive order. It went into effect immediately, and refugees previously approved for entry had that approval revoked. Was there really something so urgent that happened on Thurs Jan 23rd that required immediate action? This is a similar strategy used by the Bush Administration, where the government uses the spectre of terrorism to justify actions completely disproportionate to the threat.
The question I would ask apologists of the travel ban is this: what was the real, imminent threat that required such a hasty executive order to be made on Jan 23rd? Is it a real threat, or is it political theatre for another purpose?
This is not a ban on refugees from Muslim countries. It's neither a ban, nor targeting refugees, nor limited to Muslim countries.
It's a 90 day suspension of immigration from countries described by 8 U.S.C. 1187(a)(12), specifically:
* Iraq and Syria
* Governments which have repeatedly provided support of acts of international terrorism
* Countries or areas of concern designated by the Secretary of Homeland Security
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/27/us/politics/refugee-musli...
Rudy Giuliani has now claimed on Fox News that he helped design the restrictions as a legally valid form of Trump's "Muslim ban":
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2017/01/29/tr...
Fox News host Jeanine Pirro asked Giuliani whether the ban had anything to do with religion.
“How did the president decide the seven countries?” she asked. “Okay, talk to me.”
“I'll tell you the whole history of it,” Giuliani responded eagerly. “So when [Trump] first announced it, he said, 'Muslim ban.' He called me up. He said, 'Put a commission together. Show me the right way to do it legally.' "
And it should be noted that the list of countries of concern to which Trump's order applies came from the Obama administration.
https://www.dhs.gov/news/2016/02/18/dhs-announces-further-tr...
Why is that claim factually incorrect?
If you had said "eliminate" terrorism I would agree it's incorrect. But not allowing foreigners into the US is certainly a way to combat terrorism. Most of the terror attacks in the US have been by foreigners. Not allowing them to enter the US would help combat terrorism.
NOTE: I'm not arguing this is actually a good idea. I'm just stating that I disagree with you claim that it's factually incorrect.
" Most of the terror attacks in the US have been by foreigners"
You sure about that ?
http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/12/mass-shootings-m...And if it would make you feel better, I could just slightly tweak my comment to say "most terror attacks [by number of Americans killed] have been by foreigners".
Trump/Bannon present the following frame: we can combat terrorism by banning refugees from Muslim countries. This claim is factually incorrect, and moreover it is an attempt to set up an "other" group (Muslims) as an enemy. Keep in mind Trumps unapologetic claim on the campaign trail:
By proposing "specific ammendments", Musk says the framework as correct, but the details are wrong. In fact, the opposite is the case: the framework is wrong, as well as the details. The entire order should be rescinded, without qualification.Musk and other SV commentators should know better than this, and not lend their credibility to un-American actions by the administration.