News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by ryandamm on Monday January 30, 2017 @01:32AM (#13519104)
I fear this is the warning shot across the bow of those tech executives who supported this president. First, they come for your conferences. Then, your H1B visa-holding employees. Then...?

Innovation thrives on freedom. Freedom of expression, freedom of movement, freedom of markets. And tech, in its best form, is about freedom, rather than market-capture and rent-seeking. Needless to say, none of these recent developments are good.

Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by lkrubner on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:46AM (#13519333)
Innovation thrives on the rule of law, independent courts and neutral arbiters of contracts, habeas corpus and due process, the right to a lawyer, and the right to uncoerced testimony.

Consider Jethro Tull, the farmer. In 1700 he was 26 and he was taking over the family farm. He hired some local hands to seed the fields that spring. As had happened for thousands of years, the workers took bags of seed and cast handfuls on the ground. Jethro Tull became angry, because there were patches of ground that had too much seed, and other patches of ground that had too little seed. He went over to the workers and asked them to be more careful. But they proceeded as before. Tull became more angry, and went to speak with them again. But they still ignored him, and kept doing their work in the traditional manner, as they had since they were children, and as had their parents before them, and their parents before that. Tull was in a rage, but saw he could not change how the workers did their work. Instead, he decided to build a machine that would plant seeds at regular intervals. This was the beginning of the Agricultural Revolution.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jethro_Tull_(agriculturist)

But now ask, why did this happen in 1700, and not in 1680 or 1660 or 1500, for that matter? Was Tull simply smarter than any farmer that had ever lived before that time? Or was their a new legal system on his side?

In the time of Tull's father, England was still burning witches. The last great spasm of irrational fear and witch burning swept over Britain in the mid 1600s. But then Britain passed the Bill Of Rights, in 1688. Now everyone had the right to a fair trial, and a right to a lawyer, and no one could be tortured into confessing to a crime, such as witchcraft. And Tull belonged to the first generation of entrepreneurs in history knowing that they could depend on the rule of law -- the government could not take arbitrary action against him, but was constrained by its own processes. Therefore Tull could shatter tradition, and do completely new things, without the threat of being burned as a witch.

I could cite an endless number of examples. Galileo made brilliant discoveries in an illiberal nation, and was put under house arrest, Newtown made discoveries in a nation of laws, and he became a national hero. Simply knowing that laws will be enforced fairly defeats a lot of the kinds of evil scheming that spring up under authoritarian regimes.

"Freedom" is an empty word. When talking about the kinds of environments that cultivate innovation, it's best to try to be specific about that environment. History teach us the raw ingredients: the rule of law, fair and independent courts, habeas corpus and due process, the right to a lawyer, the right to uncoerced testimony.

Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by onion2k on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:02AM (#13519373)
That would be a compelling line of reasoning if Jethro Tull had actually invented the seed drill, but he didn't. He perfected the design but the device had been around Europe for 150 years before Tull's version, and in China for 2000 years before that. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seed_drill
Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by lkrubner on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:09AM (#13519395)
The same argument applies even more strongly. If a technology is known, but fails to come into widespread use until there is a legal system that protects people from persecution, then the new legal system clearly played a large role in emancipating that technology from obscurity.

Do I need to list every example? I was assuming they were well known.

Consider what France lost by driving out the Huguenots. Consider what England gained by offering protection to the Jews.

Consider this famous summary by Voltaire:

"Although the Episcopalian and the Presbyterian are the two main sects in Great Britain, all others are welcome there and live pretty comfortably together, though most of their preachers detest one another almost as cordially as a Jansenist damns a Jesuit. Go into the Exchange in London, that place more venerable than many a court, and you will see representatives of all the nations assembled there for the profit of mankind. There the Jew, the Mahometan, and the Christian deal with one another as if they were of the same religion and reserve the name of infidel for those who go bankrupt. There the Presbyterian trusts the Anabaptist, and the Church of England man accepts the promise of the Quaker. On leaving these peaceable and free assemblies, some go to the synagogue, others in search of a drink; this man is on the way to be baptized in a great tub in the name of the Father, by the Son, to the Holy Ghost; that man is having the foreskin of his son cut off, and a Hebraic formula mumbled over the child that he himself can make nothing of; these others are going to their church to await the inspiration of God with their hats on; and all are satisfied."

That such a great market could come into existence was thanks to the legal system set up in Britain during its revolutionary period, which ended with the passage of the Bill Of Rights that gave most British citizens the basic rights we nowadays assume.

Also consider what Britain lost, 90 years later, when Parliament suddenly asserted that the Bill Of Rights was not a universal set of human rights, but a specific set of liberties given to people living in the British Isles, but not applying to the Colonies of North America. The people living in the Colonies of North America were so outraged by this that they rebelled against British rule and broke ties with the British government.

Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by igravious on Monday January 30, 2017 @07:05AM (#13520463)
> Do I need to list every example? I was assuming they were well known.

That's not an argument, that's snark. I agree with onion2k that you do not provide a compelling line of reasoning. You provide a just-so narrative but not a line of reasoning. Sure those events may have happened in chronological order but that does not in any way imply causation.

Innovation and invention have both preceded and post-dated any notionally enlightened legal landscape.

Also, the dire situation for Catholics and the existence of discriminatory laws on the books within the British Isles puts paid to Voltaire's chummy story of a motley crew worshipping before the altar of Mammon, likewise the Bill of Rights.

You paint a good picture but I remain unconvinced.

Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by caminante on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:15AM (#13519419)
I understand your point, though, I don't see it as diminishing Tull's contributions or lkrubner's story's allure.
Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by adrianN on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:10AM (#13519403)
I'm not very convinced by your argument. I don't see how the rule of law affected Tull. I think it's more important that he was influenced by the rise of scientific thinking during the Enlightenment and sought more efficient means of agriculture using the scientific method. Also, the Wikipedia says that the seed drill was known in Europe for about a hundred years before Tull refined it and it took another one hundred and fifty years before it was in widespread use. The correlation with the rule of law seems pretty weak to me.
Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by lkrubner on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:22AM (#13519440)
You assume the outcome when you write "the rise of scientific thinking during the Enlightenment". Why didn't the Enlightenment happen in Italy? Why was Galileo arrested whereas Newton became a national hero? The regime of human rights was very different in Italy versus England, and that influenced where the Enlightenment happened. Giordano Bruno was burned at the stake, whereas Edmond Halley had the liberty needed to study comets, and even predict when Halley's Comet would return.
Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by igravious on Monday January 30, 2017 @07:15AM (#13520529)
Why didn't the Enlightenment happen in Italy?

The Enlightenment did happen in Italy.

> Why was Galileo arrested whereas Newton became a national hero?

Because of the Jesuits, and not for the reason you imply. Read Infinitesimal by Alexander Amir.

Galileo was a national hero in Italy, in fact he was an enormous figure across the whole of Europe. Giodarno Bruno was burned at the stake in Rome in 1600, Edward Wightman (for heresy) in jolly olde England in 1612.

Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by jakeogh on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:23AM (#13519445)
Property rights. It was Tull's land and "they still ignored him" so he fired them.
Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by gm-conspiracy on Monday January 30, 2017 @08:40AM (#13521017)
How about mp3.coms "Beam-It' offering:

https://cs.stanford.edu/people/eroberts/cs181/projects/1999-...

The Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) has sued both MP3.com and Napster on behalf of the record labels that they represent (Sony, BMG, EMI, Universal, and Warner). They are keen to point out thought that they are not against MP3 technology, but against the illegal use of it. MP3.com is being sued for their Beam-it online service which allows users to insert a CD into their disc drive, and then download those songs in mp3 format from MP3.com's database of over 80,000 CD's. The RIAA sued them claiming that the company was violating copyright laws by allowing users to download copyright-protected songs. On April 28th, New York District Court Judge Jed Rakoff sided in favor of the RIAA, ruling that MP3.com was liable for copyright infringement. On May 4th, a federal court also sided with the RIAA. According to Cary Sherman, general counsel for the RIAA, "The foundation on which these services are built is an unauthorized digital archive of the most valuable copyrighted recordings in the world. Frankly, it's astonishing that a publicly-traded company would behave so recklessly."

Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by ryandamm on Monday January 30, 2017 @11:24AM (#13522463)
Regardless of whether or not Jethro Tull is a perfect example, the larger point about rule of law is absolutely correct. Any catchphrase or byword can be co-opted, none more so than 'freedom.' Rule of law is a much better way to think about this, so thank you.

It's also generically true that having a good legal system is a prerequisite for a stable economy and good growth, not just innovation. I recall an article in, I think, the Economist that contrated mango farming in Haiti from the Dominican Republic -- same climate, same island, huge difference in productivity. Because in DR, farmers believed they would benefit from their hard work. In Haiti, unclear land title and corrupt courts meant a productive mango orchard could be confiscated by those in power, so the farmers had no incentive to invest in their own farms' productivity. Subsistence farming becomes the norm, and everyone loses.

Not sure why both examples that spring to mind are agricultural, but there you go.

Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by wahern on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:26PM (#13525659)
> Innovation thrives on the rule of law, independent courts and neutral arbiters of contracts, habeas corpus and due process, the right to a lawyer, and the right to uncoerced testimony.

Those are some of the bare requirements, just like agriculture is a requirement for civilization. Thrive isn't really the right word to describe subsistence living.

Also, it's not even clear whether they're requirements. We should be wary about confusing correlation with causation. The UK enjoys those things only at the pleasure of their elected Parliament. How long do you think those rights would have been maintained in America without a written constitution? Maybe the real requirements are more obscure cultural phenomena, and that there exists a wider universe of systems that could equally undergird widespread wealth creation in the presence of those same cultural forces. Don't discount the path dependent behavior of political evolution.

Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by chx on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:45AM (#13519733)
And yet, people book Uber still. Unfathomable.
Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by ryandamm on Monday January 30, 2017 @11:30AM (#13522528)
Well, to be fair, it's because someone's handing out free money in the form of subsidized rides. The fact that hailing a taxi is more expensive (nevermind less convenient) is a strong argument when the consumer is making a choice.

Wrapped in that argument is the obvious idea that Uber is burning investor money to capture the market, but you can't expect consumers to protest by paying more. That's what's so insidious about market capture; everyone is behaving rationally in their own self interest, but the outcome can become monopolistic, with increasing returns to the monopolist.

That's why it's traditionally been the role of the government to break up monopolies, because the market won't sort itself out. It's just that today's digital monopolies smell a little different, and the appetite for government intervention is lower than it used to be (perhaps because we don't remember catastrophic failings of the market quite as sharply as we used to -- 401ks being decimated is one thing, but bread lines and starvation are another).

So yeah, I think Uber's potentially dangerous. But I use it. Definitely some mental frisson, but I've spent time trying to fathom it and this is the best mental gymnastics I can manage.

Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by FabHK on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:18PM (#13524607)
Agreed. As I like to say, Uber screws their drivers (already, but wait for autonomous cars...), Uber screws their competition (subsidised), and their investors, too.

For now, they don't screw their customers, but let's see what happens when they've gotten to monopoly market share.

I've also argued before that it is somewhat of a natural monopoly insofar as the biggest player will typically have more cars nearer you, and their app will offer the shortest waiting time. To combat that, one could regulate taxis like a public utility, and require that all providers submit their data to a register that collates the data and lists all cars and all riders centrally. Then one could have different companies and different apps compete on a level playing field.

Some people disagree with that. I think it boils down to the definition of monopoly (barriers to entry? decreasing marginal cost? network effect? ...?), but at the end of the day definitions don't really matter -- what matters is a better outcome for consumers, and I fear regulation is required for that at some point.

Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by chx on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:35PM (#13525265)
> For now, they don't screw their customers

Dismantling the rule of law in my book counts as screwing up the entire society.

Re:Tripling Down Against USA Conference Hosting by briandear on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:52AM (#13520035)
How many H1s are from Somalia or the Sudan?

I agree with your basic points, but on a practical level, how much does this actually affect things for H1 companies? We are talking 7 countries very few of which produce many H1 employees.