News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by candiodari on Sunday January 29, 2017 @07:59PM (#13517876)
Because it works so well in China ?

Also Ahmadinejad has a master in civil engineering, a PhD in transportation engineering, and has taught as a professor (apparently he has returned to that job).

Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by bumblebeard on Sunday January 29, 2017 @08:03PM (#13517893)
The Soviet Union had a bunch of engineers in their government too and they made all kinds of stupid decisions anyway. I don't think the composition of the government matters as much as its structure and as governments go I think the US has a decent one.

I think the problem is more who our politicians are listening to then what they actually believe themselves. Banning lobbying would probably do a lot more than just trying to elect a bunch of scientists and engineers.

Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by _delirium on Sunday January 29, 2017 @08:39PM (#13518036)
The engineers may have even exacerbated some things, especially in the 1950s-70s, as they were more optimistic about rapid advances in (what was then called) cybernetic control than turned out to be warranted. It seemed within short term reach to have rational, data-driven optimization of large sections of the economy, but neither the technology, nor theory, nor data was there at the time to make that actually work. It's an interesting question what would've turned out differently if expectations of rapid advances turned out to be accurate, and they had 1960s USSR-level political resources paired with something closer to today's level of data-collection and ML technology. Central economic planning, but run by an engineering-bureaucracy with the resources of 2017 Google.
Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by _yosefk on Sunday January 29, 2017 @08:48PM (#13518069)
You mean today's computers can assign prices to existing products and decide which new products to develop better than the market? The iPhone coming out of a neural network which isn't close to passing even a pale shadow of the Turing test (which a lot of humans pass who certainly cannot develop new products or set prices better than the market)? I wouldn't put my money on it.

(BTW Botvinnik, the first Soviet chess champion, was trying to push his (weaker than competition) chess-playing program as a basis for running the entire Soviet economy (he explained the weakness of his program for chess by it being more general than the competition; it apparently did not occur to him however that the fact that it lost to other machines and of course to people - this was 1990 - could perhaps mean it might run the economy somewhat worse than say a person. He was an engineer.))

As to electing engineers - let's put it this way: all else being equal, I'd rather be ruled by an EXPERIENCED ex-engineer (not just a guy with a degree) with a track record of achieving something, for which people who worked with them can vouch, than an ex-lawyer or an ex-journalist. But "engineer" by itself is not even a certificate of basic sanity, let alone the ability to lead someone somewhere other than the abyss, and for this HN's comment section provides ample evidence on a daily basis.

Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by _delirium on Sunday January 29, 2017 @08:50PM (#13518079)
I'm not betting my labor vouchers either for or against it, just an interesting thought experiment. Some of the technical problems with 1960s cybernetics are solved now, especially for more defined tasks. The USSR had huge problems getting to work things that would now be called "supply-chain optimization" and similar and are now routinely done, in a pretty centrally planned style, at large vertically integrated companies with complex logistics. This kind of stuff just didn't work at the time at the scale Soviet planners hoped to use it (scales like "optimize agricultural production in the whole USSR"), and when people tried to use it it produced bad results. I do agree that how to switch production into new sectors and products and how not to have a terrible bureaucracy capture all these decisions is a different, probably more difficult question though, certainly having some logistics optimization tools that work isn't solving the full picture (it's just better than having those problems and also having logistics optimization tools that don't work).
Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by _yosefk on Sunday January 29, 2017 @09:02PM (#13518129)
There's a huge difference between a vertically integrated company competing for customers and vendors and the entire economy of a country, IMO. One evidence is that large companies keep ossifying and failing to adapt all the time which means the economy needs more than one giant company to move forward. A new Google needs a way to tell the state/the giant computer/whatever, "you're wrong, search works badly and we can do better." It's very hard to do that if the giant computer is running everything and effectively decides what you do (and it cannot run the economy if it cannot decide who does what, or at least what projects are funded and which aren't.)

Also the USSR didn't just have problems optimizing supply chains. It had a problem deciding what to make. You couldn't buy woolen sweaters so you bought woolen socks and made sweaters from the woolen threads making up the sock (yes, I fucking participated in this fuckery). How is a giant neural network going to figure out how many socks and sweaters people want better than demand affecting prices affecting production, even if I grant you the assumption that the problem of managing the socks supply chain is nailed today?

Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by _delirium on Sunday January 29, 2017 @09:05PM (#13518141)
What, A/B testing not good enough for you? Please rate how you liked these two socks, this will be taken into account in order to serve you better.
Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by _yosefk on Sunday January 29, 2017 @09:33PM (#13518247)
I hear you, I just think you're a lot like that Soviet cybernetician [1], meaning that you think you're very close to the technology of that ever-elusive tomorrow, but you aren't :-) Of course it's not really fair to say that since you qualified your statements, it just sounded good and I can't miss an opportunity to fire a cheap shot at the AI/big data bubble :-)

[1] Nobody was called that as cybernetics was declared "a servant of Imperialism", I guess nominally because automating away jobs hurts workers or something, which is one reason the USSR never produced particularly good computing machinery. But I get whom you refer to.

Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by reality_czech on Sunday January 29, 2017 @09:28PM (#13518232)
You are missing the plot completely if you think the USSR failed because of a lack of computing power. The incentives at every level of the communist system were misaligned. It was all about loyalty, not embarrassing the higher-ups, and not rocking the boat. Working too hard, or pointing out a flaw in the system that embarrassed your boss, were horrible things to do in the USSR. That's why there were shortages of even basic items like bread, where the supply was easy to predict. It's why a lot of things that got built, got built extremely poorly, like cars. And eventually, it's why Chernobyl happened, as well as many other nuclear disasters you never heard about in the Urals.
Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by twoodfin on Sunday January 29, 2017 @08:54PM (#13518100)
How would you ban lobbying consistent with the First Amendment?
Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by guest-speaker-4 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @11:42PM (#13518741)
Yes. Adding a certain monoculture of persons is tantamount to "more people with green eyes would help." There are many types of intelligences, experiences, wisdom and values besides analytical, especially social.

I do think we need some fairer, structured, open reevaluation of certain laws like US commercial code, income tax and fixed monetary fines which harm the poor and benefit the rich, whereas income-/balance-sheet-based fines (ie Finland)

Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by icebraining on Sunday January 29, 2017 @08:16PM (#13517939)
About a third of the PMs here in Portugal were also engineers, yet we're not exactly topping the charts of the EU (at least, not the good ones).

As trivia, the current UN secretary-general - one of our former PMs - is a Physics and Electrical Engineering graduate.

Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by analog31 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @08:12PM (#13517926)
In my view, the entire education process in China is ideological from the git go. Techies in China just happen to be more likely to be groomed for government positions.

I suspect that non-Western countries have different preferences for what disciplines to study. For instance, they probably don't have much use for degrees in US law or European art history. STEM subjects happen to be more portable across borders, and can be turned into a job that can pay off more quickly -- a practical issue when you can't fall back on family money.

Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by chrischen on Sunday January 29, 2017 @08:00PM (#13517885)
Is it not working well in China, or even Iran?
Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by woofyman on Sunday January 29, 2017 @08:16PM (#13517937)
Iran is a Theocracy and Authoritarian and China is Authoritarian. So I'd say, not so good.
Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by chrischen on Monday January 30, 2017 @07:05AM (#13520459)
If by authoritarian you mean that the government has all authority, the same holds for any stable government, including the US's.

There are democratic procedures in China, even if it doesn't extend to every person. As an American you've most likely been indoctrinated to the American flavor of democracy, but even here our votes aren't all equal, as evidenced by the election of Trump despite having fewer popular votes (effectively disenfranchising some American voters).

American democracy is only as perfect or democratic as can be given the constraints in its ability to amend itself (American government was designed specifically to move slowly and prevent concentration of power). It would be fallacious to think that America has the perfect representative governing system. The end goal is to serve the people, and while the government of China may be different, given that the American model isn't perfect, it means there's room for alternative systems to potentially serve the interest of its people in a better way.

If you look at the efficacy of China's government, it's done pretty well objectively in lifting its population out of poverty. As much as US criticizes other governments, you have to realize the US openly admits its own citizens come first, which means you can't really take its criticisms seriously as in the best interest of its target.

Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by mastazi on Sunday January 29, 2017 @09:37PM (#13518263)
I think the parent comment was sarcastic.
Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by syshum on Sunday January 29, 2017 @08:22PM (#13517965)
>>Iran is a Theocracy and Authoritarian

Thanks to the CIA

>>China is Authoritarian.

Yes but I would argue they are making large strides in freedom, clearly they have a LONG way to go but you have to see the changes in both the government and the culture.

Is this improvement a result of STEM leaders? Is America's decline in this area also a result of a regression in our Leaders? America used to have Inventors, Businessmen, even scientists as leaders.

Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by mistermann on Sunday January 29, 2017 @08:48PM (#13518070)
Just this comment light grey because of downvotes? Why would that be?
Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by candiodari on Sunday January 29, 2017 @08:02PM (#13517889)
If you ask some Chinese, they're unlikely to be happy with the results. Just look at just how horrible smog is in Beijing. How they're destroying the savings of the Chinese people. The total and completely endemic corruption ...
Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by pen2l on Sunday January 29, 2017 @08:07PM (#13517905)
> Just look at just how horrible smog is in Beijing.

Huh? Have you looked at it recently? Beijing has made incredible strides in solving air pollution problems. They turned around the situation quickly to pretty decent results -- give them some more time and I'm sure they'll do even better.

China is not doing that bad. And I think one of the reasons why is in fact that high amount of STEM-educated folks in the politburo.

Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by Eridrus on Sunday January 29, 2017 @08:19PM (#13517949)
They did let it get pretty bad though, I was only there once in 2008 after the games and it was already pretty crazy back then.
Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by pen2l on Sunday January 29, 2017 @10:57PM (#13518520)
It was pretty bad around 2008. Now, 2017, it's not perfect but it's much, much better. They're on the right track.

Separately, I want to say: judging per capita they're not doing bad.

Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by mistermann on Sunday January 29, 2017 @08:50PM (#13518078)
As was most any country going through their industrialization phase. And China has gone from a third world country to second biggest economy in 20 or so years.
Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by caidh on Sunday January 29, 2017 @08:32PM (#13518006)
I think electing people from a wider range of backgrounds (instead of mostly lawyers) would be advantageous. Having some scientists, teachers, and many other educated professions, who can share their diverse perspectives with their other elected peers would be beneficial.
Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by peter303 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @09:11PM (#13518172)
In most parts of Asia there is strong societal and family pressure for males to major in STEM. Colleges oblige by renaming some subjects like economics and business and trades engineering. Then articles come out how the West is losing the STEM defree race to Asia. They are, but not as bad as it looks to these naming conventions.
Re:Urge President Trump to give scientists a seat at the table by Al-Khwarizmi on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:15AM (#13519223)
You're being ironic, but of course it does work well in China. It is an authoritarian country (not the STEM minister's fault) but it's doing remarkably well in almost every other respect.