News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Black market Blackphones get sent a kill message that bri... by sqldba on Sunday January 29, 2017 @10:22AM (#13514460)
What are they meant to do?

They build a secure phone. It gets ripped off by the manufacturer and resold by anonymous eBay people who can install whatever backdoors on the phone. Then the people using them are being snooped on - exactly what they don't want in the first place.

Bricking the phones is the right thing to do.

Re:Black market Blackphones get sent a kill message that bri... by pavel_lishin on Sunday January 29, 2017 @11:45AM (#13514960)
You can notify the user that their phone is not a legitimate product and is likely insecure without completely crippling it in the process.
Re:Black market Blackphones get sent a kill message that bri... by sjwright on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:04PM (#13516254)
And allow the user ongoing use of a pirated copy of their Silent OS software? That's generous.

(It's also not Silent Circle's fault if the counterfeit devices were sold with a locked bootloader, precluding the installation of another Android distro.)

Re:Black market Blackphones get sent a kill message that bri... by sjwright on Sunday January 29, 2017 @08:40PM (#13518038)
Receiving downvotes. Would be interested in an actual response.

If someone was selling laptops with a pirated copy of Windows on it and a Windows update recognized the unlicensed install, causing the laptop to be non-functional, would that be any different?

Remember, the maker of these dodgy laptops has locked the bios so that you can't reinstall a genuine operating system...

Re:Black market Blackphones get sent a kill message that bri... by chipperyman573 on Sunday January 29, 2017 @09:20PM (#13518212)
It isn't like you're buying a used laptop from someone on Craigslist, the people buying these phones were intentionally mislead to believe that they were buying a brand new (in a shrinkwrapped box) phone from an authorized retailer. If bestbuy sold windows laptops, advertised that it came with a valid Windows licence and they turned out to be lying, should Microsoft brick their laptops?
Re:Black market Blackphones get sent a kill message that bri... by sjwright on Sunday January 29, 2017 @09:58PM (#13518329)
Buying a counterfeit product on Ebay is exactly like buying a used laptop from someone on Craigslist, save for the buyer's perception of the seller. I don't see how the appearance of the counterfeit product, or the ignorance of the buyer, or the mainstream-ness of the seller is at all relevant here.

To complete your laptop analogy, this "new" laptop from Best Buy turned out to be goods ripped off the assembly line at the Dell factory before the unit had its Windows OEM license assigned or paid for. The software is unlicensed and therefore not genuine. It is not for Microsoft to offer sympathy and a blind eye, they are well within their rights to identify counterfeit installations of Windows and disable them. The remedy is for Best Buy to offer the customer a full refund.

Re:Black market Blackphones get sent a kill message that bri... by sjwright on Sunday January 29, 2017 @11:46PM (#13518755)
Let me put it another way. Forget hardware for a moment. The purchaser of these counterfeit Blackphones thought they were buying a software license for Silent OS. In reality it is pirated software. And not just garden variety downloaded-with-bittorrent-for-free piracy but rather software piracy as a profitable business model.

Silent Circle doesn't owe these consumers anything and are well within their rights to have all of their software completely self-destruct. They don't owe these consumers a robust mechanism to install an AOSP distro. They don't owe these consumers a bootable device. They don't owe these consumers a discount on a genuine device.

The only correct resolution is for the scam victims to receive a refund from the seller.

Re:Black market Blackphones get sent a kill message that bri... by trome on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:47AM (#13519743)
Whoa whoa whoa, Silent OS is based on Android, incorporating many GPLv2 and other FLOSS software. They may have done some minor hardening & UI changes, but beyond that the value of Silent OS is the apps they have built for calling & texting securely.

I could see stopping service on those apps, but bricking the baseband is a step too far, as you lose 911 access and Silent Circle almost certainly had no part in the baseband firmware development and is not a rightsholder to it.

Re:Black market Blackphones get sent a kill message that bri... by sjwright on Monday January 30, 2017 @07:58AM (#13520749)
Let's suppose one of the proprietary software components is a special secure bootloader. If Silent Circle disabled that one component, as they would be rightfully allowed to do, the phone is a brick.

I should also point out the claim that the baseband was intentionally bricked is unsubstantiated. We don't know if that's actually happening. Or if it's happening, we don't know if it's intentional.

The percentage of proprietary software on the phone — be it five percent or fifty — is orthogonal to the point.

Re:Black market Blackphones get sent a kill message that bri... by mindslight on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:00PM (#13515042)
They're supposed to not have this capability, if they actually built a secure phone!
Re:Black market Blackphones get sent a kill message that bri... by StavrosK on Sunday January 29, 2017 @05:29PM (#13517173)
What, the capability to install updates? So you'd be fine with a secure phone that the vendor could never update?
Re:Black market Blackphones get sent a kill message that bri... by mindslight on Sunday January 29, 2017 @06:22PM (#13517447)
The vendor shouldn't be able to push an update, no. And to the extent that this update was pulled by users without a diff/sanity check/etc, then that constitutes a de facto push. In any case, any update should be completely revertible (which doesn't prevent against data leaks from hostile code, but does prevent against denial of service).

This type of attack is just a test case that any truly secure device has to defend against. I'm not advocating a specific mechanism of avoiding this behavior, because there's obviously work to be done here to come up with a better mechanism than "every user audits every line of source before installing". It's just that this design work has to be done - "security" based on trusting a company is easy, and doesn't differ appreciably from what say Apple already provides.

Re:Black market Blackphones get sent a kill message that bri... by sjwright on Monday January 30, 2017 @12:08AM (#13518842)
Your demand is impossible. Any software update mechanism relies upon trusting the software vendor.^ The only thing you can ever hope for is that the update mechanism is capable of trusting that the update has not been tampered with in transit.

^ with the debatable exception of software distributed in source code form in a language you're able to audit and compile yourself, though you'd still be vulnerable to cleverly concealed exploits

Re:Black market Blackphones get sent a kill message that bri... by otikik on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:30PM (#13515734)
But they did not build the ones which are bricked - they are counterfeit.
Re:Black market Blackphones get sent a kill message that bri... by timthelion on Sunday January 29, 2017 @03:27PM (#13516396)
This is such a bad faith reply. Of course they also have the capability to brick or backdore the ones which are not coutnerfeit as well.
Re:Black market Blackphones get sent a kill message that bri... by Nomentatus on Sunday January 29, 2017 @07:10PM (#13517678)
This is a worry - a disgruntled-but-trusted employee decides might use this fine tool you built for a reasonable purpose from using it to brick every phone you've ever made on his-or-her way out your door.