To complete your laptop analogy, this "new" laptop from Best Buy turned out to be goods ripped off the assembly line at the Dell factory before the unit had its Windows OEM license assigned or paid for. The software is unlicensed and therefore not genuine. It is not for Microsoft to offer sympathy and a blind eye, they are well within their rights to identify counterfeit installations of Windows and disable them. The remedy is for Best Buy to offer the customer a full refund.
Silent Circle doesn't owe these consumers anything and are well within their rights to have all of their software completely self-destruct. They don't owe these consumers a robust mechanism to install an AOSP distro. They don't owe these consumers a bootable device. They don't owe these consumers a discount on a genuine device.
The only correct resolution is for the scam victims to receive a refund from the seller.
I could see stopping service on those apps, but bricking the baseband is a step too far, as you lose 911 access and Silent Circle almost certainly had no part in the baseband firmware development and is not a rightsholder to it.
I should also point out the claim that the baseband was intentionally bricked is unsubstantiated. We don't know if that's actually happening. Or if it's happening, we don't know if it's intentional.
The percentage of proprietary software on the phone — be it five percent or fifty — is orthogonal to the point.