News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Resources for electronic engineers and hobbyists by Animats on Saturday January 28, 2017 @05:27PM (#13509857)
The T-962 and its clones out of the box have temperature so uneven that it can scorch the center of a board while reflowing OK an inch away from the center. With various mods [1] it's marginally usable. I've used TechShop's unmodified clone unit (melted the solder mask at board center and scorched the FR4 substrate) and a used modified Puhui unit (after careful setting of a suitable heating curve, acceptable.) With new firmware, the cooling fan is run slowly during the heating phase, which stirs the hot air and reduces the hot spot problem. You have to pay about $3000 to get a reflow oven that Just Works, unfortunately. The good ones are true convection ovens with uniform air temperature.

KiCAD is not bad. The schematic drawing part is mostly OK. The schematic symbol and footprint editors are poor draw programs, and the library management is painful, but once you figure out all the quirks, usable.

Board layout is strange. There are really two board layout programs, one for OpenGL and one for non-OpenGL, and they have different features, some of which are completely irrelevant to the display. You can switch back and forth on the fly. There used to be an auto-router, but due to an IP problem (the author of the auto-router worked for a company that sold auto-routers) it's been deprecated. Manual routing has a lot of computer assistance, and is usable but touchy. The output end, with Gerber and drill files, seems to work fine; I've had boards fabbed by two vendors with no problems.

[1] https://github.com/UnifiedEngineering/T-962-improvements

Re:Resources for electronic engineers and hobbyists by TaylorAlexander on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:39PM (#13515368)
Interesting about the T-962 problems. I've been using my T-962A out of the box on PCBs for a few years and have had no problems. I get even soldering with no scorching and no cold solder spots either.

Perhaps the larger T-962 is afflicted by problems the T-962A does not have? Or the variability in design is significant? Or my PCBs are all small enough to avoid problems?

But thanks for the link and comments about KiCAD. I'll look in to those improvements.

Re:Resources for electronic engineers and hobbyists by abakker on Sunday January 29, 2017 @02:29AM (#13512825)
If you are already making your own PCBs, making your own kiln with a thermocouple, PID, and heating element ought to be no sweat. Just buy a handful of softbricks, cut them with a saw, and put them together. I've made kilns like this that go up to 1950F. 300 - 400 should be really easy.
Re:Resources for electronic engineers and hobbyists by Animats on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @03:56PM (#13545069)
It's not about getting it hot enough.

Surface mount soldering requires a careful temperature profile. You first preheat to about 50C below the melting point of solder for about two minutes. Then, the temperature is raised to above the reflow point and held there for about 20 seconds, which is when the soldering takes place. It's easy to damage the components at this point; many components have a maximum temperature tolerance of only 30 seconds at reflow temperature.[1] Then there's a cool-down period. There are ramp rate limitations - heating up too fast causes solvent "pops" in the flux, and heating up too slowly cooks the components. Cooling too fast causes cracks in the solder; cooling too slowly cooks the components. A brick kiln would have too much thermal mass for all those controlled temperature changes.

Once it's all tuned and controlled properly, it works great as a cheap production process. The commercial systems work like a hamburger cooker at Burger King - there's a chain conveyor and several zones of different temperature through which the product passes. Once one of those ovens is warmed up and stabilized, it produces consistent results. It's doing this on one-offs that's hard.

Leaded soldering is about 2x more tolerant of temperature variations than lead-free.

[1] http://www.latticesemi.com/~/media/LatticeSemi/Documents/App...

Re:Resources for electronic engineers and hobbyists by TaylorAlexander on Sunday January 29, 2017 @12:41PM (#13515385)
It is significantly easier to hit buy it now than it is to construct a functional temperature controlled oven.

People who want to DIY often modify toaster ovens, but I haven't heard of anyone construction their own heating chamber as you've described.

Note that portability is a concern for me, since I move often.