News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Time to Take a Stand by jowiar on Saturday January 28, 2017 @01:58PM (#13508061)
This is meaningless grandstanding until:

1) YC voted Thiel off the island 2) YC establishes a policy of "take money from Thiel and you are toxic to us"

Anyone in a position of power who took a look at Trump and didn't recoil with disgust needs to be exiled from civil society.

Re:Time to Take a Stand by SirensOfTitan on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:21PM (#13508285)
> Anyone in a position of power who took a look at Trump and didn't recoil with disgust needs to be exiled from civil society.

And this well represents the leftist-elitistic-rhetoric that drove so many to vote for Trump (HRC's "deplorables" comment).

Five year olds say "I told you so," adults find reasonable pathways forward in difficult situations.

People voted for and supported Trump for a variety of reasons, let's not generalize them all into one block like his administration is doing to Muslims.

Re:Time to Take a Stand by CalChris on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:56PM (#13508665)
Adults usually tell five year olds I told you so after having already told them.

Republican voters had many choices in their primary. Cruz, Carson, Christie, Huckabee, ... were just as bad. So your variety of reasons isn't very convincing. At a certain point, you have to take responsibility for your vote. Hand waving it away with a variety of reasons isn't fooling anyone.

Re:Time to Take a Stand by concinds on Saturday January 28, 2017 @03:20PM (#13508918)
> you have to take responsibility for your vote

You're not advocating "responsibility". You're saying Trump supporters are morally defective, and when they refuse that label, you say: "see! not only are you morally flawed, but you won't even admit it! proves my point!"

Is it hard to understand that Trump supporters vote for what they think is morally just and right, just like you, and not for evil, because they're evil?

Re:Time to Take a Stand by CalChris on Saturday January 28, 2017 @03:32PM (#13509015)
Actually, I am advocating responsibility. That's why I used that word when I called out his hand waving with a variety of reasons. Moreover, when you say what they think is morally just and right it's pretty much the same.

At a certain point, you have to accept responsibility. Trump is your guy and he is doing your work.

I suppose you need to understand that y'all went way over the line with Trump and that we're not going to be nice about it.

Re:Time to Take a Stand by concinds on Saturday January 28, 2017 @05:11PM (#13509768)
> I suppose you need to understand that y'all went way over the line with Trump and that we're not going to be nice about it.

Don't include me in that. I'm not even American.

"We're not going to be nice about it" is once again pretty vindictive. Is that a threat?

Re:Time to Take a Stand by CalChris on Saturday January 28, 2017 @06:26PM (#13510275)
You're not very good at this.
Re:Time to Take a Stand by concinds on Saturday January 28, 2017 @09:37PM (#13511504)
Explain.
Re:Time to Take a Stand by jowiar on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:43PM (#13508526)
Perhaps I wasn't clear enough with "position of power". I wasn't talking about "James Wilson, truck driver in Madison" or "Allison Smith, bartender in Columbus".

It's the folks who single-handed lot have power to shape the world. Thiel can grab a friendly dinner with the greatest threat to humanity on Monday, and yet Sam Altman will gladly have lunch with him on Tuesday and joke about his "friends" as though nothing happened?

Re:Time to Take a Stand by concinds on Saturday January 28, 2017 @03:12PM (#13508842)
> the greatest threat to humanity

Objectively ridiculous. Davos disagrees[0], and geopolitical experts are utterly nonplussed by Trump (Stratfor, Geopolitical Futures). What 22 year old journalism majors decry as "a systemic threat to the world order" is just seen by geopolitical observers as an interesting gambit that may pay off big. Take what they say about Trump and Taiwan[1], NATO, torture (Trump said yesterday that Mattis was in charge, and if Mattis doesn't believe in torture, he gets to override Trump's orders). Your hysteria is unfounded.

[0]: http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/the-biggest-risks...

[1]: https://geopoliticalfutures.com/trump-taiwan-and-an-uproar/

Re:Time to Take a Stand by SirensOfTitan on Saturday January 28, 2017 @03:04PM (#13508759)
> Perhaps I wasn't clear enough with "position of power". I wasn't talking about "James Wilson, truck driver in Madison" or "Allison Smith, bartender in Columbus".

I suppose I don't really see much of a rhetorical difference. Proposing that we exile people who disagree with you is pretty gross to me. It doesn't matter you constrained yourself to only punishing the 'powerful'.

> Thiel can grab a friendly dinner with the greatest threat to humanity on Monday

This just sounds hyperbolic. Care to back this ridiculous statement?

> and yet Sam Altman will gladly have lunch with him on Tuesday and joke about his "friends" as though nothing happened?

People are multifaceted. As much as you'd like to reduce people down to single words or ideas, they're not that simple.

Re:Time to Take a Stand by geofft on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:26PM (#13508349)
Five-year-olds don't commit genocide. Five-year-olds don't become tyrants. Five-year-olds don't deport people. Five-year-olds might say "I told you so," but they have a far better track record at the things that matter than adults. Maybe we should take a lesson from them.
Re:Time to Take a Stand by SirensOfTitan on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:38PM (#13508467)
I find your comment a bit bizarre. You ignored the point of my entire comment, instead deciding to focus on a meaningless portion of my metaphor and apply it to an equally meaningless point about how humans ought to be.

This comment becomes even more bizarre whenever my comment was about acceptance of everyone, including Trump supporters, which is in line with your tao of five year old here.

Re:Time to Take a Stand by geofft on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:59PM (#13508700)
Five-year-olds don't feel compelled to accept everyone. They love everyone, yes, but when someone hurts them, they cry and fight back, they don't say "Hm, how can I work together with this person like an adult."

The inclination to treat unreasonable people as if they're reasonable is a major and easily exploited failure of adulthood. Plenty of Trump supporters are reasonable. Peter Thiel is not.

Every five-year-old knows a dozen stories about a good king with an evil counselor, and how the king would have been better off getting rid of the counselor.

Re:Time to Take a Stand by qwertyuiop924 on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:04PM (#13508095)
>Anyone in a position of power who took a look at Trump and didn't recoil with disgust needs to be exiled from civil society.

I don't like Trump, but fighting him isn't worth going against the very principles we fight for.

People have a right to their beliefs, even if their beliefs are stupid. If not, than what kind of country are we?

Re:Time to Take a Stand by ebola1717 on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:22PM (#13508289)
Thiel donated $1.25 MILLION to the Trump campaign. This isn't holding him accountable for his "beliefs" or even his "speech" - this is holding him accountable for helping to cause this mess we're in.
Re:Time to Take a Stand by qwertyuiop924 on Saturday January 28, 2017 @03:32PM (#13509011)
For the third time, that's different from being exiled from civil society.
Re:Time to Take a Stand by ihsw on Saturday January 28, 2017 @04:19PM (#13509424)
He's fixing the mess we're in.
Re:Time to Take a Stand by qwertyuiop924 on Saturday January 28, 2017 @04:46PM (#13509591)
I disagree...
Re:Time to Take a Stand by MusaTheRedGuard on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:10PM (#13508155)
People have a right to their beliefs, and those beliefs sometimes have strong social consequences.
Re:Time to Take a Stand by yks on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:23PM (#13508298)
DJT and his associates hint that only a subset of the population have a right to their beliefs, others should keep their mouths shut. That seems like a problem worth going against and it may become acute rather sooner than later.
Re:Time to Take a Stand by fictioncircle on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:25PM (#13508328)
> People have a right to their beliefs, even if their beliefs are stupid. If not, than what kind of country are we?

When the person's actions are directly and publicly detrimental to the business interests, the investor/backer/employee is at odds with the rest of the group and yeah at that point its not just a belief but a question of the self-interest of the business being at odds with one of its investor/employee/backers.

Let us be honest here, Thiel is also backing a man that has no trouble firing people who aren't Yesmen. If that is the sort of standard he wants applied to other people, it should apply to him as well.

There comes up a point when the pile of problems extends simply beyond belief but realized action in the real world that directly impacts other people. It is at that point, action is always taken in any situation. Please do not simply call this a 'belief' at this point when Thiel's goals and the related actions are realized in the manner he desired.

Re:Time to Take a Stand by qwertyuiop924 on Saturday January 28, 2017 @03:26PM (#13508970)
That's different from saying he should be exiled from civil society.
Re:Time to Take a Stand by cobralibre on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:42PM (#13508511)
> People have a right to their beliefs, even if their beliefs are stupid. If not, than what kind of country are we?

Politics is a process of conflict and negotiation between varied, competing interests. In a liberal democracy, "people have a right to their beliefs" is the starting point for that process, not the endpoint.

Re:Time to Take a Stand by qwertyuiop924 on Saturday January 28, 2017 @03:24PM (#13508953)
Yes, but it's a starting point we shouldn't loose sight of.
Re:Time to Take a Stand by kasey_junk on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:15PM (#13508203)
I'm not sure of any nominal principle that says we have to do business with, work for or to invite to things people who behave abhorrently.

That Thiel can get a table at a restaurant in SV proves all the talk about changing the world tech leaders do is so much nonsense.

Re:Time to Take a Stand by concinds on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:29PM (#13508371)
Do you believe Christian bakeries should be forced to bake cakes for gay customers?

You and plenty of people in this thread seem to confuse "behave" and "say".

"While Trump's"enemies take him literally not seriously & friends seriously not literally", the wise looks at his acts & acts only. No words." --NNTaleb

Ostracizing others for their words is incredibly immature, petty, and vindictive. And ironically, ostracizing is an act, not words, so it does expose your character.

Re:Time to Take a Stand by kasey_junk on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:45PM (#13508539)
> Do you believe Christian bakeries should be forced to bake cakes for gay customers?

I don't believe Christian bakeries should be forced to bake cakes for anyone. I do believe that if they want the protections of the legal system, they must follow the same protections for others, even if they find them abhorrent. A principled stand against those protections does not mean they get to do that at no cost to themselves.

If "person who supports an abhorrent ideology" is a protected class in SV restaurant service law, I rescind my call to ban him from getting a table, and change it to "let him eat alone".

> Ostracizing others for their words is incredibly immature, petty, and vindictive. And ironically, ostracizing is an act, not words, so it does expose your character.

No its not. Its a basic component of all human interactions. We all choose to associate or not with people based on their beliefs. Those associations are powerful multipliers for both success and failure in this world. That there is not a penalty for unwanted behavior in a given society is not a mark of value.

Finally, giving money to someone is also an act, regardless of what the Supreme Court says. Thiel has exposed his character, he is not welcome at my house and I won't work for him.

Re:Time to Take a Stand by concinds on Saturday January 28, 2017 @03:30PM (#13509002)
> If "person who supports an abhorrent ideology" is a protected class in SV restaurant service law, I rescind my call to ban him from getting a table, and change it to "let him eat alone".

Political ideologies are legally protected against discrimination in California.

But even if they weren't, why judge someone by their beliefs? The only reason you would is if you think support for Trump is a moral defect, with no exceptions. In other words you're not against him because of his political beliefs, but because of your (not universal) beliefs about what is moral and what isn't.

> We all choose to associate or not with people based on their beliefs.

Disagree. Most people judge others on social status and personal character, neither of which have any link to political ideologies or personal beliefs.

> he is not welcome at my house and I won't work for him

That's a fine personal decision, but there's a huge leap between "I don't want to be involved with him" and "everybody else should ostracize him, or they are just as evil as him". The former is "live and let live", and the latter is "the world should bow to me".

Re:Time to Take a Stand by ryanx435 on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:20PM (#13508271)
It's crazy that you can't see how hypocritical you are: you ate literally saying that restaurants shouls ban thiel because he supports a person who bans people. Look in a mirror once in a while, buddy
Re:Time to Take a Stand by kasey_junk on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:23PM (#13508297)
There is a significant difference between voluntary association and compulsory exclusion through use of force.

It's not even partially hypocritical to claim one is ok & the other isn't.

Re:Time to Take a Stand by ebola1717 on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:25PM (#13508323)
Are you really comparing divestment to segregation?????????????

You realize the reason segregation was wrong was because it was based on someone's skin color, not the actions they've taken?

Re:Time to Take a Stand by qwertyuiop924 on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:18PM (#13525591)
That's true.

However, people were sent to concentration camps for their actions and beliefs, and we all think that's wrong...

Re:Time to Take a Stand by tptacek on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @10:42AM (#13541519)
You are now literally reprising a joke from Season 1 of Silicon Valley.
Re:Time to Take a Stand by qwertyuiop924 on Thursday February 02, 2017 @03:09PM (#13554140)
Am I? Huh.

Also, does that invalidate my point? I mean, I don't think it does, but I figured I might as well ask...

Re:Time to Take a Stand by qwertyuiop924 on Saturday January 28, 2017 @03:23PM (#13508940)
That's different from being exiled from civil society.
Re:Time to Take a Stand by keithwhor on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:33PM (#13508431)
I appreciate this post by Sam, it means a lot. I think your sentiments are sound, as well.

I think what's more important is clarifying Peter Thiel's beliefs and how he's going to make things better moving forward. The line in the sand that Sam and YC should seriously consider is when do the political freedoms of their partners supersede the actual freedoms of their founders?

The way I feel, as a founder, is slightly taken advantage of. I'm not directly part of the YC network, but there's an implicit social contract in Silicon Valley --- help others, and it will come back to you. YC's value is in fighting for founders. When a partner actively supports a vehemently anti-immigrant candidate and their political freedoms are defended at the potential expense of founders' livelihoods, it's confusing. It sends a message to founders that they're simply cattle - you can afford to lose a few along the way because you have the greenest pasture and you're confident they'll overlook the slaughterhouse.

I like YC. I love the founders and partners I've met that are part of the network and have a great deal of respect for everyone involved. There's some murky water here, though, and additional clarity would alleviate the anxieties of, I think, a lot of talented entrepreneurs, both aspiring and successful.

Re:Time to Take a Stand by iaw on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:13PM (#13508189)
> YC voted Thiel off the island

The hypocrisy of being anti-Trump but accepting Thiel is all over the valley.

Re:Time to Take a Stand by apsec112 on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:14PM (#13508192)
How many degrees of separation from Trump do you think people should go?

"It goes without saying that if the people of Group X are staring at you demandingly, waiting for you to hate the right enemies with the right intensity, and ready to castigate you if you fail to castigate loudly enough, you may be hanging around the wrong group." - http://lesswrong.com/lw/42/tolerate_tolerance/

Re:Time to Take a Stand by gyardley on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:19PM (#13508249)
Just the one will suffice for Thiel.

This is the guy, after all, who spent his time making "you can't take him literally" arguments about the same policies Trump is pushing forward in his very first week.

Re:Time to Take a Stand by smacktoward on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:19PM (#13508251)
Thiel is not some distant nodding acquaintance of Trump's. He is a close advisor and Trump's lead point of contact with the tech community.

So how many degrees of separation? Let's start with "more than one, please" and go from there.

Re:Time to Take a Stand by puzzle on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:37PM (#13508459)
Yeah, where IS Thiel?
Re:Time to Take a Stand by mythrwy on Saturday January 28, 2017 @02:40PM (#13508487)
"Anyone in a position of power who took a look at Trump and didn't recoil with disgust needs to be exiled from civil society"

We don't work like that. If we do the next one exiled will be you.

[dead]
Re:Time to Take a Stand by varjag on Saturday January 28, 2017 @04:22PM (#13509439)
Re:Time to Take a Stand by angry-hacker on Saturday January 28, 2017 @03:16PM (#13508879)
And Obama was the biggest nazi of all times, he created a spy machine that would have made gestapo jealous. Where was the outcry in the last 8 years. Some of you bigots voted for him twice!