News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by muninn_ on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:27AM (#13506675)
From the article:

"Trump signed an executive order Friday prohibiting entry by people from seven majority-Muslim nations for 90 days. Citizens of Syria, Iraq, Iran, Sudan, Somalia, Yemen and Libya would be banned from entering the U.S. for the period, while the government determines what information it needs to safely admit visitors."

I... have a hard time finding this to be that outrageous. I noticed the article mentions that they are muslim-majority, but they are also war zones, which I think matters much more. If it was an anti-islam thing then why wouldn't they ban people from places like Indonesia?

For our firm this won't really make a difference right now, and we'll figure out what to do in the coming months. I don't really have a problem with better vetting procedures for people from these countries.

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by rtpg on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:32AM (#13506709)
Iran is a war zone?

Besides, there are people from these countries who have green cards. People living in the US for years. They could have gone on a business trip to Canada last week, and now are stuck outside the country.

If we don't let people who are already living here come back, do you think we should kick them out?

What about the Iraqis that worked with the military and got visa status before? Do we kick them out?

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by yequalsx on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:38AM (#13506735)
I believe this does not affect green card holders. My understanding is that green card holders are entitled to enter the U.S. in a similar way that U.S. are entitled to enter the U.S.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by tobltobs on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:47AM (#13506792)
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by mistermann on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:55AM (#13506852)
As a soft Trump supporter, this infuriates me. I hope he walks this back quickly.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by cookiecaper on Saturday January 28, 2017 @11:31AM (#13507180)
That's not much of a source. Not even a full sentence from the supposed email. Color me dubious.

I don't think anyone would expect this to affect green card holders, and if this isn't an outright fabrication, which frankly wouldn't surprise me at this point, I'm sure Trump will clarify the matter shortly. No one wants these policies to affect established, permanent residents.

Remember, this is a very hard transition and the teams are still in the process of exchanging. It's absolutely plausible that there are anti-Trump people in the government doing everything they can to throw a wrench in the works. The media has certainly made it clear that they're basically willing to self-immolate to try to stop Trump, and I think there are a lot of Obama-era workers of similar mind.

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by cookiecaper on Sunday January 29, 2017 @01:52AM (#13512688)
I know this thread is old now, but I wanted to update with a follow-up.

Reuters has edited the story linked above [0] to state that the spokeswoman had improperly stated the effect and that, per a "senior administration official", permanent residents will be allowed to enter the United States after a "routine rescreening". [Permanent residents, or "green card holders", are non-citizens who have been granted a permanent right to reside in the United States.]

As expected, this is just another case of the media heavily misrepresenting an action by Trump because they want to destroy him at any cost.

[0] See http://archive.is/JViXa for a snapshot of the Reuters article at Sun Jan 29 01:52:21 EST 2017. The old snapshot is accessible by clicking the "history" link on that page, or going directly to http://archive.is/ZwEBt .

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by tobltobs on Monday January 30, 2017 @07:55AM (#13520738)
> As expected, this is just another case of the media heavily misrepresenting an action by Trump because they want to destroy him at any cost.

Or it is the result of an amateurish group in power, which seem not to understand the consequences of their actions.

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by cookiecaper on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:19PM (#13524149)
As the administration itself implements and interprets its own policies (at least until judicial intervention corrects that interpretation), thus creating the consequences of enforcement, that doesn't seem likely.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by derenrich on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @12:29AM (#13527967)
The administration wrote the policy then the DHS interpreted it. Then the administration overruled that interpretation. And then about a day later the administration changed its mind. It's almost as if they should've thought about this proposal for another 48 hours before signing it.

Source: http://www.cnn.com/2017/01/28/politics/donald-trump-travel-b...

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by tyingq on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:43AM (#13506765)
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by disantlor on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:41AM (#13506752)
the order seems to be vague on this and, since it was executed with little planning, leaves it up to immigration officers to make ad hoc decisions, saying things like "call the president" when questioned
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by yequalsx on Saturday January 28, 2017 @12:49PM (#13507667)
For those downvoting, why? It is my belief from talking to green card holders that they have a right to entry in the U.S. I'm not a lawyer and I suspect those downvoting aren't either. I phrased my comment in terms of what I thought to be true and as a fact.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by mjmsmith on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:34AM (#13506715)
> they are also war zones

Yeah, because that's where refugees tend to come from.

> If it was an anti-islam thing

You know that if and when the ban is lifted, it also prioritizes Christian refugees over Muslims, right?

> For our firm this won't really make a difference right now

Your humanity is a shining example to all.

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by ledbettj on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:30AM (#13506693)
Can you talk about what the existing procedures are for refugees from these countries, and why they're not sufficient?

I would Also be interested in knowing how many terrorist acts have been committed in the US by refugees.

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by jonathankoren on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:54AM (#13506832)
It takes two years of vetting before a refugee is granted entry to the United States, and even then most applicants are denied. The process includes multiple interviews, background checks, and biometric searches.[1]

Why isn't this sufficient? Well, it is sufficient. Your chances of being killed by a refugee turned terrorist is 1 in 3.6 billion according to the Cato Institute.[2] So why isn't considered sufficient? Quite frankly it a political ploy to gain support by stoking unfounded fears of others.

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/11/20/us/why-it-tak...

[2] https://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/truth-about-for...

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by pfarnsworth on Saturday January 28, 2017 @11:29AM (#13507161)
Germany had a massive amount of sexual assaults perpetrated over NYE last year, mainly from Middle Eastern immigrants/refugees. Things like this tend to leave lasting bad impressions on refugees in general, regardless of how true it is, and look at how that issue blew up in Merkel's face since then.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2016/07/10...

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by mkesper on Saturday January 28, 2017 @12:11PM (#13507439)
The offenders were mostly from northern Africa (so not from Syria, where most immigrants in 2015 came from). That Washington Post article is clearly biased. Better read the source article: http://www.sueddeutsche.de/politik/uebergriffe-in-koeln-frau...
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by jonathankoren on Saturday January 28, 2017 @11:51AM (#13507308)
Perception and reality are two different things, and only the former is relevant to politics.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by JacobJans on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:55AM (#13506844)
Unfortunately, it is about the fact that they are Muslims.

"Mr. Trump also established a religious test for refugees from Muslim nations: He ordered that Christians and others from minority religions be granted priority over Muslims."

Source: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/27/us/politics/trump-syrian-...

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by tboyd47 on Saturday January 28, 2017 @11:08AM (#13506975)
This statement alarmed me, so I looked into it and I find it's a tad misleading. The executive order itself neither explicitly prioritizes Christians over Muslims nor mentions either religion by name. It directs authorities to give priorities to applicants who practice a minority religion in their country of origin.

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/27/us/politics/refugee-musli...

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by JacobJans on Saturday January 28, 2017 @11:37AM (#13507224)
The President made it clear that it is about prioritizing Christians:

“if you were a Muslim you could come in, but if you were a Christian, it was almost impossible."

"I thought it was very, very unfair. So we are going to help them,” the president said.

Sadly, even his logic is factually incorrect.

Not that facts matter. Anger does, right? And fear.

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by tboyd47 on Saturday January 28, 2017 @06:57PM (#13510518)
Perhaps that was what he meant with the order, but the text of the order does not indicate a preference for any one religion over the other.

I'm really getting tired of reporters (or journalists, or bloggers, or whoever it is that writes news these days) describing Trump's actions as they understand them rather than how they actually are. It's unnecessary and doesn't help. It just means I have to go digging around for explanations to things that should have been fully explained in the article itself.

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by HillaryBriss on Saturday January 28, 2017 @12:11PM (#13507435)
i gather you're saying that Trump has his facts wrong here, which unfortunately seems to be a common problem for him.

that said, what are the facts about refugee counts by religion from Syria?

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by tacomonstrous on Saturday January 28, 2017 @11:24AM (#13507116)
That's not a religious test? It's clear what its intent is.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by curun1r on Saturday January 28, 2017 @11:05AM (#13506935)
The purported anti-terror rationale seems pretty disingenuous when you look at the nationalities of the people who have previously committed acts of terror on US soil. San Bernadino was someone from Pakistan and someone from the US. 9/11 was people from Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Lebanon and UAE. Oklahoma City was an American. And every school, church, theater, etc mass shooting that has taken place over the past decade was either committed by an American or national of a country not on his list.

So what's the point of it then? It can't be about "safely allowing immigration" if we're not blocking people from countries that have historically threatened our safety in the past.

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by HillaryBriss on Saturday January 28, 2017 @11:55AM (#13507335)
yeah, this is very suspicious.

immigrants from Saudi Arabia and Egypt are not scrutinized the way immigrants from Iran are, under this policy. we really must look at Trump's motivations.

Just considering the case of Saudi Arabia, we have this:

[Trump] emphasized that he has a good relationship with Saudi Arabia. On the same day, he said: “They are buying apartments and properties from me,” adding, “They spend $40-50 million, I am supposed to hate them? I love them very much.”

http://english.alarabiya.net/en/business/economy/2016/11/22/...

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by tdkl on Saturday January 28, 2017 @12:30PM (#13507554)
Point out an American politician who doesn't do business / takes donations from the Saudis. I'm waiting.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by HillaryBriss on Saturday January 28, 2017 @12:40PM (#13507605)
but that's the beauty of it. i don't have to name such a politician in order to justify my comment.

even if every single US politician takes donations from the Saudis, it still makes sense to scrutinize the motivations behind any policies that appear to unfairly favor Saudi Arabia.

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by KKKKkkkk1 on Saturday January 28, 2017 @11:16AM (#13507049)
I'm sad to see that muninn_'s comment is being downvoted, since he's expressing a view that I'm sure is held by a majority of the US public. It's actually already common for J1 visa holders to be vetted for months before they are allowed to return to the United States. This is a policy that existed long before Trump became president.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by ebbv on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:34AM (#13506717)
Banning people trying to escape war zones makes it worse not more acceptable. Stop watching so much TV news and reading articles by cowardly hate mongers. Most people are just like you and me and only want to provide a nice life for their families.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by cookiecaper on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:52AM (#13506816)
That's true, but it's not about "most people". Most people from those nations never had a chance of ending up in the United States anyway. Even for first-world migrants, getting access to another first-world country costs tens of thousands of dollars and months or years of time.

If we're seriously interested in helping, we should stop pretending like we can absorb all the refugees in existence and focus instead on practical, tangible ways to improve the lives of the people who are suffering. There is also a degree of isolationism, which is important. There is no need for America to get involved in everyone else's fight. There are always going to be problems in the world, and it shouldn't be our concern to try to fix all of them.

Because the wars in the Middle East are often blamed on the U.S. (because of support for Israel, or American involvement in regime change, or something else), segments of the population grow to hate us, and segments of that population radicalize and believe they can derive meaning from attacking their perceived enemy in the only way they can (terrorism). This has happened numerous times in the US already. Since foreign nationals have no inherent right to access the U.S., it's perfectly logical to tighten procedures for prospective entrants from terror-prone nations.

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by ebbv on Saturday January 28, 2017 @11:00AM (#13506883)
It's not an either or. We can absorb a lot more refugees than we are taking now (which is basically none) and we can also have better foreign policy than we have had for the last 20 years.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by cookiecaper on Saturday January 28, 2017 @11:22AM (#13507094)
But why would we? Because it's the polite thing to do? That's fine to an extent, but when there are active state-sponsored terrorist populations trying to sneak in operatives from the very region affected, why is that a risk that's wise for us to take? The "state-sponsored terrorism" boogeyman used to be a mostly-imaginary thing with reference to Iran, but who can argue now that ISIS, a literal terrorist state, controls large sections of Iraq and Afghanistan?

Culturally, we have very little in common with Middle Eastern refugees, and I don't just mean "they go to a weird looking church". We don't share similar cultural values. It's a big culture shock in both directions. There are other nations nearby that are much more similar and that the majority would be much more comfortable in.

Geographically, we're nowhere near the affected areas, and we already have a burgeoning refugee crisis on our southern border. Why do we need to import Syrian or other Middle Eastern refugees, specifically? We have taken them in some limited quantities, and that alone is risky enough, is it not?

I sympathize with wanting to be nice, but we need to be smart about it. There's more to life than tingly feelings, and there are plenty of opportunists out there who'd be happy to exploit our kindness. I love being nice, but I also love being smart. We should do both.

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by ebbv on Saturday January 28, 2017 @12:34PM (#13507575)
Because it's the morally right thing to do and immigrants enrich our country. Read some history.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by cookiecaper on Saturday January 28, 2017 @01:41PM (#13507945)
OK, so you're suggesting that we discard practicalities due to the purity of your ideology.

I don't believe that giving refuge to anyone who asks/wants it is automatically the right thing to do. In an ideal world, that would work fine, as would a lot of other naive solutions to social ills. But we don't live in an ideal world.

Immigrants enrich our country under the right circumstances. This is typically accepted as an implicit truth and it's the theory that underpins all immigration policy and visa restrictions; it's hardly anything new, and such restrictions are so self-evidently necessary that they're universal. Every country has entry requirements, and many of them are quite significant; not something that your average Joe could qualify for without years of work.

If we let in anyone who asks or anyone who poses as a refugee, we are being reckless with our own resources and safety. Not everyone in the world is acting in good faith.

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by ebbv on Saturday January 28, 2017 @03:07PM (#13508784)
> OK, so you're suggesting that we discard practicalities due to the purity of your ideology.

No, I'm not. I'm suggesting we abandon your unfounded fears in the face of historical evidence that bringing in immigrants has only ever done good things for our country and the reality of what is right (helping to relieve human suffering) and wrong (refusing to help when you are able to do so at no real cost to yourself.)

This will be my last reply to you since you are just clinging to right wing xenophobia.

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by cookiecaper on Saturday January 28, 2017 @03:55PM (#13509223)
Again you're casting this in hard ideological terms. I'm not a hard ideologue. It's possible for someone to disagree with you without "clinging to right-wing xenophobia", and, also again, stringent migration restrictions are not only normal but universal.

"Bringing in immigrants has only ever done good things" is an inherently subjective statement, so pretending like we can just open a history textbook and have the virtue of unlimited immigration smack us in the face is easy to dismiss without further argument. Even if someone does subjectively agree with this conclusion (and the topic is far too wide for such a broad generalization to hold), they'd point out that the stringent immigration restrictions that have always existed have played a large role in that success.

It's disappointing that rather than discussing the issue, you've chosen to apply a derisive and incorrect label, which you feel enables you to dismiss the argument without analyzing or discussing it. We're never going to get anywhere if, after two polite statements from someone, you're ready to label them with [what you feel] is a mean label and state that their opinion is invalid in light of the label you've just assigned. This is, simply and frankly, an extremely immature level of discourse, and sadly, many of us lack the moral backbone to stand up to it and we just comply with whoever is bullying the hardest/loudest. Many of our contemporary problems have this lack of moral backbone at their root.

Personally, I have great respect for Islam and Muslims in general. I think they're a net force for good, especially in modern secular nations that seriously need more influence from religious people. Though I haven't had the opportunity to travel abroad extensively, I'd like to some day, and I've seriously considered relocating outside of the United States to countries with very different cultural perspectives, including Muslim nations. My grandparents are immigrants who arrived at Ellis Island in the aftermath of World War 2, and they speak non-English at home, which I don't find at all upsetting or threatening.

By any objective measure, I'm not a "xenophobe" ("a person unduly fearful of what is foreign and especially of people of foreign origin"), but because you don't like my conclusion that some restrictions on refugee immigration from terror-prone regions are reasonable, you've chosen to label, shame, and ignore instead of politely agreeing to disagree.

Such dismissive ignorance and self-righteousness is exactly why the blue-collar hoi polloi are rejecting this tyranny of the rising nerd bourgeoisie.

Do you offer a room to every homeless guy you've ever met? I'm sure you could fit a lot of them in sleeping bags in your living room if you were so inclined. Why don't you do that? Hasn't history proven that people are good, and that "relieving human suffering" is good, and that it comes at "no real cost to yourself"?

Perhaps we just disagree about the costs and risks involved in accepting refugees from nations with substantial terrorist activity. That's fine, and it doesn't warrant petty labeling from either side. That's just called a "disagreement" and they happen all the time. Maybe we can work on learning how to disagree better?

There is nothing wrong with considering either the safety of American nationals or the cultural compatibility and willingness/likelihood of assimilation of foreign nationals into the American mainstream before we admit them to our country. Every country has a responsibility to make these determinations when accepting new migrants, which is why every country has nation-of-origin-based visa rules and other universal immigration controls. In fact, the rules for the US are much less stringent than those of many of our first-world peers.

The fact is that your shame-based suicide cult is simply not sticking. Please come out of the bubble. Is Trump's win not enough to wake you from the echo chamber?

[dead]
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by sangnoir on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:56AM (#13506859)
> I have trouble wrapping my head around that

It's not hard to understand once you stop lumping together civilian refugees and combatants as "these people".

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by linkregister on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:47AM (#13506791)
Many Democrats don't support drone strikes; drone strikes are also supported by Republican congressmen; the drone strikes are used to kill enemy combatants that have planned and continue to plan bombings to kill U.S. noncombatants.

It's pretty disingenuous to claim that enemy combatants dodge a drone strike and then are subsequently approved for an entry visa.

I could make the insult, "Your side imagines all brown people are terrorists, racist!" But that's not how you feel.

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by cmdrfred on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:55AM (#13506845)
Not only "enemy combatants" were killed a great number of innocent women and children were as well. I never claimed "terrorists" might try and enter the country by this route but it is utterly preposterous in my mind to claim you care about a population that you are murdering. If Democrats cared about drone murder they certainly dident enough to protest.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by hprotagonist on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:34AM (#13506714)
i don't think it's fine to do either, and i'm a registered democrat.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by cmdrfred on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:40AM (#13506742)
Voices like yours were sorely missed over the last 8 years while the bombing was going on.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by kasey_junk on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:46AM (#13506786)
So? You are willing to make it worse now because we did something bad in the past? That's an insane position.

You'll note this isn't a trade we aren't quitting the bombing by banning travelers.

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by cmdrfred on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:50AM (#13506806)
It makes me incredibly distrustful of their motives in the future. If they supported Obamas actions because he was on "their team" then how do I know that any attacks on Trump are based in fact instead of more partisan motives?
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by kasey_junk on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:57AM (#13506865)
It can be trivially argued that Hillary lost because her base was so lukewarm to her & a big reason for that was because of her support for violent encounters.

Instead of the result of that being we bomb less people it seems to be that we are going continue to bomb them and also enact amoral immigration policy. At this point it's not about partisan ship it's about morality for many of us.

In one week we've gone full bore insane. I'll be first in line to support any republican that stands against or.

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by somebehemoth on Saturday January 28, 2017 @11:08AM (#13506974)
Republicans and Democrats supported bombings. You've made a false dichotomy to suit your own bias.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by mjmsmith on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:57AM (#13506868)
You pay more attention to the facts than the motives.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by cmdrfred on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:59AM (#13506876)
That is what I do. And in that regard both parties have a great deal of blood on their hands.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by mjmsmith on Saturday January 28, 2017 @11:03AM (#13506920)
So do the facts make you in favor of this order or not?
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by cmdrfred on Saturday January 28, 2017 @05:06PM (#13509732)
Not at all. I'm not afraid of terrorism, as far as I can tell it's mostly used as a reason to keep weapons manufacturers employed and a surveillance/police state chugging along smoothly. The actual odds of dying in a terrorist attack are lower than winning the lottery. I actually used to consider myself on to lean to the democratic side. At least during the Bush years when they appeared to be anti-war party. Just lately, everything has been so sanctimonious and hypocritical from them that I'm no longer able to vote for them.
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by shadowfiend on Saturday January 28, 2017 @11:06AM (#13506957)
Were they? I'll just point to one liberal-leaning reputable news source and ask for your evidence that Democrats, and liberals in general, have been big fans of Obama's drone strikes:

http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/03/the-obam... https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/12/preside... https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2016/08/ob... http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2013/09/the-kill... http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2015/09/dro... http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2015/04/war...

Perhaps you mean something other than the drone strikes? Libya?

http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2016/04/oba... http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2012/09/how-obam...

Or did you have some other specific situation in mind that some mythical liberals have been silent about instead of emphatically critical of?

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by jbooth on Saturday January 28, 2017 @10:52AM (#13506822)
You mean while the bombing was reduced to almost nothing from 2 hot wars?
Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by 551199 on Saturday January 28, 2017 @11:05AM (#13506933)
Obama is the only president being in war for everyday of his 8 year presidency and simultaneously bombing what 6-7 countries at same time. Good thing he got a nobel peace prize.

Too bad we didn't get same kind of outrage of Obamas actions in press what we get now because Trump has to sort this mess.

Re:Ask HN: YC please talk about Immigration Order by livestyle on Saturday January 28, 2017 @11:39AM (#13507238)
Racist!! jk

It's refreshing to see a rational response to theses EO's instead of the over the top virtue signaling that is now common place on HN.