Re:Show HN: Magnetissimo – Self-hosted torrent search engine...
by brian-armstrong on Saturday January 28, 2017 @06:53AM
(#13505891)
Have a look at this repo for yourself if you don't believe me. The image demonstrates the tool being used for copyright violations. It's billing itself that way, no?
Re:Show HN: Magnetissimo – Self-hosted torrent search engine...
by msl on Saturday January 28, 2017 @06:57AM
(#13505901)
Are we looking at the same image? The one I see shows a search for the term "hdtv" with some results from an idexed site. I really can't see how the user has in any way violated anyone's copyright.
Edit: Removed an irrelevant addendum.
Re:Show HN: Magnetissimo – Self-hosted torrent search engine...
by brian-armstrong on Saturday January 28, 2017 @07:12AM
(#13505926)
It's not like the image is somehow accidental or out of the author's control. I don't know how you wouldn't read this as advertising a way to violate copyrights, it's an explicit advertisement of the sort of content you can find.
If the image weren't a suitable representation, then the author wouldn't have chosen it. You're trying to downplay that these sorts of decisions are intentional.
Re:Show HN: Magnetissimo – Self-hosted torrent search engine...
by dibstern on Saturday January 28, 2017 @07:51AM
(#13506019)
This is like an advertisement for guns, with a laser sight on the gun, pointed at someone.
Gun ownership is not a crime. But the gun is shown in a scenario where a crime is about to be committed.
At first I didn't have any issue but this analogy seems to have convinced me it's a bad image to use.
Re:Show HN: Magnetissimo – Self-hosted torrent search engine...
by Frenchgeek on Saturday January 28, 2017 @08:08AM
(#13506084)
Or the image was a random search and there isn't a team of marketing and legal experts to interpret a quick demo in the worst way possible.
But I'm sure the maintainer will be happy to modify the picture with a search for "big buck bunny" if you ask nicely.
If the content of the sites are the problem, well why would Google get a free pass on that point too?
The goal of the application itself, just like Google's, doesn't have anything to do with copyright violation, it just can be used that way.