Re:Mac sales declined nearly 10% last year as Lenovo, Dell a...
by izacus on Friday January 27, 2017 @06:14PM
(#13503621)
I've been using a 15" tMBP and the TouchBar has been a huge step back in usabilitiy for me. Mostly due to:
1.) It's utterly buggy. There are times when it doesn't boot after laptop comes back from sleep. Sometimes buttons don't redraw (e.g. missing ESC until you tap on that empty space). Sometimes it even hangs leaving you without brightness and volume controls. It's incredible how Apple managed to release something this buggy and how it passed QA.
2.) It gives no touch feedback at all, making pressing anything blindly on it feel terrible and inaccurate. Since each supporting app defines their own button position, it means that the buttons keep moving around making muscle memory pretty much impossible.
3.) Most of the time it's empty - pretty much none of the non-Apple software supports it. Volume control and brightness controls are now hidden behind a slider that's hard to hit blindly (as opposed to previous function keys).
4.) For most cases when it DOES work, it's still easier and quicker to press a keyboard shortcut because you can reliably press it without looking down at your fingers.
5.) It's pretty bright and sometimes distracting in the evening. This is a minor issue, but it's not synchronized with the keyboard brightness control and you can't darken it manually when working in dark environments or watching movies.
6.) TouchID is the only part I really like - it's made the OS experience way better.
If I could rip it out and replace it with proper ESC/Fx keys, I'd do it in a heartbeat. The part that most marketing materials don't show is this: the touchbar will only show shortcuts of the currently focused app (besides a few pre-set ones like volume, siri, show desktop). If the focused app doesn't support it, it'll sit there empty.
It would be significantly better if it would at least show shortcuts to dock applications, let you fully customize it with macros and shortcuts or let you control a certain app in the background while using another app. But you can't (yet I'm aware BTT exists, but even that hides macros behind another tap and slow animation).
All in all I can't fanthom how anyone at Apple thought this would be a productivity win for their most expensive 4000EUR laptops. I'd expect it to be useful for less techy people who don't use or know shortcuts... but for their high-end pro machines it's just a huge step back in usability.
1.) It's utterly buggy. There are times when it doesn't boot after laptop comes back from sleep. Sometimes buttons don't redraw (e.g. missing ESC until you tap on that empty space). Sometimes it even hangs leaving you without brightness and volume controls. It's incredible how Apple managed to release something this buggy and how it passed QA.
2.) It gives no touch feedback at all, making pressing anything blindly on it feel terrible and inaccurate. Since each supporting app defines their own button position, it means that the buttons keep moving around making muscle memory pretty much impossible.
3.) Most of the time it's empty - pretty much none of the non-Apple software supports it. Volume control and brightness controls are now hidden behind a slider that's hard to hit blindly (as opposed to previous function keys).
4.) For most cases when it DOES work, it's still easier and quicker to press a keyboard shortcut because you can reliably press it without looking down at your fingers.
5.) It's pretty bright and sometimes distracting in the evening. This is a minor issue, but it's not synchronized with the keyboard brightness control and you can't darken it manually when working in dark environments or watching movies.
6.) TouchID is the only part I really like - it's made the OS experience way better.
If I could rip it out and replace it with proper ESC/Fx keys, I'd do it in a heartbeat. The part that most marketing materials don't show is this: the touchbar will only show shortcuts of the currently focused app (besides a few pre-set ones like volume, siri, show desktop). If the focused app doesn't support it, it'll sit there empty.
It would be significantly better if it would at least show shortcuts to dock applications, let you fully customize it with macros and shortcuts or let you control a certain app in the background while using another app. But you can't (yet I'm aware BTT exists, but even that hides macros behind another tap and slow animation).
All in all I can't fanthom how anyone at Apple thought this would be a productivity win for their most expensive 4000EUR laptops. I'd expect it to be useful for less techy people who don't use or know shortcuts... but for their high-end pro machines it's just a huge step back in usability.