News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by golemotron on Thursday January 26, 2017 @08:35AM (#13491135)
In the past few weeks the idea of 'legitimatizing violence' has been circulating heavily. On my Facebook feed most of it has centered on the idea that it is "okay" to punch neo-nazis now. The people saying this are people I'd never expect to. Twitter is similar. I wish I had stats on whether the legitimatization meme is really rising. To me, it looks like the fake news meme. Suddenly it's everywhere.
Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by whyileft on Thursday January 26, 2017 @08:50AM (#13491267)
Not sure if you are old enough to remember that far leftist ideological organizations were often violent up until the last quarter of the 20th century.

This period of peacefulness is a recent phenomenon. One of the big pacifiers of democracy is that people accept the result because the majority voted for it. When you have a situation when 46% of the population is pushing an agenda that at least 48% of the population is strongly against. That group often starts to look for alternative ways to flex its majority power.

Especially when you realize that in large urban areas we are looking at 25% to 70% type splits in some cases.

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by AlexB138 on Thursday January 26, 2017 @08:58AM (#13491329)
>When you have a situation when 46% of the population is pushing an agenda that at least 48% of the population is strongly against. That group often starts to look for alternative ways to flex its majority power.

46% and 48% of voters, not of the population. Neither voting block are a majority of the population.

I would argue this particular part of our current political climate is largely pushed by a minority, and is as much about them believing their own propaganda as it is about the fact that they lost the election. Keep in mind there was quite a bit of violence coming from the left long before the election was over (attacking people at Trump rallies, fire bombing a GOP headquarters). They genuinely believe the sky is falling, so to speak. It's unfortunate, because it makes it difficult for the rest of us to have a discussion about where we've actually gone wrong.

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by whyileft on Thursday January 26, 2017 @10:05AM (#13491907)
The state of California which has one of the largest economies in the world was 62% to 32% against Donald Trump.

Is it really that surprising there is a fair amount of visible decent?

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by arethuza on Thursday January 26, 2017 @10:53AM (#13492337)
Indeed if California was a country its GDP would put it somewhere below France (#6) and above India (#7).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nomi...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_between_U.S._states...

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by hueving on Thursday January 26, 2017 @09:23AM (#13491531)
>at least 48% of the population is strongly against

Where did you get that number from? Hillary Clinton got 65.8 Million votes. That represents 20.6% of the United states population.

>That group often starts to look for alternative ways to flex its majority power.

See above. They were the majority of voters but they defintely don't represent the majority of the US.

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by ch4s3 on Thursday January 26, 2017 @10:44AM (#13492238)
There are 146.3 million registered voters though, which equated to about 45% of registered voters. The voter turnout was roughly 133 million, so she received about 49-59% of votes among those who bothered to show up. Trump received about 46-47% of votes, losing the popular vote by 3 million and winning electoral votes by about 80 thousand votes spread among several states. He ran on an extremely divisive and (perhaps racist) platform, so it's not hard to see why people are a bit frustrated.
Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by whyileft on Thursday January 26, 2017 @09:59AM (#13491858)
The largest voting blocks that have low turnout would make that gap larger, not smaller. Also, in urban areas where most of these protests are happening the gaps were enormous.

In Washington, DC Donald Trump won 4% of the vote.

Is it not surprising those people feel a bit underrepresented right now and might turn to alternative means of flexing their massive majority in the areas they specifically live?

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by hueving on Thursday January 26, 2017 @10:31AM (#13492096)
>The largest voting blocks that have low turnout would make that gap larger, not smaller. Also, in urban areas where most of these protests are happening the gaps were enormous.

There is no proof of that. "If this person who decided not to vote were a person who decided to vote then they would vote in a similar manner to the other people who decided to vote" is stupid reasoning because that person decided not to vote.

>In Washington, DC Donald Trump won 4% of the vote.

I am shocked, shocked! A city filled with people who's lives revolve around a big federal government voted for the most establishment candidate in history.

>their massive majority in the areas they specifically live

In D.C., Hillary got 282k votes. The population is 659k. That's not even half of the population. Cool it with the 'massive majority' crap.

The US operates on an election system reflecting the house and senate. This should be basic knowledge for most American citizens. Throwing fits because it didn't go your way is pretty childish since it's exactly how the electoral college works.

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by whyileft on Thursday January 26, 2017 @11:04AM (#13492451)
Im just helping one to understand why there are protests and unrest.

DC had a very small inaugural turnout and very large protest the day after. I was trying to give some perspective.

I believe it was about 90% in Chicago. San Fransisco was over 90%. New York City had a large margin. We are talking approximately 45 of the 50 largest cities in the country did not vote for Donald Trump.

I took high school civics. I know how the rules work. Im just telling you that civil unrest usually happens when people feel like the rules are unjust and they have little or no power to change it through the democratic process. So Im simply trying to shed some light on it to people who may not understand why people might feel that way.

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by hueving on Friday January 27, 2017 @01:27AM (#13498143)
And 'they' did not vote for Hillary either if your bar is the majority. The problem is that people think their view represents the majority of the country because they won the popular vote. Their view only represents the majority that voted.
Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by sigmaprimus on Thursday January 26, 2017 @12:09PM (#13493112)
Since this thread is going a bit off topic I figured I would share a link from your friendly neighbors to the north it relates to your two party system and is from a great canadian leader we had a long time ago, who brought us our version of obama care.. It's the story of mouseland.

https://www.google.ca/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://...

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by whyileft on Thursday January 26, 2017 @12:38PM (#13493360)
What you are showing is a common tactic for a group that knows they are doing the wrong thing to validate themselves by claiming everyone is a bad guy. Or that the other side is worse etc etc.

You would seriously have to be blind to not realize the the current path of policies is simply incorrect policies that will lead to harm. For example instead of paying for a wall, Mexico will just pay for better ports as Donald Trump and the fools that voted for him seem to forget they have coastal shipping access to both Europe and Asia. Not to mention all of South and Central America.

That's the problem. Replacing social security with private retirement funds is a debate about which is better. With pluses and minuses on both sides. And guess what? The combination of 401k's IRAs and Social Security kind of does that. See how that works? Its actually saner than people want to believe. Same with things like how health care is run. Its not like we have some kind of socialist utopian system. Its a compromise. Or taxation with our 15% cap gains. Both sides have different opinions but both are at least based in some kind of functional reality where they might actually work. And the reality is that they are both a little bit right so in the end we typically wind up someone in the middle despite how it looks.

Stupid crap like building a wall is just plain incorrect policy. I mean if you even asked experts in border security, they would not suggest just building a giant wall. Its like what a 7 year old would suggest. What you would actually have is very similar to what we currently have. Its pretty easy to see a group of people running across the open desert and intercept them with the technology we currently have.

That is the big difference between what is happening now and what is typical in US politics.

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by germinalphrase on Thursday January 26, 2017 @09:20AM (#13491508)
Culturally, Americans have chosen "Nazis" and zombies as default groups on which we can assert violence without questioning our moral values or their expression. While Richard Spencer is even saying in that clip that he isn't a Neo Nazi (before getting punched) - a great deal of the American population don't draw the lines as finely as he might. He's certainly said some things that put him in that world of thought.

I share your discomfort with this in so far as we shouldn't normalize violence in daily life.

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by soundwave106 on Thursday January 26, 2017 @12:33PM (#13493326)
There's a very long-standing association of "neo-Nazis" with disaffected whites that are over-prone to violent behavior towards anyone that aren't neo-Nazis. (As far as I'm aware Richard Spencer has never been violent himself, but the association of neo-Nazi types with overly-violent people has extended back for decades.) So it's a bit more than just the "Nazis are the face of evil" type symbolism seen in the movies.

Evoking the sort of deep tribal behavior Mr. Spencer is engaging in, instinctively often leads to tribal responses (including violence). Which is unfortunate. I don't think Richard Spencer "deserves" to be punched, and I don't see punching as a noble act. Violence is only justifiable as a defense against violence, in my opinion. I actually think aggressor violence plays right into the hands of the "help we're being oppressed!" narrative, that seems to be a lot of the "drive" behind white supremacism.

I cannot see Mr. Spencer's philosophy to be anything but illogical and immoral to the rational mind. I therefore don't have any real good way to combat his (and other) tribalism, other than continuing to emphasize rational thought. Such is a much more difficult job in this current climate, when the current leader of the US got there half by exploiting tribal politics. But what else will work? I can't see the fisticuffs approach leading to anything other than deepening division.

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by ch4s3 on Thursday January 26, 2017 @10:48AM (#13492285)
> saying in that clip that he isn't a Neo Nazi

To be fair, he says that it's an "antiquated term" and that it's "unfortunately tarnished" and that he prefers to be associated with ethno-nationalism... So it may be a distinction without a difference.

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by SolaceQuantum on Thursday January 26, 2017 @10:37AM (#13492162)
I'm also uncomfortable with violence but I don't have an answer to the inevitable "well what else should we do". Facts, reasonable logic, and ridicule do not seem to work. Do you have any suggestions?
Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by germinalphrase on Thursday January 26, 2017 @01:47PM (#13494063)
Turn off the media and talk to your neighbors?

Interpersonally, I think we need to keep pushing the belief that there is more than unites us than divides us. At the core of it, we all really want the same sort of stuff (safety, purpose, love, fun, etc.) The more we allow ourselves to be divided (by media, by political rhetoric, by rumor and gossip, by hate) the less likely we will be able to hold those with real power and influence to task - the less we will be able to shape policy and investment in such a way that everyone in our communities benefit.

Big picture, we need to create communities in which all people - including disaffected bigots - can feel that they are thriving (rather than merely surviving). If we do that then these groups, and this repressible rhetoric, will find less support and fewer fertile minds to pollute.

That's my belief anyway.

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by SolaceQuantum on Friday January 27, 2017 @08:20AM (#13499585)
I agree that at the core most people want the same thing but there are bigoted beliefs that are inherently difficult to be a minority around and it's harder to handle. For example, the guy whose face has been punched often recently, he desires an ethnic cleansing in order to accomplish safety, purpose, etc. Should we expect the people who are targets of his rhetoric(the people he wishes to ethnically cleanse) to feel safe talking to him or interacting with him? I don't know, and I don't know if he'll even listen to those people. Has it worked for you with people you've met?
[dead]
Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by dang on Thursday January 26, 2017 @06:18PM (#13496304)
You've done almost nothing but post angry political boilerplate since we asked you to stop using HN primarily for political battle. We ban accounts that do that, regardless of their politics or the correctness of their views, because that's the only way to protect HN from being overrun with flamewars. The purpose of HN is the gratification of intellectual curiosity (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html), not war by other means, so please stop using it for the latter.
Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by germinalphrase on Thursday January 26, 2017 @10:01AM (#13491872)
No. I'm recognizing that dangerous thoughts are not illegal in the United States of America and perpetuating violence is dangerous and ineffective.

My wife and I both chose careers of service that are directly antithetical to the words and thoughts of this man. I sympathize with the desire to punch him - he is eminently punchable - but I believe that directing violence on him will serve to draw support to his cause, increase the likelihood of violence being perpetrated on my allies, and undermine the credibility and standing of my moral and political beliefs.

We should resist the normalization of violence in our political discourse.

Edit: grammar

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by legodt on Thursday January 26, 2017 @10:21AM (#13492024)
So what is the line? Neo-nazis don't respond to debate or rationality. What line do they have to cross for violence to become acceptable for you?

Because, clearly, actively calling for and organizing a group centered around my death and the death of my community isn't enough

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by Torgo on Thursday January 26, 2017 @02:41PM (#13494560)
That's not what he did or said, and your inability or refusal to recognize that is why a lot of people are against you trying to create a moral justification for mob attacks.

You don't get to decide that for yourself because you live in a society where you gain benefits from designating sole authority to enact violence to the state. If you engage in violence, then the state will in turn give you what you deserve. Even if you understood him correctly, which you did not, he has a right to speak them and people like you get to go to jail if you go around assaulting people.

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by legodt on Thursday January 26, 2017 @04:26PM (#13495383)
>That's not what he did or said,

He had repeatedly called for an ethnic cleansing of America. And now his buddy, Steve bannon is in the white house. The state has a monopoly on violence, and they aren't on our side

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by germinalphrase on Thursday January 26, 2017 @12:43PM (#13493417)
It is not illegal to talk of, and organize around, hateful and morally reprehensible beliefs. If they act on these beliefs or create credible plans to act then that would be the line.

We also have civil authorities - like the police - that we bestow with the power of violence to protect these lines. Additionally, we have civil rights and hate crime laws that bestow additional punishments for groups like this acting on their beliefs.

I think we will be better served reinforcing our shared beliefs in these civil authorities rather than acting as vigilantes and undermine our moral stance and possibly reinforce/embolden the support for our enemies.

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by donatj on Thursday January 26, 2017 @09:04AM (#13491383)
The remarkably sad part is the violence does nothing but legitimize the attacked parties hate. Hate begets hate.
Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by BEEdwards on Thursday January 26, 2017 @10:25AM (#13492051)
Violence totally legitimized the fascists and Nazis...

OH wait, no it's the opposite, the only way to defeat them is on their own terms.

You keep on appeasing them hoping it will work this time though.

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by donatj on Thursday January 26, 2017 @02:47PM (#13494634)
It legitimizes their position in their minds.

You punch someone, you are certainly not encouraging them to not hate you. You are not making your point that you are something not deserving of hate. If anything you are proving it and cauterizing their hatred for you in the process.

It achieves nothing positive save very brief catharsis.

[dead]
Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by Dirlewanger on Thursday January 26, 2017 @11:59AM (#13493025)
Because Martin Luther King Jr. was such a large proponent of violence...
Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by vkou on Thursday January 26, 2017 @01:47PM (#13494058)
Martin Luther King would not have gotten anywhere if it weren't for people like Malcolm X (Who scared the hell out of white America.)

When you've got Black Panthers on the streets with assault weapons, negotiating with (Instead of ignoring) a pacifist Baptist minister suddenly starts to sound like a way better idea.

Ghandi won because the empire was, quite literally, too broke to hold on to its colonies. An Indian nationalist movement would not have gotten anywhere before the World Wars bankrupted England.

Mind you, today, Martin Luther King's boycotts and marches are called economic terrorism.

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Thursday January 26, 2017 @02:44PM (#13494603)
To say a thing like this betrays the lack of just about any knowledge of the historical record.
Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by donatj on Thursday January 26, 2017 @12:01PM (#13493036)
And Gandhi
Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by MrZongle2 on Thursday January 26, 2017 @03:15PM (#13494877)
"On my Facebook feed most of it has centered on the idea that it is "okay" to punch neo-nazis now."

This is especially disturbing because the epithets "nazi" and "fascist" have increasingly become synonymous with "somebody I really don't agree with", rather than a description of somebody who admires the tenets of National Socialism.

That isn't progressive; it's Jacobin.

Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by tptacek on Thursday January 26, 2017 @10:19AM (#13492006)
Whatever else this comment might be, it is certainly wildly off topic for the thread. Please don't catalyze sprawling off-topic subthreads on stories.
Re:Stanford historian uncovers a grim correlation between vi... by golemotron on Thursday January 26, 2017 @10:52AM (#13492328)
It isn't. The article is about the efficacy of violence for political change. My comment is about its timing.