News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by simon_ on Friday May 14, 2010 @01:04PM (#1347844)
I don't think it's likely, but I deeply hope that Google (or somebody else) can kill the US addiction to subsidized handsets. The market will be so much more efficient and flexible when we pay for phones as phones and pay for service as service.
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by donw on Friday May 14, 2010 @01:18PM (#1347892)
Apple could, but chose not to. I'm one of not just a few people who would have happily ponied up $600 for an unlocked iPhone direct from Apple, mostly because I could then use it with both my Softbank and AT&T accounts.

As is, I have to do the unlock dance, and have a phone that crashes semi-randomly. I'm very unlikely to buy another iPhone again, at least not unless they sell them as unlocked handsets, and I'm also unlikely to use it with AT&T.

Shitting on your customers is such a stupid strategy.

Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by dzlobin on Friday May 14, 2010 @01:59PM (#1348033)
I actually don't see why this is so bad. There are only a handful of carriers and and I switch every 5 or 6 years at this rate. Right now I can enjoy a new phone, as I just did with a new blackberry, for free if I extend my contract, which I would do anyway. How would actually dropping $300 on my phone and then 'choosing' a new carrier help me at all? Especially when they peddle the same shit service and same shit customer support
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by moultano on Friday May 14, 2010 @02:12PM (#1348068)
Plans get cheaper if there isn't a phone to subsidize (at least with T-mobile.) You end up spending less money over the course of the contract if you buy the phone directly.
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by dzlobin on Friday May 14, 2010 @02:38PM (#1348167)
According to the website, the contract-less 1000 min plan costs exactly the same as my 2-yr contract with at&t's 1000 min plan. Except I got a 500 dollar phone for free.

Maybe if the discounts were much steeper and widespread, but as of now, I still don't see a reason.

Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by rbranson on Friday May 14, 2010 @02:48PM (#1348196)
Are you looking at the Even More Plus? It's not contract-less (there's a document to sign and a credit check) as much as it doesn't require you to sign a long-term contract. It's month to month. While AT&T is saying $59.99/mo for 900 minutes, T-Mobile's 1000 is $39.99/mo, the real savings comes in the data and texting plans. 1000 minutes + Unlimited Text + Unlimited data is $69.99/mo with T-Mobile, versus the gouging AT&T gives you at $109.99/mo.
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by btmorex on Friday May 14, 2010 @02:55PM (#1348211)
I guess I'm missing something. t-mobile 1000 minute plan is $40 per month. at&t 900 minute plan is $60 per month.

$20 * 24 = $480, roughly what your phone is worth except you're stuck with the carrier for 2 years.

Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by gte910h on Friday May 14, 2010 @01:15PM (#1347882)
I'd honestly prefer it was just legislated that we do it like Europe (where you see the amount you're paying for the phone itself, and there aren't really ETFs)
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by roel_v on Friday May 14, 2010 @02:42PM (#1348175)
What's an EFT?
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by gregstoll on Friday May 14, 2010 @02:51PM (#1348202)
An ETF is an Early Termination Fee, which you have to pay if you leave your contract early. It protects the carriers since they're subsidizing your phone.
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by pyre on Friday May 14, 2010 @03:01PM (#1348230)
You say that it 'protects' them, but it was only recently (last year or two) that they decided to pro-rate those fees.

So a month before my 2-year contract is up, my ETF would be the same as if I cancelled within the first month. This is bogus if the reasoning is so that the carriers can 'recoup the cost of the phone that they were subsidizing.'

Even with the pro-rated ETFs now, IIRC they won't be insignificant at the 'month before the end of a 2-year contract' point even though the carrier has obviously made back most (if not all) of their sunk costs by then...

ETFs are there because the mobile carriers like to bank your monthly fees as a constant revenue stream, and when people cancel early it screws up their numbers and projections, much in the same way that banks penalize you for closing out a CD early. Talk about how it's to 'protect the carriers from people that cancel early without covering the full cost of the phone' is just people buying in to the BS story that the US mobile industry's PR depts have been telling us for years.

Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by gte910h on Friday May 14, 2010 @03:06PM (#1348243)
> decided to pro-rate those fees.

They didn't decide. Non-prorated fees were found to be unenforceable. I'd call that forced.

Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by pyre on Friday May 14, 2010 @03:08PM (#1348248)
That's even worse. I didn't know the root cause of the change, just that it had happened.
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by detst on Friday May 14, 2010 @07:08PM (#1348873)
I think compatibility would kill this practice. Maybe LTE can bring this?

If we could buy a phone from Europe, off Craigslist, a phone from ATT but switch to Verizon, etc., and not worry about carrier, we would start to question the contracts and pricing structure. There would be a huge demand for discounts (with the real threat of being able to take our phone elsewhere if they didn't comply) on non-subsidized phones.

Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by mattmaroon on Friday May 14, 2010 @01:15PM (#1347884)
It would be great but it won't happen. Humans are genetically predisposed to wanting things that are free (even if, in reality, they only seem free).

Number portability means carriers can't offer phones at steep discounts without the contract. People figure "I'm going to have a cell phone for the next 2 years anyway, I might as well just pick one carrier and get it for free."

Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by laut on Friday May 14, 2010 @02:53PM (#1348206)
It is already reality to a certain degree outside of the US.

The difference can likely be explained by how some combination of the economics, regulation, politics, culture, geography is different in the US.

Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by mechanical_fish on Friday May 14, 2010 @03:28PM (#1348305)
As has been pointed out elsewhere on the thread, the fact that there are multiple cellular radio standards in the USA (GSM and CDMA), combined with the fact that network coverage in the USA is so spotty (my colleagues in the Bay Area can't stop complaining about the poor AT&T coverage, whereas my AT&T coverage north of Boston is fine) means that you effectively don't have much choice of carrier. Once you choose a home and a phone you're very nearly stuck with one carrier. So unless you see yourself switching your service on and off over time, or you enjoy switching hardware more often than once every 24 months, there's no real disadvantage to signing the evil contract.
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by doron on Friday May 14, 2010 @05:16PM (#1348629)
I will admit first ignorance on cellular radio standard, but i'm quite sure its possible to build a CDMA and GSM all in one phone, that are activated based on availability and carrier.

I would love to get a droid phone that does just that.

Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by joshhart on Friday May 14, 2010 @01:42PM (#1347985)
Not sure about that entirely. Remember when computers were given away free with 3 years of AOL sign up in the late 90's? That fad only lasted a while.
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by brg on Friday May 14, 2010 @02:07PM (#1348055)
At that time the subscription fees did not cover the cost of the hardware. Subscription fees were also falling due to decreasing barriers of entry into dialup and internet providers. Alternatives such as advertising did not cover the cost of the net-pcs either.

For cellular phones, the $200-300 hardware cost is easily recouped over two years on a $70.00 monthly plan.

Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by mattmaroon on Saturday May 15, 2010 @10:24AM (#1349899)
Not only that, AOL didn't last long after that.
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by dagw on Friday May 14, 2010 @04:13PM (#1348461)
Give people the choice between a free phone and $60 a month or the same contract for $30 a month and no free phone, and I see no reason why many people wouldn't choose the second option. Personally I prefer to optimize my finances to minimize my monthly bills, and I'm sure I'm not the only one.
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by orangecat on Friday May 14, 2010 @06:20PM (#1348793)
Give people the choice between a free phone and $60 a month or the same contract for $30 a month and no free phone, and I see no reason why many people wouldn't choose the second option.

That's because you have a basic understanding of math and finance, unlike an alarmingly large percentage of the population.

Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by mattmaroon on Saturday May 15, 2010 @10:26AM (#1349902)
Right. Most people pay more taxes than they need to on purpose out of each pay check so they get a refund at the end of the year.

People who are so bad at savings that they want the government to hold their money are taking the contract.