News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by WalterBright on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @02:09AM (#13469414)
No. It's the scientific method - by which truth can be separated from crap.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_method

Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by timnic on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @03:32AM (#13469715)
An (maybe) interesting fact is, that in Germany the notion „scientific method“, to my knowledge, is largely unknown. For example, there is no link in the english wikipedia entry you have given to the german wikipedia. When I studied physics in Germany no one ever used that term.
Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by di4na on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @04:22AM (#13469908)
Same in most place in Europe. This is mainly an American name. Because it is _not_ how science works.
Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by tdfx on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @10:51AM (#13472301)
Could you elaborate? As an American who hasn't traveled as much as he should, this came as a surprise to me. I always assumed the "scientific method" that we were taught in school was some universal international standard.
Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by di4na on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @06:31PM (#13476836)
Because science does not works by a "scientific method". It work with some really simple things :

- Be sceptical

- Believe the data

- Keep asking questions.

All the rest is just fluff. Most of the time you have experiments before hypothesis. Or an intuition that only match part of it. Or publish some food for though and it will only be proved to be false hundreds of years later. The whole "hypothesis -> experiment -> theory" miss so many things.

From the french wikipedia entry

Très souvent, le terme de « méthode » engage l'idée implicite de son unicité, tant auprès du grand public que de certains chercheurs, qui de surcroît la confondent parfois avec la seule méthode hypothético-déductive. L'étude des pratiques des chercheurs révèle cependant une si grande diversité de démarches et de disciplines scientifiques que l'idée d'une unité de la méthode est rendue très problématique.

Quick and bad translation :

Most of the time, the term "method" push the implicit idea of unicity, to some scientists but also to the public, who also reduce it to the solely "hypothetico-deductive" method. The study of scientists practices reveal a so big diverity of method and scientific fields that the idea of an unicity of the method is highly problematic.

Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by timnic on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @11:25AM (#13472699)
When I was in school "scientific method" wasn’t teached as a separate topic, but more like the result of "osmosis": you are given many examples of how science works and you somehow learn by this the process of science itself. Ok, you are taught how do do proofs in maths and how to do experiments, but no direct reference to a concept like the scientific method.
Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by metaxy2 on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @11:38AM (#13472859)
In the US we do teach about the scientific method as an abstract idea, especially in grade school and high school, but working scientists mostly learn by osmosis here as well. I'd say it serves a role similar to the way finance guys use math models, or musicians use advanced music theory: an idealized description of the way things are done on the ground that you study in school, but rarely use day to day.
Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by posterboy on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @11:29AM (#13472744)
I was taught that in a german university (in Experimental Physik), but not the name. I guess it falls under the broader concept of epistemology.
Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by warrenpj on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @03:57AM (#13469808)
How would one convey the scientific method in a single sentence?

What about the motto of the Royal Society: Nullius in verba; Take nobody's word for it.

Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by lngnmn on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @04:26AM (#13469928)
> How would one convey the scientific method in a single sentence?

Test it.

Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by rayalez on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @10:47AM (#13472253)
To find out the truth about how the world works - observe it, collect evidence, make a hypothesis that explains it, use it to make predictions, and do experiments to test them.
Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by vacri on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @03:09AM (#13469633)
While the scientific method is right up there, I'd say that the Golden Rule edges it out. Luckily it's not an either/or proposition :)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_rule

Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by warrenpj on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @03:44AM (#13469754)
The Golden Rule is flawed, as the Wikipedia article explains in the criticism section. Your comment bought to mind this quote from Deutsch:

"The Golden Rule (treat others as you would wish to be treated) has the same fatal flaw as future-is-like-the-past inductivism: it justifies anything and nothing, depending on what attributes of the other person you choose to imagine yourself having. And so, like induction, it only seems to yield some specific moral conclusion if you had already reached that conclusion by other means." - David Deutsch.

Here, "other means" is just the scientific method (conjecture, criticism) generalised to morality. So I'd say that the scientific method, (and a good epistemology in general), is a more valuable concept than the Golden Rule.

https://twitter.com/DavidDeutschOxf/status/25231910520029593...

Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by hueving on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @04:09AM (#13469850)
>treat others as you would wish to be treated

This is particularly problematic because it assumes you know everything about the other person's situation.

"If I were acting like that, I would be thankful if someone hit me in the face to make me realize how rude I was being."

"If I were poor, I would be grateful for someone who took away my government handouts so I became self-sustaining."

"If I were rich, I wouldn't mind being taxed at 98%."

Etc

Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @04:05PM (#13475436)
Yes, humans can rationalize anything. And yes, you don't know everything about the other person's situation. But the Golden Rule is still a huge step up from "Spend all your time trying to find ways to screw the other person over".
Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by vacri on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @04:36AM (#13469959)
Conversely, the scientific method has no human warmth to it. It doesn't give us much of a mechanism to build better societies given our human flaws. As an example: take the death of a loved one. The scientific method tells us "shit happens for no reason". The golden rule tells us to comfort our companion. Truth is a fine thing, but there are things in our experience that aren't limited to simple veracity of facts.

And just like there are people out there who disagree on what the golden rule means, so too are there people who disagree on the scientific method - I've lost count of the number of times that I've had to say here on HN that the scientific method extends beyond 'test the null hypothesis'.

> it justifies anything and nothing, depending on what attributes of the other person you choose to imagine yourself having.

Only if you apply it in a flawed or superficial manner. Heuving's example of "I'd like someone to punch me in the face" is a clear example of this. The scientific method has equally poor results if you apply it in a flawed or superficial manner.

In any case, regardless of opinion on which is better, they're both far more important to us as humans than atomic theory :)

Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by stcredzero on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @02:01PM (#13474375)
Conversely, the scientific method has no human warmth to it

"My songs are of time and distance. The sadness is in you."

https://www.goodreads.com/work/quotes/879764-count-zero

If the problem domain isn't amenable to the crude reductionism puny human brains are capable of, then there are other ways of "dealing with it." (Other than applying a hydraulic press.) Science can help you be a good dog owner, but not all of the problem solving strategies and wisdom most dog owners will be the scientific method. The same goes for being a human being.

Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by vog on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @03:36AM (#13469725)
I'd go one step further and recommend the logical conclusion of the Golden rule, the "Rechtsstaat", meaning "state of law":

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rechtsstaat

(Until now I didn't even know that this German word is also used in the English language.)

The "state of law" is a combination of the Golden rule (which works only within small groups) with some aspects of the scientific method (reproducible results and independence of the subject: If I do the same thing as somebody else, in the same circumstances, it should be equally okay. Or, if it is not okay, we both should face the same consequences).

Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by vog on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @03:01AM (#13469602)
Indeed! This principle enables a civilization to discover all important things they need, on their own, in a reasonable speed.

Having said that, I see two areas in science where we have serious issues.

1) In some sciences, strict application of scientific method is not possible in large scale, due to unhealthy influence from the outside.

The classic example from the middle age is the research on astronomy and physics being suppressed and/or heavily influenced by the church and political leaders.

Today, one of the best examples is research on economy. That is heavily influenced (and sometimes even paid) by various types of financially strong bodies. This leads to heavily biased results. Also, suddenly results become acceptable even though they are based on almost comically far-fetched assumptions.

2) In some sciences, the scientific method cannot be applied in all rigor, due to the nature of the topic of research.

For example, complex psychological tests cannot be done with a huge amount of people, because you won't find enough people doing so volutarily. Also, you can't simply repeat an experiment on the same human being, because are are influenced from and learned from the previous experiment, so will react differently than an "unused" human being.

Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by hueving on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @04:03AM (#13469830)
Economics falls under the second category quite a bit as well. In particular its hard to reason about impacts of individual policies on any kind of real complex economy because there are so many confounding variables. And it's not like you can conduct experiments because time travel isn't possible and no two economies are even similar, let alone the same.
Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by vog on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @04:21AM (#13469905)
I agree that the empirical part of economics is hard, but manageable in modern times [1]. However, the real problem is that even the theory has so many flaws, yet it is used as if it was evidence, which is why I think the real problem is 1).

[1] Some very popular multi-player games have a quite advanced economy, where the individual actions of each participant are recorded and can be analyzed. While this is not "real", it gives more detailed information about human economic interaction than all the mass surveillance in the "real word" right now. Also, the game developers have god-like powers in the virtual world, so they can run controlled experiments,. As far as I know, they already do so. And and if something goes really wrong, they still have the ultima ratio to reset everything to the state of a few hours or days ago. Or, they can re-interpret the last actions of the players in a more appropriate way. That may still make some players unhappy, but won't crash a real economy.

Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by cel1ne on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @03:28AM (#13469701)
" Any headline that ends in a question mark can be answered by the word 'no'. "

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge's_law_of_headlines

Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by stcredzero on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @02:05PM (#13474410)
In headline form: "Can Any Headline with a Question Mark be Answered by 'No?'"
Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history? by cel1ne on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @06:35PM (#13476867)
From the wikipedia article:

"As with similar "laws" (e.g., Murphy's law), it is intended as a humorous adage rather than always being literally true."