Re:Is atomic theory the most important idea in human history?
by stcredzero on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @02:01PM
(#13474375)
Conversely, the scientific method has no human warmth to it
"My songs are of time and distance. The sadness is in you."
https://www.goodreads.com/work/quotes/879764-count-zero
If the problem domain isn't amenable to the crude reductionism puny human brains are capable of, then there are other ways of "dealing with it." (Other than applying a hydraulic press.) Science can help you be a good dog owner, but not all of the problem solving strategies and wisdom most dog owners will be the scientific method. The same goes for being a human being.
And just like there are people out there who disagree on what the golden rule means, so too are there people who disagree on the scientific method - I've lost count of the number of times that I've had to say here on HN that the scientific method extends beyond 'test the null hypothesis'.
> it justifies anything and nothing, depending on what attributes of the other person you choose to imagine yourself having.
Only if you apply it in a flawed or superficial manner. Heuving's example of "I'd like someone to punch me in the face" is a clear example of this. The scientific method has equally poor results if you apply it in a flawed or superficial manner.
In any case, regardless of opinion on which is better, they're both far more important to us as humans than atomic theory :)