But they all run with reduced settings, and their non console versions offer higher quality on better hardware (if developers of course took care of taking advantage of that and make it all configurable).
So I'm really not sure how API can change the simple fact that current day consoles are underpowered in comparison with modern high end PC hardware.
Not sure what you mean by this. MGS V, for example, runs with more effects on PS4 than on my PC with Geforce 980Ti (which alone costs as much as two PS4s btw). Anyways, this conversation is stupid. It's not a Console vs PC flamewar. Nobody forbids you from buying a $10K PC with colored lights everywhere and setting all the settings to 11. And if you think it's a good business, this being an entrepreneur site, you should starting making those and selling to others, driving stupid console developers out of business and laughing while doing so.
Nonsense. Developers use hardware as well as they understand within given project constraints.
Optimizing modern game engine to run fast is generally considered a non-trivial task. The more arbitrary the hardware platform, the harder it is to optimize.
Yes, if PC port had to target only a specific, known, hardware and software combination (say a specifiv i7 with gtx 1080) then they could probably optimize the shit out of it.
A console is a fixed, known target. Thus it takes much less resources to optimize for it - thus developers can reuse their understanding from project to project.
The AAA game scene is full of recent examples with crawling PC ports, such as Arkham Knight.
> The AAA game scene is full of recent examples with crawling PC ports, such as Arkham Knight.
Poor quality games isn't an good example of proper hardware usage. There was a time when AAA meant quality. Today it can mean any junk as long as it's funded by big publisher.
By high end I mean demanding, those which heavily load the GPU, and benefit from better ones.
So IMHO those who stick to current day consoles, are OK with not getting the max settings in demanding games. But why those who do want more, can't play their games using controller / sofa style gaming? I.e. I don't see an inherent relation between console style gaming and avoiding more expensive hardware.