Re:Tesla brings online its 80 MWh Powerpack station with SoC...
by guelo on Monday January 23, 2017 @08:10PM
(#13467968)
I don't know why this article keeps using the word 'massive'. 20MW is tiny at utility scale. For comparison the typical pumped-storage station has 1,000-3,000MW capacity.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Tesla brings online its 80 MWh Powerpack station with SoC...
by the8472 on Monday January 23, 2017 @08:26PM
(#13468044)
Pumped-storage exploits pre-existing landscape features. Battery storage is essentially building storage from scratch in places where no favorable geological features exist.
How much would digging a mineshaft, a bedrock cavern and a lake or additional caverns just to pump water up and down cost?
Re:Tesla brings online its 80 MWh Powerpack station with SoC...
by throwaway91111 on Monday January 23, 2017 @08:39PM
(#13468107)
When weighted against cost and expected lifetime, it may not make sense to do this over e.g. solar + molten salt.
Re:Tesla brings online its 80 MWh Powerpack station with SoC...
by greglindahl on Monday January 23, 2017 @08:56PM
(#13468193)
Except that utility-scale thermal solar + molten salt doesn't exactly have a good track record so far. It'd be great if it lived up to expectations...
Re:Tesla brings online its 80 MWh Powerpack station with SoC...
by pokemon-trainer on Monday January 23, 2017 @08:28PM
(#13468053)
80 MWh is massive for a battery. MW are a measure of power, not energy. You mean MW-h. It's incorrect to say something has a MW capacity when discussing energy storage.
Re:Tesla brings online its 80 MWh Powerpack station with SoC...
by deathanatos on Monday January 23, 2017 @08:55PM
(#13468186)
> MW are a measure of power, not energy. You mean MW-h. It's incorrect to say something has a MW capacity when discussing energy storage.
He's quoting TFA,
> With a capacity of 20 MW/80 MWh
It would seem sensible that the system has both metrics: a total capacity of storage, and a total rate at which it can supply that storage to things connected to it.
Further, my understanding is that the parent you're responding to is correct: pumped-storage hydro tends to have much greater generation rates; Wikipedia lists an example of 360MW.
Re:Tesla brings online its 80 MWh Powerpack station with SoC...
by Dylan16807 on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:40PM
(#13468634)
Batteries have inherently high MW per MWh so you can usually ignore the power capacity. But that's not true with everything. Both numbers are important.