News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by chris_7 on Monday January 23, 2017 @06:58PM (#13467509)
Really, I just want a 9-to-5, instead of a 9-to-8 + "oh hey quick question" notification from Slack at 11.
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by mjfl on Monday January 23, 2017 @07:51PM (#13467875)
Seriously, 9-5 is the dream. This article is so filled with naive melodrama. Does this person realize how much effort it takes to kill, pluck, and dress a single chicken? to grow a single ear of corn? Things you might eat in a single meal? Someone has to "slave" themselves away to grow that for you. They can't just quit and become a poet, if they did the author would starve. That attitude is the definition of childish because it always assumes that someone is going to be there to provide for you, whether it is the state, some rich patron, or your actual parents.
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by chillwaves on Monday January 23, 2017 @08:44PM (#13468126)
You do realize that efficiencies in agriculture means our country alone has more than the capacity to feed the entire world?

Second consideration, no one opts in to capitalism. You are simply born into a situation with scarce access to natural resources (fenced off by the rich and powerful). Now, it only seems fair to me that a person has to ability to opt out, if we wanted to level the playing field between workers and owners. That is the price of civilization.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by pjlegato on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @03:52AM (#13469784)
You can absolutely opt out of capitalism, and many have: you can get some likeminded people together and start a commune, or you can go sleep on a park bench and panhandle, or you can just leave and move to Cuba or North Korea. Nobody will stop you or hinder you in any way.

However, you cannot opt out of socialism. "Not having a job" is illegal in socialist countries. Don't like the job that was assigned to you by some bureaucrat? Want to start a mini-free market with your friends? Too bad, the alternative is the labor camps.

The border guards in capitalist countries are there to prevent illegal immigration into the country. The border guards in socialist countries are there to keep people from escaping.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by audunw on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @05:15AM (#13470144)
FYI, there's nothing inherently socialist about what you describe. It's an artifact of countries that tried to implement communism in one way specifically.

Socialism at its core is simply the social ownership and democratic control of the means of production.

It's pretty common to consider social democracy a form or derivative of socialism, and personally I think its the form of government that has come closest to the socialist ideals, even though they didn't fully implement it the way classical socialists or communists imagined.

Communism just replaced the capitalists with a political elite. There's no difference between communism in practice, and simply one big corporation running everything. The people didn't gain social ownership, and certainly not democratic control.

Planned economy was naive. But having a democratic state have majority ownership in large, key corporations that compete in an otherwise free market gets to the social ownership/democratic control part, but without the oppressive government part that inevitably results from the naive approach to achieving socialist ideals.

> you can get some likeminded people together and start a commune

You still have to buy the land. Probably you wouldn't have too much trouble finding relatively cheap and fertile land still, but it might be getting harder. It's not like you can just settle down wherever and live off the land.

I think the main problem here is that if you'd like to grow a non-capitalist economy, you have absolutely no state support. All laws are written with capitalism assumed. So non-capitalist approaches have little chance to grow beyond a single commune. In fact, even if you tried to grow a new capitalist economy (in the sense of doing trade, not in the sense of Marx' definition), which isn't the state sanctioned variety of capitalism, you'd probably get jailed. Try starting a set of communes that trade goods with your own gold-standard currency, see what happens.

So no, you can't opt out. You, personally, if you have enough money, can perhaps do a big one-time purchase which will let you partly opt out for just you and maybe a few other people. But you don't really get to have any economic activity with more than a handful of people.

> or you can go sleep on a park bench and panhandle

I don't think that's what the parent post had in mind. That's not really opting out at all. You're completely dependent on capitalism for surviving that way, even if you don't have a job yourself.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by erikpukinskis on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @10:47PM (#13478292)
> You can absolutely opt out of capitalism, and many have: you can get some likeminded people together and start a commune... Nobody will stop you or hinder you in any way.

This is patently false. If I go find a nearby piece of unused arable land to farm the police will arrest me and throw me in jail. If I try to trade milk for bread with my neighbor the police will arrest me and throw me in jail. If I build a house using indigenous materials the police will arrest me and throw me in jail.

Not immediately, but if I stick to my guns in any of these practices the legal path ends with me in jail. Maybe I can avoid enforcement through secrecy, but that doesn't make it any less illegal.

Many counties in the U.S. have made it illegal to live outside the capitalist system.

And your suggestion that no one will hassle you for sleeping on a park bench is completely absurd. People sleeping on park benches are perhaps the biggest target of police harassment of anyone.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by legulere on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @05:40AM (#13470277)
> start a commune,

That does not mean you are not part of the capitalist society anymore. You have to get enough capital to get land and you will have to continue paying taxes.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by chillwaves on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:57PM (#13473735)
I would say the most offensive/dishonest aspect of this loaded statement is basically the implied isolation of "you guys go over there, leave the world to us" -- as if only the capitalists can claim the inherited knowledge of humanity (fenced off with copyright laws etc). As if only the capitalists, who have taken so many (all) natural resources, have a right to the land we are born on and we must slave to pay for small parcel of land just to exist. How exactly is that "opting out" of capitalism again?

It's more akin to playing socialism than actually living in it.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by badsock on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:52PM (#13468423)
Just to further your point:

http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SL.AGR.EMPL.ZS

Employment in agriculture (% of total employment) of the USA: %2.

If we could provide shelter and clothing with similar efficencies, the question of having to work just to survive ends up in a very different place than it has done historically.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by mjfl on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:05PM (#13468487)
I mean, what's stopping you? Just pool some money, buy some plots of land, and then 2% of you at a time can rotate into doing the farm work - the rest of you can just do poetry. Utopian society in an instant. Wow, modern technology!

Also: shameless plug for my blog post https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13467783

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by mjfl on Monday January 23, 2017 @08:55PM (#13468191)
So who's going to grow your food while you "opt out"?
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by nothrabannosir on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:00PM (#13468225)
The people who labeled the earth we were given as their property, and who deny us access to it?

I'm a staunch free market supporter, but OP is right: you're lucky if you like this competitive society we were born in. If you don't like our rules, we screw you. You can't just up and move to a fertile plot of land without anyone bothering you, anymore. The least we can do is recognize that.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by wernercd on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:07PM (#13468255)
But the technology IS approaching that can make a basement a place to grow food. How much longer until we can literally grow food anywhere that has electricity?
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by chillwaves on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:17PM (#13468286)
There is a cost to the existing world order. Right now it costs on average over $40,000 a year to put someone in jail in America -- for breaking the social contract. It seems fair to me that the rich, in return for being the few who own so much, pay for someone to live and not die in the streets if they do not want to work (a pittance).

We have the resources as a society, so scarcity is not a compelling retort. Secondly, the resources are being used anyway (welfare, prison, police), arguably inefficiently and can be done without needless suffering and waste of human potential.

If the owner class is going to close access to resources we need to live, it is the right of the worker class to break the social order. Your assertion that people who recognize this hierarchy of power as "childish" seems unfair. And the real reason why basic income is untenable for the rich is that it gives too much negotiating power to those who work for a living, because they would not die in the streets if they were to opt out. That reality greatly undermines any notion of freedom in the economic sense. Time is money and it seems the rich get to take both from the poor with impunity.

edit since I can't reply: Did you read my comment? Somehow you are under the strange perception that the rich people, who own literally almost everything are at the worse end of the deal wrt to subsidizing sustenance living for the poor. To answer your question: anyone can grow the food, but no one will be forced to.

Does it occur to you that the owners are actually doing nothing (if they choose) while everyone else grows THEIR food and provides an endless list of goods and services? I see you don't have a problem with this system, which is strange since you are so insistent that everyone must work for their food.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by literallycancer on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:30PM (#13468341)
>it is the right of the worker class to break the social order

This line of reasoning isn't very useful, since it doesn't matter what is "right" or "just", only what's realistic or at least possible. The "worker class" can't break the social order, or at least not in a way that improves their situation.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by cmdrfred on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:19PM (#13468545)
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by gaius on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:59AM (#13469145)
The "worker class" can't break the social order, or at least not in a way that improves their situation.

It's far too soon to say how Brexit and Trump will ultimately play out. Scrapping the TPP for example (the TTIP already having been killed by the same forces).

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by chillwaves on Monday January 23, 2017 @11:42PM (#13468857)
It would be interesting to hear your thoughts on the rest of what I wrote, specifically why owners are exempt from working for what they consume while consuming so much.
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by SomeStupidPoint on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:03PM (#13468481)
Sure they can.

Torches, gasoline, and guns do wonders to motivate social change.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by literallycancer on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @02:59PM (#13474907)
And then everyone's quality of life will drop, including the people who initiated the changes.
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by allenbrunson on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:18PM (#13468538)
you seem to be making the assumption that there have to be crap jobs, and that somebody has to do them. the only reason there are crap jobs is because there are people to do those jobs who don't have any choice.

suppose for a moment that everybody has fulfilling work in their lives, or they are independently wealthy. suddenly, nobody wants to be garbage men, or work the counter at mcdonalds, and so on. in the case of the garbage men, local communities won't have much choice: they will either have to pay more, or make the job more attractive somehow: better trucks, better working hours, and so on. and maybe fast food places just won't be economically viable anymore, if you can't get high school kids to work for you for practically nothing. no big loss. and if it turns out that some people do perceive that as a big loss, then prices are going to go up, instead.

there doesn't have to be soul-crushing jobs. that's just a consequence of the societal rules we live under right now.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by mjfl on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:30PM (#13468592)
> you seem to be making the assumption that there have to be crap jobs, and that somebody has to do them. the only reason there are crap jobs is because there are people to do those jobs who don't have any choice.

Actually, the only reason that there are crap jobs is that someone needs to do the crap job. If that wasn't the case, no one would pay you to do it. The whole point of money is to make people do things they wouldn't normally want to do - like farm, clean toilets, kill a cow, or build buildings in the rain. And it's a good thing that money does that, it keeps us fed. It keeps society moving.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by chillwaves on Monday January 23, 2017 @11:41PM (#13468854)
Is that why the people that do the crap jobs get paid the least? Or maybe there are systemic power imbalances and threatened violence for the poor.
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by guiambros on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:06PM (#13468493)
> This article is so filled with naive melodrama.

Well, of course it has to be full of complexities and life melodrama; this is Bukowski after all. It is his trademark.

But his life story has a beautiful twist, which unfortunately is not covered in OP's piece. From the interview[1] with John Martin, his longtime friend and editor, and the guy who paid the $100 per month:

"We sat down with a little piece of paper. I sat there with a pen, and he listed out all of his monthly expenses—and you've got to remember, this was 1965, when his rent was $35 a month. He had $15 in child support, $3 for cigarettes, $10 for liquor, and another $15 for food. And yet, even though that sounds pitifully small, at the time he was feeding himself and had nice clothes, drove a very old car, and lived in this completely or partially destroyed unit in East Hollywood. He could get along on $100 a month. I was only earning $400 a month, so I was giving him 25 percent of my income. But as soon as the thing took off we did much better.

At the very end, I paid him a retainer so I wouldn't owe him some horrible amount of money. Eventually I paid him $10,000 every two weeks. So he went from $100 every month to $10,000 every two weeks, and then, at the end of the year, I'd make up whatever I still owed him. Later, the really big money came in when we started to sell his books for movies and stuff like that."

[1] https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/bukowskis-longtime-publis...

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by vmeson on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @09:50PM (#13478037)
To put the initial amount in context: $100 in 1965 equals ~$760 in 2016. (http://www.saving.org/inflation/inflation.php?amount=100&yea...)
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by intrasight on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:30PM (#13468591)
I read Bukowski in the '80s but I never read ABOUT Bukowski - so I found this very interesting
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by lapsock on Monday January 23, 2017 @08:12PM (#13467976)
No, you just lack breadth in your understanding of life. People have different personalities, Bukowski clearly had a personality that caused him to despise the 9-5 work environment. He grww up with people telling him if he didn't work 9-5 he would be a dirty bum hippie. That explains his hatred for the 9-5.
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by damontal on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:54PM (#13468436)
Well he was kind of a dirty bum.
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by intrasight on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:33PM (#13468604)
And a dirty old man
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by Swizec on Monday January 23, 2017 @08:47PM (#13468142)
Turns out that if you create an excuse to leave on time (kids, gym class, whatever), people will generally let you leave on time and won't question it.

If you disable notifications you won't feel the urge to reply to messages. You can't reply to what you can't see.

If anyone questions your loyalty, explain that jobs come and go, but you [and your family etc] are forever. If they keep pushing, explain that you will gladly behave like a cofounder in exchange for a paltry 20% stake in the company.

They usually leave you alone after that.

Caveat: this only works if you're good at what you do and difficult to replace.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by flukus on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:21PM (#13468552)
> Caveat: this only works if you're good at what you do and difficult to replace.

So it only works for a minority of people then. I'd also say "or difficult to replace", the ones that are good at what they do tend to make themselves replaceable.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by Swizec on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:30PM (#13468590)
You'd be surprised. Just knowing how the org works and knowing the internal lingo makes you really annoying to replace. Onboarding people takes a lot of time and effort. Finding ones you're even willing to onboard is even harder.

But if you're just stacking boxes, you might not have enough leverage.

Everyone who reads HN probably has enough leverage to set boundaries.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by TheSmiddy on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:53AM (#13469347)
"Everyone who reads HN probably has enough leverage to set boundaries."

I'm reading this at work while installing windows updates on a desktop PC for a client, don't be so sure.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by Swizec on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @02:15AM (#13469436)
I bet the client is terrified of doing it themselves and is paying oodless of money for the assurance that the computer will now and forever Just Work. And if it doesn't it's your fault and not theirs.

Being a scapegoat can be very profitable.

How does the saying go again? Nobody ever got fired fot buying IBM? Something like that.

Being the scapegoat is a valuable service if you do it well.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by learc83 on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:55PM (#13468446)
I managed to do it when I was a lowly Geek Squad employee during college. I always had an excuse prepared ahead of time in case someone asked me to stay late, and I was just generally prepared to say no to ridiculous requests.
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by losteric on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:03PM (#13468239)
I realize it really depends on individual situations, but let me just say this: I have no problems managing a 9-5:30 work-life at Amazon.

Employers, customers, and coworkers tend to overestimate the importance of their issue. Employees tend to underestimate how much they can push back, prioritize, or say "no". The answer is not long working hours.

If everyone is accustomed to your 9-8 work hours, it might take time to roll back... but it can be done.

And if your company refuses to give you a reasonable work-life balance? Leave.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by jboggan on Monday January 23, 2017 @07:35PM (#13467770)
Don't answer.
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by mistersquid on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:57PM (#13468452)
I've taken to signing out of Slack on my mobile phone every evening and signing back in in the morning.

Works like a charm.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by emteycz on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @07:57AM (#13470922)
I simply don't have slack on my personal mobile phone. Works even better.
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by mistersquid on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:07PM (#13473188)
That does work even better.

In my case, my personal and work mobile phones are one the same (company pays for data), so I'm expected to be at least Slack-responsive during business hours.

Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by TomMarius on Wednesday January 25, 2017 @06:22AM (#13480514)
Same in my case, but 99% when I'm able to respond during business hours, I'm sitting in front of a computer. If it's an emergency, a phone call is more suitable anyways. Sure there was this one time when I had to use Slack from my phone browser (set to desktop mode), but it's a small sacrifice.
Re:Charles Bukowski: The Slavery of the 9 to 5 by Vinkekatten on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @06:04AM (#13470424)
Hell, I love my 9-5 dev job in government sector. Almost never overtime, decent pay, great colleagues and I get enough say and time to shape my work a little.