Favorite pencil: Rotring 500 0.5mm, with Pilot Neox 4B lead. I never much liked pencils before I found this lead. It's the softest I've found in 0.5mm, softer than most brands of 4B. It lets you write with very little pressure so it feels more like using a pen. The Rotring 500 has the same solid and reliable mechanism as the famous Rotring 600, but a plastic body so it's cheaper and lighter. But despite being a good pencil, I can't recommend it as strongly as the Lamy Safari because of one major flaw - it has no end cap. I reserve it for desktop use because the end pipe is completely unprotected and fragile.
I have no strong preferences for paper and IMO a good writing implement should work with any common paper.
If you meant that you want the thickness of the ink to vary with angle, then yes - most modern fountain pens are designed that way. However, they do also make the "italic" type ones.
Personally, one of the reasons I like fountain pens is that I don't have to apply pressure. :-)
One thing i do with all fountain pens are to resurface the nibs using dremel or grinding on any fine surface. Basically a hit and trial to get fine calligraphy like quality, writing after that is more consistent and in control.
Paper: Still working this out - finding a good diary-style notebook that fountain pens don't bleed through is a real challenge. I've had good luck with a Daler Rowney sketchbook, but I find that I'm missing the lines.
For notebooks, I need something that opens flat and stays flat, so I need a binder. I found these Blue Sky notebooks at Walgreens and really like the look and feel of them: https://www.bluesky.com/blue-sky-trade-black-5-75-x-8-5-note...
Almost two decades later, only a few months ago, I decided to give them another try.
Fantastic stuff. I use a Pilot Metropolitan MR. Medium nib. But one does need to purchase higher quality paper than what you'll find in regular stores. These days I write on Figurare notebooks.
I can't believe I wrote with ballpoints all these years. Fountain pens are so much better. I now look for excuses to take notes on paper.
The notebook strikes a balance of quality (but not heirloom quality so you don't want to touch it), cost, and portability.
I discovered the original Pilot Precise pen in high school for writing left handed without smearing ink. It has been my go-to pen for years, and the retractable version is a welcome convenience.
Only for note taking though, I'm not happy about erasable ink on official forms.
I ordered a bunch of pens from Jet Pens a year ago and my favorite also ended up being one of the cheapest - the Pilot Hi-Tec-C.
My favorite notebook used to be an engineering notebook. It had a grid on one side of the page and college-ruled lines on the other and had a spiral bound spine. Not sure if I have a favorite any more. I do use a lot of index cards.