News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by jakeogh on Sunday January 22, 2017 @01:26PM (#13456379)
"shifted around" is nice euphemism for theft.
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by anonfunction on Sunday January 22, 2017 @01:42PM (#13456463)
With that logic all taxes and social policies are theft.
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by jakeogh on Sunday January 22, 2017 @01:47PM (#13456499)
Correct. Personal taxes (taking things via threat of force) are theft. It does not matter who is doing the taking.
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by dasil003 on Sunday January 22, 2017 @03:02PM (#13457055)
You would not have been in a position to earn any of the money you have without public infrastructure paid for by taxes. Maybe you would have been successful under an anarchy, but I doubt that is the case for the majority of HN'ers, and my best guess is that your ideological position would crumble pretty quickly if you were forced to live in the world which you ostensibly desire. Fortunately for everyone I can't see that happening without massive death and destruction.
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by jakeogh on Sunday January 22, 2017 @04:46PM (#13457733)
I'm not advocating Anarchy. That's never going to work. We need laws, and I would love to change the laws regarding the income tax.
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by frio on Sunday January 22, 2017 @08:49PM (#13459050)
Who enforces the law? How does their labour get paid for?
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by jakeogh on Sunday January 22, 2017 @08:57PM (#13459083)
Why would you think a tax on personal income is the only way to do that?
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by frio on Sunday January 22, 2017 @09:26PM (#13459223)
I didn't say it was :). What alternative do you propose?
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by jakeogh on Sunday January 22, 2017 @09:50PM (#13459334)
Numerous states haven't had a problem with it even though they have no personal income tax.

http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/personalfinance/2013/03/...

Re:Why we should all have a basic income by frio on Sunday January 22, 2017 @11:38PM (#13459805)
Right -- so those 7 states listed in the article have alternative forms of tax (corporate income tax, oil-production taxes, etc.). Are you opposed solely to personal income taxes (while still supporting alternative forms of tax), or are you opposed to all taxation?
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by jakeogh on Monday January 23, 2017 @12:25AM (#13459986)
Personal income tax only. In general, I believe individuals are the best deciders on how to spend their money, but I do not deny that gov has a responsibility to defend life, liberty and property. If it can't do that with the voluntary support of it's citizens (aka owners) then it deserves to be replaced. Fortunately we have a pretty awesome system to do exactly that.

I was too glib (wrong) in my second response to the assertion that my statement implies all social policies are theft.

Re:Why we should all have a basic income by frio on Monday January 23, 2017 @03:21PM (#13465596)
I see; fair enough :). I'm not personally opposed to personal income tax, but I'm from a country that leans a little more to the left overall and the benefits of my taxation are evident. It's also less vexing; the tax comes directly out of my paycheque -- I never see that money. My understanding is that in the USA, one has to annually perform a federal tax return?

I'm not exactly pro-income tax either, but (governed effectively!) personal income tax has always seemed to me like a least-worst solution to funding a government and a country's public infrastructure. It's not great, but it provides the least opportunity for mass rorting (although that no longer seems to be true, the more I think on it). I could be convinced that other solutions work :).

Re:Why we should all have a basic income by jakeogh on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:26AM (#13469030)
Thanks :) Yes, every year we are expected to fill out a bunch of paperwork (generally between 1 and 100 pages) and hand it in by a certain date "or else". The bureaucracy that interprets this paperwork (imho) is a total waste of money (on the personal income tax side), and the time_cost*every_taxpayer is absurd.

For most people, their employer took out (in excess) taxes all year and sent them in, so they get a refund (after the paperwork ritual) on the loan they made to the gov with 0% interest.

I'm not a fan on taxes on things you own because it means you don't _really_ own them. For example a person who owns a piece of property but can not pay the property tax. It gets taken from them by force if necessary, hence they never really owned it. At the very least we should carve out an exemption for property you live on. Transaction taxes don't have that problem.

Re:Why we should all have a basic income by EliRivers on Sunday January 22, 2017 @02:29PM (#13456803)
You have redefined the English language for your own propaganda purposes. This significantly degrades any chance of you being taken seriously.
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by vostok on Sunday January 22, 2017 @02:36PM (#13456859)
It's not necessarily for propaganda purposes, but I agree that this is a highly nonstandard terminology and it's not obvious to me that it improves anyone's ability to communicate.
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by prodmerc on Sunday January 22, 2017 @05:44PM (#13458081)
Glad you are and always will be a millionaire who doesn't use any public services and will never need to worry about hospital bills, housing or food.

Otherwise you're an idiot.

Re:Why we should all have a basic income by jakeogh on Sunday January 22, 2017 @05:58PM (#13458161)
You know we had hospitals, housing assistance and food assistance before the personal income tax right? A personal income tax is just one way we fund gov services, there are plenty of other options that don't require a gun to the head.

Alaska, Florida, Nevada, South Dakota, Texas, Washington, and Wyoming have no state level personal income tax.

Re:Why we should all have a basic income by woofyman on Sunday January 22, 2017 @08:19PM (#13458912)
Alaska and Texas have oil. Florida has tourists. Wyoming has coal.
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by TheCoelacanth on Sunday January 22, 2017 @05:58PM (#13458162)
You say taxation is theft. Anarchists say that the fact that you have any property that can be taxed is theft. This is a matter of opinion, not an indisputable fact.
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by raintrees on Sunday January 22, 2017 @02:32PM (#13456823)
Thank you. If my seizing my neighbor's extra car because I do not have one is theft, it is still theft if I convince a majority to pass a law take it for me. And it is enforced with the threat of (or actual) violence against my neighbor, if my neighbor refuses.
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by EliRivers on Sunday January 22, 2017 @02:41PM (#13456895)
Negative. Theft is a crime. Crime is defined by the criminal law. If you choose to have your own personal criminal law, so that you can call whatever you like theft, that's up to you, but if you're going to do that with language, you can claim anything is anything.
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by raintrees on Sunday January 22, 2017 @04:19PM (#13457544)
Okay, we disagree. (*edit: we disagree about taxes being theft). But that is what I enjoy about communicating with other intelligent people, we can discuss ideas and not have to agree.

I have been studying this in my free time for the last decade or so, and do not have a ready list of sources handy, but here are a few I gathered in the last 30 minutes, should you be curious as to why I think this way: https://mises.org/library/taxation-robbery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxation_as_theft

A very short list of sites containing general backgrounders: https://mises.org/ http://www.ronpaulcurriculum.com/ http://tomwoods.com/ https://www.freemansperspective.com/

A short list of sources on this direction of thinking to start with: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludwig_von_Mises https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedrich_Hayek https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murray_Rothbard

Much of this is intertwined in Libertarianism, Austrian Economics, and even Minarchy/Anarchy.

I obey the laws of the jurisdiction that I reside in, but that does not mean that I am not trying to actively change those laws for what I perceive as "the better"...

I search for as close an approximation to "the best way" as I can, understanding that humans are fallible by nature.

For entertainment, I am re-reading the book A Lodging of Wayfaring Men, a fictional book by Paul Rosenberg. While it is in severe need of editing (self-published?) I find it entertaining enough to re-read to get excited/stimulated about the possibilities of correcting systems that I consider to be operating very inefficiently, or flat out wrong.

[dead]
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by sctb on Monday January 23, 2017 @04:01PM (#13465980)
Please no personal attacks like this on HN, no matter what you're replying to.
Re:Why we should all have a basic income by briantakita on Sunday January 22, 2017 @02:50PM (#13456966)
Theft is a crime committed by another citizen. Redistribution of wealth is a "social program" committed by the State. See, with language, you can justify anything. One can make anything legal or illegal. It all depends on which Entity is saying those words. That's the nature of political power...

"A traitor is everyone who does not agree with me." ---George III of the United Kingdom

Re:Why we should all have a basic income by psyc on Sunday January 22, 2017 @01:44PM (#13456476)
Such a statement is only meaningful if the rules and systems that distribute wealth are sufficiently orderly and broadly considered fair. In a system considered to be significantly arbitrary or rigged, the whole concept of ownership is seriously weakened.