News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You Can Change Your Personality by nxc18 on Saturday January 21, 2017 @02:05PM (#13451499)
People often use "its just my personality" as an excuse for bad behavior. Intuitively I think most people know that you have control over your behavior at the very least as well as aspects of your personality. Just like any other activity, you can practice being a more considerate, or more respectful, or less neurotic personality.

There is a weird meme that tech people aren't capable of being "team players" or working with other people. Maybe research will help address that perception; awkward is ok, but we shouldn't accept that techies will be dicks to people all the time.

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by underwater on Saturday January 21, 2017 @04:58PM (#13452362)
It is a really counter productive meme. My theory is that engineers are so comfortable using logic to solve problems, and viewing solutions as right or wrong that they fail to adapt when there are shades of grey.

Get a bunch engineers in a room and they'll argue forever about a solution because they don't understand their own biases or how emotion is clouding people's judgement. Bringing a bit of empathy can resolve these impasses so much more quickly.

The most effective technical people I've met have combined intelligence with an ability to get people on board with their vision.

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by mememachine on Saturday January 21, 2017 @09:13PM (#13453207)
>It is a really counter productive meme. My theory is that engineers are so comfortable using logic to solve problems, and viewing solutions as right or wrong that they fail to adapt when there are shades of grey.

Youre going wrong trying to paint engineers with a brush this broad.

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by underwater on Sunday January 22, 2017 @05:36AM (#13454588)
In my experience engineers will discuss if a solution is correct or incorrect, as though there is one global truth. But I rarely see discussions that acknowledge people have biases and that leads to differing opinions on correctness.

I follow some developer advocates on Twitter who get very angry at engineers who don't prioritise web performance above everything else (UX, accessibility, features, actually shipping code). Given their experience battling bad performance all day every day this is understandable. But from the perspective of someone who is trying to juggle a million priorities this comes across as crazy.

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by wfbbiue on Monday January 23, 2017 @03:38AM (#13460764)
"republicans see everything in black and white, democrats see every shade of grey"
Re:You Can Change Your Personality by tw04 on Saturday January 21, 2017 @02:41PM (#13451683)
I've always wondered, given this "stereotype" if there isn't more to it. Is it possible that because, in general, people who were "nerds" were likely more of a social outcast growing up, that they have essentially become "hardened", if you will, to social graces. They spent so much of their developmental years being teased/ridiculed/whatever that what is "normal" treatment of others has essentially become foreign to them? Sure, you can form a relationship with your family, but that really doesn't extend to how you interact with people outside of your inner circle.

There seems to be such a strong correlation, curious if anyone has ever studied it. It seems we've gotten to the point that so very much of our adult behavior can be traced to childhood events/upbringing that this can't be an outlier.

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by dpark on Saturday January 21, 2017 @04:29PM (#13452249)
I think this is mostly an effect of nerds not wanting to be exclusionary and therefore enabling this kind of behavior. If you're a nerd and you're kind of a prick, other nerds will tend to excuse it rather than just pushing you away. They'll disregard your behavior and keep inviting you to events. They'll ignore the fact that you're unpleasant when bonuses/promos are being handed out at work because it should be based on merit, as if there's no merit in behaving sociably. They'll generally look the other way because the alternatives are to be confrontational (which most people, including nerds, don't want to do) or to exclude you.

On the other hand, if you're not a nerd and you act like a prick, people will just start to cut you out of their lives. You won't get invited to social events. You probably won't get promoted because no one wants to work with you. Your behavior will impact your life. You can be a prick and be successful, but it's harder, because you have to balance it by being really good at something else. You're an amazing salesperson so you get rewarded despite being unpleasant. You're wealthy so people hang out with you even though you're rude.

The bar for nerds looking the other way seems to be lower. You're rude, but that's just how you are. Obviously there are limits even for nerds, but the limits seem to be pretty high.

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by g00gler on Saturday January 21, 2017 @05:57PM (#13452553)
Why not both?
Re:You Can Change Your Personality by qball on Saturday January 21, 2017 @07:58PM (#13452988)
To someone with an uncommon interest (a "nerd", in other words, though nerdy interests tend to require higher-than-average intelligence to possess), people with that interest are hard to find.

Once you finally meet someone sharing that interest, and it turns out that they act like a prick, you have a difficult choice (if you value sociable behavior over the opportunity to be social at all; willingly choosing isolation is frequently not a tenable position).

The cost and stakes for confrontation (and exclusion) are higher than it is in a "nerdier" group than for people with more common interests, simply because of the lack of people who are capable of the interest in the first place. So, more bad behaviors are tolerated. It's also worth noting that "bad" covers both "weird" and "malicious", which is also why groups with these interests tend to be much more accepting of people with other interests outside of those standard for the surrounding society.

The feedback loop is as such less; personality quirks don't get as rounded-off as they would in a less-exclusive group, so any conversions from asshole -> non-asshole in a small community will take longer if they even happen at all.

So, it should be no surprise that individuals more aware than most of the fact that "good people are hard to find" are willing to make certain sacrifices to retain them. For individuals whose interests and abilities involve a larger cross-section of the population, however, people are much more interchangeable, so excluding weird/malicious behavior is much easier.

As an example, consider the tech community's recent trend of attempting to exclude speakers with non-standard political views from conferences. The arguments for doing so come from people with the mindset that technology experts are interchangeable (which is valid in some areas), the arguments against it come from those who see technology experts as an unusually scarce resource (which is valid everywhere else in the world).

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by ArkyBeagle on Saturday January 21, 2017 @04:22PM (#13452227)
There is a scene in "Better Things" where Sam's oldest expresses a dread of the future because she'd spent all her time "being social" and felt unprepared. This when the school counselor had demonstrated that her options for college were quite limited.

This appears to be still encouraged, or at least not discouraged.

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by sametmax on Saturday January 21, 2017 @03:03PM (#13451786)
+1. Most asocial persons I know have been raised that way by society. Now you want them to undo what took years of training. This is hard. And unfair.
Re:You Can Change Your Personality by mseebach on Saturday January 21, 2017 @05:32PM (#13452466)
That is true, but irrelevant. "He had a hard time in school, so we should tolerate him being an asshole" won't really fly.

Many racists were probably raised that way by society, too, and undoing that is probably both hard and unfair - but necessary and a reasonable prerequisite for being a part of polite society.

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by tw04 on Saturday January 21, 2017 @08:09PM (#13453009)
I think you're missing the point. "Being racist" is pretty easy to nip in the bud. Telling someone not to be mean to someone else just because they're insert non-white race is easy. Telling someone "when you say X, that doesn't even occur to you might be offensive, it upsets other people". Now repeat that for a thousand different social interactions, and tell me how easy it is.

"Don't be an asshole" is what? "Being an asshole" means different things to different people. THAT is the core of the issue.

For instance: I've got coworkers, who if they screw something up, I can just straight up say - that was wrong, do it this way next time, then we won't have an issue. For other coworkers that direct interaction would be the absolute end of the world. And instead you have to tap dance around until you eventually get to a state where you're fairly certain they know not to do what they did again.

Would it make me an asshole for not knowing one person can handle direct feedback, and others can't? Is it "being an asshole" for telling someone factual information without sugar coating? I don't think so, plenty of people out in the real world do, however.

And, quite frankly, most of the people who want direct feedback consider people who tapdance assholes because so much effort is wasted on getting to the point.

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by nagvx on Sunday January 22, 2017 @04:35AM (#13454434)
I generally agree with your idea that "don't be an asshole" is an incredibly subjective and unhelpful rule of thumb. However your comment that "being racist is pretty easy to nip in the bud" is just absurdly oversimplified.

A racist may live in fear of the criminality of (insert race here) without seeing the bigger picture of poverty that causes it. A racist may have a majority of bad experiences with (insert race here) without realising their own prejudice was to blame.

Racism isn't "being mean", racism is potentially diverse set of prejudices and overly broad opinions that are founded on faulty logic or incomplete data. Racism can be propped up by an entire web of social beliefs and a lifetime of personal experience. Racists don't think they're "being mean", they think they hold sane, justifiable opinions against other "mean" or even "inferior" groups of people. Indeed, it may "not even occur to them they are being offensive".

The long and sordid history of racism around the globe can attest to the fact that racism is not something "easy to nip in the bud".

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by tw04 on Sunday January 22, 2017 @02:21PM (#13456736)
Stopping someone from fearing someone of a different race isn't easy. Stopping blatant racism in the workplace is. I think it's a bit of a stretch for you to assume I was talking about "eradicating racism from planet earth" when the context of the discussion was interacting with coworkers. CLEARLY when I said "nipping it in the bud is easy" I wasn't referring to the end of racism across the planet. That will LITERALLY be impossible until the point we have a unified culture globally: which I won't say will NEVER happen, but we're generations away if it ever does.
Re:You Can Change Your Personality by nagvx on Sunday January 22, 2017 @08:41PM (#13459015)
I wasn't assuming you were talking about "eradicating racism from planet earth" - that's a bit of a strawman. "Stopping blatant racism" is moving the goalposts, because "blatant" wasn't part of the original context.

As you say, you can stop someone overtly declaring their racism, but that doesn't mean they won't still covertly (or even unconsciously) continue with racist behaviors. Which is why it isn't so "clear", because even a simple situation with coworkers, you can be facing an uphill battle.

Anyway, I would wager we both broadly agree and this is now just a semantic argument.

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by apinstein on Sunday January 22, 2017 @03:05AM (#13454212)
Great analysis! Have you heard of the Birkman personality assessment? One of the components it measures is exactly what you describe (they call it Esteem).

It doesn't make you an asshole (intent) not to know that, but it does make your interactions less effective to not work "with the grain" of that dynamic.

At our company everyone takes the Birkman and we train everyone on how to leverage the knowledge it provides on your personality style and how that intersects with others' style. Whenever you're having trouble in an interpersonal interaction with someone, you can think about / looks at the profile and tweak your approach to improve things. It had been incredibly effective for making it easier, more effective, and more pleasant to work with others.

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by awfgylbcxhrey on Saturday January 21, 2017 @03:37PM (#13451985)
There is a weird meme that tech people aren't capable of being "team players" or working with other people.

This is purely anecdotal, but at one particularly memorable company, the head of HR would regularly make casual comments that cast the engineers as socially incapable and childish. Meanwhile, she was constantly offending people and her life was a chaotic mess.

At the same company, they always talked about team this and team that, but efforts to actually incorporate the team (e.g. clear communication, collaboration) were obviously seen as weak, and the "arrogant know it all" persona was rewarded.

I don't know how many of these things are simply cognitive dissonance, or poor communication, and which are deliberate efforts to gain power over others. Seems like a little of all three to me. I also think it's a convenient way for technically incompetent management to lord something over you. They may not understand your technical contributions, but they can finish the review by mentioning how you need to work on some undefined and arbitrary social aspect.

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by pjc50 on Saturday January 21, 2017 @03:58PM (#13452117)
"Not a team player" is a common euphemism for "won't compliantly do what I tell them".

(A common cause of these complaints is people hearing "we can't do that" as "we won't do that", mistaking impossibility for insubordination)

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by 77pt77 on Saturday January 21, 2017 @06:37PM (#13452733)
The common retort is that nothing is impossible.
Re:You Can Change Your Personality by 77pt77 on Saturday January 21, 2017 @06:37PM (#13452730)
> they always talked about team this and team that, but efforts to actually incorporate the team were obviously seen as weak, and the "arrogant know it all" persona was rewarded.

These are usually techniques to weed out people that the people defending those strategies think (consciously or not) are unfit. If you follow the advice you really are unfit and they will exclude you.

This is common across the board in social situations.

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by awfgylbcxhrey on Saturday January 21, 2017 @09:23PM (#13453239)
These are usually techniques to weed out people that the people defending those strategies think (consciously or not) are unfit.

I don't understand what you're trying to say.

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by 77pt77 on Sunday January 22, 2017 @06:13AM (#13454698)
They say one thing, expect that people follow it, but then only promote those that explicitly do not follow it, because in reality they want to promote people that do not follow that rhetoric but saying that outright invalidates the test.
Re:You Can Change Your Personality by _0ffh on Saturday January 21, 2017 @03:21PM (#13451887)
I'm not familiar with that meme, and I wonder how it came to be. Maybe from people who got on the nerves of others who do not suffer fools or lazy people gladly?

Personally, I work in a environment where most of my colleagues are also engineering professionals, and most everyone is friendly and helpful. And while probably being the most stereotypical tech nerd in my department, I still get occasional commendations for my good team play.

BUT...

even I will not for long put a good face for lazy whiners who would have me do their job for them, and hold their hand through every trivial aspect of things they should either already know, or be able to figure out for themselves with a bare minimum of brains and effort. And, unfortunately, those people are not quite unheard of.

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by dpark on Saturday January 21, 2017 @04:35PM (#13452275)
The meme is that tech people are generally just assholes. It is a pretty common meme, but I don't think it's actually true. Very few of the tech people I know are actually assholes. Most are quite pleasant, even the ones that are socially awkward.
Re:You Can Change Your Personality by mseebach on Saturday January 21, 2017 @05:37PM (#13452486)
It's rare now, but probably less so in the 80s/90s. The BOFH meme didn't come from nowhere, and there's also the quite strikingly sudden exodus of women from the field to consider.
Re:You Can Change Your Personality by dpark on Saturday January 21, 2017 @10:32PM (#13453447)
BOFH comes at least in part from putting people who don't want to do customer service into what are effectively customer service roles. You see this at food service locations where someone who hates customers ends up interacting with them. They end up being unpleasant. For roles like food service, the person eventually either gets fired or learns to be socially reasonable.

For technical support roles, this behavior gets a pass unless it's really egregious because the employee is supposedly hired for technical ability and not hospitality. Plus in these roles the "customer" is often another employee who's basically captive. So largely this is the result of messed up incentives.

You see the same issue, e.g., at the DMV. Largely the employees are fine, but there are always several who clearly don't want to be there and a couple who are actively unpleasant. The incentives are set up to enable this because customer service is not "job 1". The customers are captive and there's little pushing out unpleasant employees.

The relative lack of women is probably multifaceted but to the extent that it's related to antisocial geeks, I again think it's more to do with enabling the behavior than with the volume. A very small portion of the population can do severe damage if the rest allow it.

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by _0ffh on Saturday January 21, 2017 @11:07PM (#13453541)
The best character trait you could possibly have in a helping role is to genuinely enjoy the experience of having helped a person deserving help. Fortunately, I am blessed with that trait. But with that comes the challenge of sieving the "deserving" from the "undeserving", when everyone clamours for your time.
Re:You Can Change Your Personality by umberway on Sunday January 22, 2017 @06:44AM (#13454787)
My thought is that 'nerds' collaborate better despite poorer than average understanding of fellow humans. It's because their work and its success or failure are more objectively defined which makes organising and delegation of tasks relatively straightforward. So we can have thousands of scientists and engineers building the Large Super Hadron Collider while a Liberal Arts Department may be beset by bickering and feuds.
Re:You Can Change Your Personality by bambax on Sunday January 22, 2017 @05:52AM (#13454637)
Absolutely.

In a great text written in 1880, Émile Littré, author of a great French dictionary that took him over 15 years to write, says this:

> je suis corrigible, ayant de bonne heure compris qu’il était peu sage de répondre aux suggestions d’amendement «Je suis comme cela» [1]

> I can change, having grasped early that it's not very clever to answer "that's just how I am" to people giving you life advice [my translation]

[1] https://fr.wikisource.org/wiki/Page%3AEmile_Littre_-_Etudes_...

Re:You Can Change Your Personality by ArkyBeagle on Saturday January 21, 2017 @04:19PM (#13452218)
"Being a team player" may be meant to include being intellectually dishonest and/or groupthink.
Re:You Can Change Your Personality by refulgentis on Saturday January 21, 2017 @02:25PM (#13451602)
Over time, it seemed to me there was a strong correlation between the technical expertise of my co-workers and their ability to neuter anti-social behavior.

To be fair, I went from poorly funded startups and contracting work to BigCo.