News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by codehusker on Friday January 20, 2017 @05:34PM (#13447523)
Is there any person as trustworthy as Ladar Levison for a service like email or chat?

To my knowledge, he is one of the few that has gone to the mat for his users.

Re:Lavabit Reloaded by pvg on Friday January 20, 2017 @05:59PM (#13447658)
A good way to regain and build trust with users would have been to acknowledge his previous mistakes. Then at least you could say "he's been around the block, done it wrong and learned how to do it right". Instead, he writes:

"In August 2013, I was forced to make a difficult decision: violate the rights of the American people and my global customers or shut down. I chose Freedom."

That isn't what happened. He chose to build and sell a supposedly secure email service that was fundamentally vulnerable to government intrusion. He then decided to play chicken with the USG over a warrant no different than ones he'd complied with previously. The completely pointless escalation forced him to compromise all of his users, something the government had not been asking for. He then shut the service down.

There are a lot of ways to describe this but 'I chose Freedom' without any acknowledgment of his previous mis-steps is both misleading and shameless. I wouldn't buy supposedly secure services from him.

Re:Lavabit Reloaded by ycmbntrthrwaway on Friday January 20, 2017 @06:20PM (#13447752)
> The completely pointless escalation forced him to compromise all of his users

How has he compromised all of his users? The service was shut down and emails kept encrypted. Am I missing something?

Re:Lavabit Reloaded by pvg on Friday January 20, 2017 @06:30PM (#13447804)
He gave up the cert, there was no PFS-only configuration, plus, presumably the FBI got to do their surveillance except instead of the target's email, they could read everyone's. So no, you are not right.
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by ycmbntrthrwaway on Friday January 20, 2017 @06:43PM (#13447863)
I was not aware he gave up the cert in the end. Thought he just closed website without disclosing TLS cert. Now it looks way worse than I imagined.

Anyway, I really hope that it leads to adoption of backward-compatible and secure email protocols. Server encryption can't be trusted anymore anyway, we need end-to-end encryption.

Re:Lavabit Reloaded by pvg on Friday January 20, 2017 @06:53PM (#13447919)
The business with the cert was just the final outcome. The initial mistake was making and selling snake oil. It is possible for someone to innocently do this, out of inexperience and ignorance.

Over time, though, it's become increasingly clear Ladar Levison is just a snakeoil salesman who misled his users. He's never acknowledged he did anything wrong. Don't fall for his posturing about 'Freedom'.

Re:Lavabit Reloaded by jevinskie on Saturday January 21, 2017 @03:20AM (#13449361)
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by Spone on Friday January 20, 2017 @07:00PM (#13447958)
Do you have a source for these claims?
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by ctrl_freak on Friday January 20, 2017 @07:29PM (#13448077)
From what I read, he gave up the SSL cert by printing out a hard copy in a tiny font, and when he was ordered to provide a digital copy, he shut down the service.

> At approximately 1:30 p.m. CDT on August 2, 2013, Mr. Levison gave the F.B.I. a printout of what he represented to be the encryption keys needed to operate the pen register. This printout, in what appears to be four-point type, consists of eleven pages of largely illegible characters.

And:

> On August 8th, rather than turning over the master key, Levison shut down Lavabit.

That was according to this article from the New Yorker: http://www.newyorker.com/tech/elements/how-lavabit-melted-do...

Re:Lavabit Reloaded by tylersmith on Friday January 20, 2017 @09:54PM (#13448498)
How big was that key? 11 pages at 4pt is a lot of characters. I wonder what encoding.
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by hornetblack on Saturday January 21, 2017 @01:43AM (#13449174)
Hex maybe?
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by BinaryIdiot on Friday January 20, 2017 @07:37PM (#13448111)
To be fair you have to acknowledge how society is essentially driven through tales of one's bolstered narrative. Many consider us in a "post facts" era given how you can watch almost any politician (some far worse than others) go on live television and say something that is completely untrue but it tells a fantastic story. Elections are won based on being able to sell a narrative.

While I agree with you I think a large amount of people will buy into the narrative of him sticking up for freedom.

Re:Lavabit Reloaded by KirinDave on Friday January 20, 2017 @08:06PM (#13448209)
The extent to which these narratives work is proportional to how much we accept them. No one can stop him from telling lies but we can make sure people know they're lies.
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by danielpatrick on Friday January 20, 2017 @09:42PM (#13448463)
Source? So many hacks in this thread. Why trust any of this?
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by pvg on Friday January 20, 2017 @09:58PM (#13448507)
What's your question?
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by curun1r on Friday January 20, 2017 @10:43PM (#13448623)
If Edward Snowden started a mail service, I'd probably trust it more. If you want to talk about "going to the mat" for people, I think Snowden has made the bigger sacrifice.

Moxie and Whisper Systems probably would get my nod too. Perhaps even DJB or Bruce Schnier.

Re:Lavabit Reloaded by nommm-nommm on Saturday January 21, 2017 @12:07AM (#13448929)
Moxie is not impressed with lavabit as lavabit's entire security model relied on "we totally promise we won't look at your private key."

https://moxie.org/blog/lavabit-critique/

>Unlike the design of most secure servers, which are ciphertext in and ciphertext out, this is the inverse: plaintext in and plaintext out. The server stores your password for authentication, uses that same password for an encryption key, and promises not to look at either the incoming plaintext, the password itself, or the outgoing plaintext.

>The ciphertext, key, and password are all stored on the server using a mechanism that is solely within the server’s control and which the client has no ability to verify. There is no way to ever prove or disprove whether any encryption was ever happening at all, and whether it was or not makes little difference

Anyways, having good inventions doesn't equal having a secure product.

Re:Lavabit Reloaded by ycmbntrthrwaway on Saturday January 21, 2017 @08:47AM (#13450008)
This one is about old Lavabit. It equals "trustful mode" of the new Lavabit.
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by simplehuman on Saturday January 21, 2017 @12:14AM (#13448945)
Moxie is not impressed with anything other than signal
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by pvg on Saturday January 21, 2017 @01:45AM (#13449181)
He lists two projects unrelated to Signal in the article. There is no mention of Signal.
[dead]
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by nommm-nommm on Saturday January 21, 2017 @03:42PM (#13452024)
Yeah but the GP was saying that Ladar Levison must have made a trustworthy system because he's Ladar Levison. However, I was pointing out that there was serious issues with the trustworthiness of the original lavabit.
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by pvg on Friday January 20, 2017 @11:23PM (#13448773)
Snowden is not a security expert nor a cryptographer. He used Cryptocat and Lavabit, for instance - he was (like most people) unable to independently assess the quality of their security guarantees and believed their claims.
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by nyolfen on Saturday January 21, 2017 @02:11AM (#13449225)
he has said that he used pgp in his emails with poitras and greenwald because he knew from personal experience that, properly implemented, nsa was unable to decrypt messages protected with it
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by pvg on Saturday January 21, 2017 @02:15AM (#13449233)
Are you saying he didn't use Lavabit and Cryptocat?
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by ycmbntrthrwaway on Saturday January 21, 2017 @08:53AM (#13450028)
He used PGP over Lavabit. So even though Lavabit was compromised, content of his emails is secure.
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by geofft on Friday January 20, 2017 @10:38PM (#13448609)
He didn't go to the mat for his users. He built a service that he knew was vulnerable to standard legal process (or if he didn't, he was amazingly incompetent) but sold it as if it were safe from the government, duping even Edward Snowden. The government, naturally, engaged in standard legal process, and found that he possessed a key that would give the government access to everything they needed, and that he was capable of turning it over. So he was ordered to turn it over, which should have surprised no one.

He did surrender the key, although by printing out the key in 4-point font (unclear if he was buying time, or just thought contempt charges sounded fun). After the government pressed him harder, he shut down the service days later. He didn't disclose that he had surrendered the key; the public found out when the court documents, including the key itself, were unsealed.

If something can't be done securely, don't tell your users that it can be done securely. If you know you can't win, there's honor in refusing to lose without a fight. But there's no honor in first promising people that you'll win, and there's quite a bit of dishonor in asking people to pay you to win.

Lavabit v1 should never have been built. Many people were technically qualified to build something like it it (it's email, which constrains the design significantly), had the resources, and chose not to. The fact that Levison built it, and that he hasn't apologized for building it, demonstrates that he's untrustworthy. This is not to say that he's a bad person; everyone makes mistakes, and I wouldn't trust myself to build a secure email service singlehandedly, because I know what mistakes I've made and what sort of personality flaws I have. It's just a statement that the required level of trust is extremely high, and Levison hasn't demonstrated it.

Lavabit v2's "Trustful" mode has all of the same flaws as Lavabit v1. He writes about his "free and open source server" and asks how you feel about "trusting our servers," when that was never the problem. If you can magically make sure that the government doesn't have access to your system, a standard unencrypted email server will do just fine. If you can't, they'll issue the exact same legal order to Lavabit v2 that they did to v1, and it'll be just as effective.

Re:Lavabit Reloaded by msh on Saturday January 21, 2017 @09:20AM (#13450111)
Phil Zimmermann

He went to prison over pgp.

But then the mail service he was involved in (silent circle mail) shut down at the same time as lavabit.

Re:Lavabit Reloaded by bb611 on Saturday January 21, 2017 @09:45AM (#13450204)
He never spent time in prison, but he was investigated intensely by the US gov't.
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by msh on Saturday January 21, 2017 @01:01PM (#13451207)
You seem to be correct. He never went to prison for pgp.

But apparently he thought up pgp while in prison for nuclear protests.

Re:Lavabit Reloaded by MaymayMaster on Friday January 20, 2017 @05:35PM (#13447524)
Vincent Canfield
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by psybin on Friday January 20, 2017 @06:05PM (#13447698)
The owner of Cock Mail / cock.li is at least completely realistic with what can be expected from an email provider. Goofy domain names aside, being completely frank about privacy and security realities is what you want.
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by SSLy on Friday January 20, 2017 @06:34PM (#13447824)
sadly he seems MIA.
Re:Lavabit Reloaded by psybin on Saturday January 21, 2017 @02:21AM (#13449248)
He has a phone number, go call him.