Hillbilly Elegy https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/11/books/review-in-hillbilly...
My version: Republican party platform does not believe in the "veil of ignorance" at all whatsoever. They support neo-feudalism and aristocracy. Equality is fake, people are in fact different, those differences should be rewarded and punished in a free market, it is considered unfair to force equality to be true. Even equality under the law is negotiable, where those who can afford better lawyers get better justice.
Democrats are tone deaf, and suck at marketing their own policy successes. They'd rather convince people to vote for them on the basis of a smug liberalism which says if only people had the facts they'd vote Democrat. Ergo if you vote Republican you're either stupid or evil. This is not a winning strategy, obviously.
that is a feature of democracy not unique to America
I recall seeing a snippet of the Prime Minister of the UK being asked about a mail box on some particular street corner in London, in an open forum. He knew exactly what was being discussed. Smaller countries have their politicians more tangibly connected to people, as opposed to local representatives being seated thousands of miles away as is the case in the US.
People also forget that the US is set up kind of more like the EU, rather than most other countries. It's a federation of independent states, with deference of law to those states, except for those powers specifically granted to the federal government (at least on paper). This is a yet another abstraction level layered on top of politics that many people in other countries don't conceive.
So propaganda easily overwhelms people's natural gleaning of what's going on.
To quote you: If you are not noticing that, that's probably a bad sign (for what? Can you explain that?)
From cursory observation of various political engagements around the world, it's all very similarly tribalistic - whether it be over the top rhetoric that appeal to emotion - or in some cases violent. Heck look at the rise of the far right support in various EU states. Politics is very often personal, so people will take it personally.
The only real difference is America takes up all the media oxygen given it's position in the world stage.
The fact of the matter is that there are many democracies in the world where the level of discourse is much more advanced. There are many reasons for this, but the primary factor seems to be that the average level of education in those countries tends to be higher.
Serious question, not trolling: why does wealth disparity matter?
Let's say you start the year barely having enough to eat and are living in a cardboard box and you end the year with plenty of food and a small house, why would it matter if your neighbor gets to eat steak once a week and has a slightly nicer house? Surely the absolute fact that your are better off than you were previously is more important than the relative distribution of goods?
A quick way to reduce wealth disparity is to burn down every home that costs more than the median house price. That doesn't mean it's a good idea.
So why is relative wealth more important than absolute wealth again?
Most poor people I know wouldn't consider themselves lazy, so that one is out. With some serious social engineering and propaganda you may be able to convince the poor that they are inherently inferior, but the trend in most of the world seems to be against this sticking. So in most cases wealth disparity means that the poor people feel like they are getting screwed, i.e. they feel entitled to a better life, and they feel that their institutions have failed them.
Look at any country with a high Gini Coefficient and you can see what this leads to. The rich end up corralled into compounds surrounded by razor wire and electric fences, kidnapping runs rampant, political corruption is the rule. With no reason to believe that the government is working for the underclass, you can't really expect the underclass to abide by the government's laws.
If you want to optimize for "someone can own everything" then wealth disparity is not and will never be bad.
If you want to optimize for a wide host of other things, such as the health of the people in a society, crime rates in a society, class mobility or personal freedom, or other stuff, then you're already motivated to keep wealth disparity in check, because enough of it negatively affects all the rest.
There are some good thoughts here: https://www.quora.com/Is-wealth-inequality-bad
But really, a google search for "why is wealth inequality bad" will give you a lot of stuff.
Please, if you're genuinely curious, read some of that and decide what you think society should be optimized for.
It's about having a fair and free society. Would you rather have a gourmet dinner every night in prison, or a PB&J in a free and egalitarian community?
Isn't health insurance a wealth disparity issue?
That's not the biggest threat, any more than Diarrhea is a bigger threat than other health issues, despite Diarrhea killing more people: https://www.cdc.gov/healthywater/global/diarrhea-burden.html
By that I mean the two - wealth disparity and Diarrhea - are outcomes, not causes. Diarrhea is the outcome of poor infrastructure (food and water) and poverty that lead to weaker, susceptible immune systems.
Wealth disparity is the outcome of a bunch of things, like automation, a better ability to detect good workers, a greater desire to be rewarded for good work (if two people provide X and 10X performance and are rewarded as such... disparity), the DECREASE in wealth distribution globally (China is richer than in 1980, as is all of Asia), that geographically set people have global wealth, e.g. Gates, Zuckerberg, Page, Brin et al are top not of the US, but a world economy, whereas many people still earn a percentage of local money (trades people, waitresses etc) and probably many more elements I don't know about.
The problem is we live locally, so the disparity looks worse, even as globally it is coming down.
That is why there is more LOCAL choice than ever - in say beers - as we get imports, but LESS global variety, as we all get the best X of something, rather than having a vast array of isolated areas with their own unique elements. It is why Sydney, Australia is home to some of the best Thai food in the world, and the UK home to some of the best Indian.
> we should be relentless about leading our politicians back to the topic of wealth disparity
But towards what policy? Basic Income? Higher taxes? Less automation? Open borders? What is the policy prescription for this issue?
Economic rent I can see being concern, especially when regulatory capture is involved, but there are many reasons for increasing wealth disparity that are completely fair.
Many of those being rewarded with wealth have built and led companies that have improved productivity and allowed many of those on the other side of the wealth divide to do more with less. Is it not fair to compensate them accordingly for the ways they have improved general welfare?
Our system not only greatly rewards/punishes circumstance of birth, it further rewards those who leverage their luck to secure more even advantage, while the unlucky are forced to compete with each other in a race to the bottom for the scraps.
1. Wealth disparity is an issue -- this needs to be justified beyond an appeal to fairness. Why is this an issue at all? Is the real issue the decline of the middle class? Is that necessarily connected to increasing wealth in the upper class?
2. The election of Donald Trump is a 'lose-lose' scenario. How? What, specifically, about his proposed policies has a demonstrably negative impact on the quality of life for American citizens and the United States' geopolitical influence?
There's more to a president than their proposed policies. Trump's bigoted rhetoric is already having a demonstrably negative impact on the quality of life for many minorities in the USA (and he's not even in office yet)
2. Oh man, where to even begin?
a. Repeal of ACA is the most obvious one. According to the recently released report from the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office[1], 18 million Americans will lose their health insurance in the first year when ACA is repealed. Over ten years, this number will increase to 32 million. In other words, by 2026, one in ten Americans will be without health insurance.
b. Trump wants to strip FCC of consumer protection laws[2]. It's pretty obvious why this will be horrendous for the average American.
c. He proposed pulling out of NATO. This one should also be pretty obvious: NATO is the major force that is keeping Russia in check. Without America there would be a NATO, and without NATO, Russian geopolitical influence would expand massively, reducing America's influence as a result.
d. His cabinet picks are a major disaster. Department of Labor headed by a guy who has fought against labor protection laws all his life. Department of Education headed by a woman who wants to abolish it. Department of Energy headed by a guy who has a degree in animal science. Department of Housing and Urban development headed by a guy whose only "qualification" for the job is having grown up in a poor neighborhood. Environmental Protection Agency headed by a guy who is a close ally of the fossil fuel industry. It gets worse and worse.
[1]https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/powerpost/wp/2017/01/17/...
[2]http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/01/trump-team-report...
Often I'm told "I know about issue x, but I can't do anything". To which I reply "well, yes you can. First dump your TV. Use the spare time to read books and choose a hobby than make you gather with others. Start trying to spend your money like every note is a voting buletin. Then get involved in any social/political activity at your local level".
Of course this has no impact. Most people do want TV. They want drama. They don't want to spend time and energy learning, thinking or taking responsibilities of their life.
If you let a cookie jar open in your garden and ants come to eat it, it's not the ants fault. ants are just ants. They see sugar, they try to get it. It's sucks, but you are the giant and they are the ants. You are responsible to understand the situation and make proper choices.
If you're serious about wanting change, you should appeal to the values of the capitalists. Don't complain about inequality, complain about inefficiency. A capitalist economy is supposedly (and probably) more efficient than a command economy, because a centralized bureaucracy is worse at allocating resources than a decentralized market. The central tenet of the free market is that decentralization is more efficient.
So what happens when a capitalist accrues more wealth, as is natural for some to do with luck or skill? Eventually, the most skilled or most lucky have most of the wealth. Wealth forms a log-normal or power-law distribution. It's natural and nothing to whine about. Unfortunately, this is an unstable system. As the wealth distribution becomes ever more long-tailed, what once was a free market becomes more and more like a centralized bureaucracy with a handfull of capitalists allocating resources instead of a handfull of bureaucrats.
Redistributing wealth, fairness aside, is simply the most efficient way to keep the market growing. It closes the loop of decentralization. Think of a Bayesian Meta-Bandit, a Bayesian Bandit [1] that selects a Bandit according to the probability that Bandit is best. No matter the history we've observed, the probability of our best Bandit in fact being best never reaches 100% and we always choose the lesser (according to our observations) with some non-zero probability. In the same way, the best societal strategy is to redistribute according to the probability that our best allocators (our wealthiest capitalists) might make a mistake or get unlucky.
Too much redistribution and we lose efficiency, because we're not giving the bulk of our resources to our best allocators. Too little redistribution and we lose efficiency, because our observed-best might either (1) just have gotten lucky in the past and aren't actually better or (2) might get unlucky in the future and we need a hedge against random failure.
Aaaanyway. Anyone who argues against redistribution needs to do some thinking about why capitalism works.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boston_Tea_Party#Resisting_the...
"Colonial merchants, some of them smugglers, played a significant role in the protests. Because the Tea Act made legally imported tea cheaper, it threatened to put smugglers of Dutch tea out of business."
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multi-armed_bandit#Probability...
A Bayesian Bandit chooses actions according to the Bayesian probability that the action is best.
if recent political movements (tea party, the 99%) and national elections have taught us anything, it's that this is increasingly on the minds of americans (and seemingly others, but i won't speak for them), yet politicians seem to want to talk about anything but that, lest they lose the financial backing of the economic elite.
at its core, this is about fairness, which is one of those fundamental psychological forces we can't and shouldn't ignore. game theory studies show time and again that we are willing to play into lose-lose situations if it means maintaining a semblance of fairness among participants. the trump election seems to be an example of that. the arab spring uprisings seem to be larger, more international examples.
we should be relentless about leading our politicians back to the topic of wealth disparity every single time they try to distract us with something else (particularly terrorism, which has killed far fewer people in the last 15 years than a single year of car accidents has, yet we have sacrificed so much monetarily and psychologically trying to battle that phantom).