News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX Data Shows Loss in 2015, Heavy Expectations for Na... by jusq1 on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @07:02AM (#13416764)
Most of the payments are made upfront and for milestones hit. As in a lot of it is paid up. The only reason that works is having the govt as a customer.

The Russians can any day drop their margins and put SpaceX out of business. They have the tech and the track record that SpaceX will take another decade or two to match.

SpaceX is being propped up cause NASA, Boeing, Lockheed et al have become such dinosaurs that they can't do anything by themselves.

Re:SpaceX Data Shows Loss in 2015, Heavy Expectations for Na... by neekburm on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:31AM (#13417314)
>The Russians can any day drop their margins and put SpaceX out of business.

This is an argument I haven't heard before. Any sources I can read up on to learn more?

Re:SpaceX Data Shows Loss in 2015, Heavy Expectations for Na... by noir_lord on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @09:06AM (#13417579)
I'm not sure it's true, I would also like to see the sources.

As for the 'tech', yes the Russians have a long and pretty good history with rocketry but SpaceX has technological edges as well.

Re:SpaceX Data Shows Loss in 2015, Heavy Expectations for Na... by avmich on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @01:00AM (#13424396)
There are at least two arguments in favor of ability to keep Russian launches cheap(er).

First if mentioned in John Clark's "Ignition!", where he says that the Russian approach to bigger payload isn't the technology, but just the size of the rocket - with same low-tech as something smaller. So, in other words, technological edges aren't always translating into lower costs in this industry.

Second is Russian's technological edges with kerosene liquid fuel engines. Technologies are well-optimized, including costs, and are the primary used ones for Russian space program. Not solid rockets, not hydrogen - and comparatively little hydrazin-based rockets, at least by the number of launches.

Re:SpaceX Data Shows Loss in 2015, Heavy Expectations for Na... by bonzini on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @02:51PM (#13429685)
As an aside, solid rockets is perhaps the part that disappointed me most about "Ignition!". I guess it shows its age. Do you know of any reading about their development? Couldn't find much on Wikipedia...
Re:SpaceX Data Shows Loss in 2015, Heavy Expectations for Na... by noir_lord on Thursday January 19, 2017 @07:37AM (#13435255)
Those are interesting arguments but there isn't any evidence.
Re:SpaceX Data Shows Loss in 2015, Heavy Expectations for Na... by avmich on Friday January 20, 2017 @12:21AM (#13441875)
Where is the evidence that SpaceX rockets are cheapest? Just because SpaceX says so?
Re:SpaceX Data Shows Loss in 2015, Heavy Expectations for Na... by avmich on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @12:55AM (#13424363)
Rocket launches aren't exactly over the counter commodity with stable prices.

Having said that, here - http://novosti-kosmonavtiki.ru/forum/forum13/topic2156/?PAGE... - is a table maintained by Russian space forum participant(s). You can dig for more original sources from there.

Re:SpaceX Data Shows Loss in 2015, Heavy Expectations for Na... by PerfectDlite on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @11:44AM (#13427727)
You're using a forum posts as a credible source? Really?
Re:SpaceX Data Shows Loss in 2015, Heavy Expectations for Na... by avmich on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @09:41PM (#13432512)
Well, this is the best public Russian space forum. Won't get any better in Russian, with all Russian sources.

So - yes, I agree that the information sources are limited. But at least you can try to trace the original sources from posts there.

On the original question, I haven't seen a comparison of actual SpaceX launch prices with actual launch prices used by other launch providers, specifically Russian ones. With Russians it could be useful to check both "commercial" and "federal" launch prices, as the first are driven by market, while second are more driven by actual costs.

Can SpaceX prices be compared to Russian ones?

Re:SpaceX Data Shows Loss in 2015, Heavy Expectations for Na... by PerfectDlite on Friday January 20, 2017 @10:23AM (#13444404)
> both "commercial" and "federal" launch prices, as the first are driven by market, while second are more driven by actual costs.

I.e. "federal" prices are likely subsidized. What's the point using them?

Re:SpaceX Data Shows Loss in 2015, Heavy Expectations for Na... by nickik on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @10:36AM (#13418350)
The Russians can absolutely not just drop the margins and put SpaceX out of bushiness. Of course if the Russian state would fully fund everything and over free space access, so could the US. Neither of them will, neither can practically, politically do it. Its a pretty absurd claim, that I have heard nobody make except you.

SpaceX is not being propped up, the get contract because they beat everybody else on price.

Re:SpaceX Data Shows Loss in 2015, Heavy Expectations for Na... by avmich on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @12:52AM (#13424351)
> Its a pretty absurd claim, that I have heard nobody make except you.

Nevertheless it's a widely circulated claim in certain groups.

The idea that "SpaceX beats everybody on price" unfortunately got little actual checks. Of course there is the claim, and some support for that, like rocket structure, engines - but not the actual comparisons. SpaceX does wonderful advancements - but just how wonderful and how do they compare with existing offerings on the whole range of parameters, including price, is rarely compared to what SpaceX actually proclaims.

Don't overestimate the cost of older technologies.