News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by bkraz on Monday January 16, 2017 @08:10PM (#13414438)
It fits a pattern. I was a hardware engineer at Valve during the early VR days, working mostly on Lighthouse and the internal dev headset. There were a few employees who insisted that the Valve VR group give away both hardware and software to Oculus with the hope that they would work together with Valve on VR. The tech was literally given away -- no contract, no license. After the facebook acquisition, these folks presumably received large financial incentives to join facebook, which they did. It was the most questionable thing I've seen in my whole career, and was partially caused by Valve's flat management structure and general lack of oversight. I left shortly after.
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by maxander on Monday January 16, 2017 @10:06PM (#13414887)
So people at Valve gave away tech, and then got hired by other companies to work on that tech, presumably for stacks of money? Leaving others who happened to be working on less lucrative subjects their a prestigious but lower-paid positions with little hope of meaningful advancement?

Huh. Valve is just like academia.

Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by modeless on Monday January 16, 2017 @10:55PM (#13415097)
... except Valve ultimately came out with the better product and is selling twice as many (according to Tim Sweeney). Plus, the VR market is not zero sum right now. The extra investment and attention that Oculus has brought to the industry has almost certainly resulted in Vive selling more units, not fewer. And Steam is winning over Oculus Home, too. The people advocating technology sharing were right, in my view.
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by maxander on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @12:12PM (#13419168)
It's definitely the right thing for the VR market, and probably for people in general, but it doesn't help those working for Valve in other areas when Valve's VR tech goes to making other companies rich rather than raising their own salary.
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by headshock1111 on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @07:40AM (#13416948)
>the VR market is not zero sum right now.

this is only true if anyone who buys either a Vive or a Rift has sufficient funds to afford getting both

Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by benjaminjackman on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:41AM (#13417382)
I think not zero sum in the sense that currently a good battle between two rivals could stir up more attention for both VR companies and lead to increased sales for either than they would have if they weren't competing.

People don't have to buy both they just have to be more likely to buy either due to the presence of competition.

Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by rogeressig on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @10:54AM (#13418520)
oculus home vs VR sales on Steam. My guess it's oculus home by a huge margin because GearVR.
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by AlphaSite on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @08:49AM (#13426251)
None of the games which work for the gearvr are really useable nor worthwhile on the rift.
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by blazespin on Monday January 16, 2017 @08:38PM (#13414524)
You left because Valve made a good faith gamble in hopes of accelerating the development of VR with no guarantee of return?

Was Valve not growing fast enough for you?

That being said, yes, I agree that FB has been a tad arrogant with oculus. And, if you look at sales, karma is catching up to them.

Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by bkraz on Monday January 16, 2017 @09:44PM (#13414800)
Overall, I think Valve is a good place to work, and I learned a lot from all of the incredibly smart people there. The main reason that I left was the difficulty in merging hardware development with the company's exceptionally successful business model. The hardware team was pressured to give away lots of IP that could have been licensed, with the explanation that hardware is just so worthless anyway compared to online software sales, there was no other choice. It's possible that this was a good faith gamble, however it still doesn't preclude the use of business contracts that would have protected our investment. It also isn't so great for morale to hear everyday that your years of work are going to be given away to another company, and then watch that company get acquired for $2B. This is especially the case since many employees strongly voiced concerns about just such a scenario.

Growth at Valve is a little funny. It's like an oil-rich nation. Gaining more citizens is not really desirable since the wealth will just get spread more thinly, and there is no way that new employees will be able to make more money than Steam already does with a very limited number of employees. I know the company is trying new things, and making honest investments in new areas, but it's hard to shake the bottom line.

Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by shostack on Monday January 16, 2017 @10:11PM (#13414907)
Personally I think there is a ton of growth potential for Steam that has yet to be realized. I wonder if the revenue is making Valve soft since it tends to hide many problems that scrappier companies are forced to confront and solve or perish.
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by shostack on Monday January 16, 2017 @10:12PM (#13414914)
Personally I think there is a ton of growth potential for Steam that has yet to be realized.

I wonder if all the revenue is making Valve soft since it tends to hide many problems that scrappier companies are forced to confront and solve or perish.

Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by dleslie on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @12:26AM (#13415388)
Sounds like Valve lacks direction.
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by devwastaken on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @01:41AM (#13415621)
If you look at how Amazon has been buying up Twitch.tv, Curse, and now are experimenting with having a Twitch game downloader, you see how far behind Steam is with the times.

Valve makes ridiculous amounts of money, has no board, Gabe Newell can do whatever he wants with the company. I think he's really taken a retired seat. Steam's social platform is lacking, the technology behind it all is old (Just look a the steam API), and they aren't investing into anything. Even customer support is majorly lacking. The second Amazon starts selling games, its game over. They can advertise their client and services through twitch, and connect games and players back to twitch and the Curse client. Thats the triangle of doom to competitors, where you control the product, the platform and the community. They have it all in the bag, and it was so blindingly obvious.

Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by drzaiusapelord on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @10:11AM (#13418141)
>Even customer support is majorly lacking.

I have probably refunded 10 games in the past year or so for various reasons. I've gotten sales and deals unimaginable before the days of steam. I can't imagine any other company letting me get away with such things. Arguably, we have the EU to thank for that, but Valve has zero obligation to allow this policy for US customers like me, but did so anyway.

> I think he's really taken a retired seat.

From my reading of recent VR history, he's fairly hands on with it. I did read an interview where he claims he purposely puts himself in the backseat because he didn't want to become "King of Valve" where his personal taste and ideas trump everyone else's. He something of the anti-Jobs.

>Valve makes ridiculous amounts of money, has no board, Gabe Newell can do whatever he wants with the company.

Privately held companies have different pros and cons than publicly held ones. I can't imagine Valve being a better company as a public entity. Think of all the investor-minded decisions (must hit certain milestones, projections, etc) that have doomed gaming companies in the past. Valve is largely immune to that, but as you say, comes with the price of being fairly slow moving compared to their peers.

Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by Vraxx on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:56AM (#13417488)
I really dislike Curse for gaming, the UI is the most unintuitive thing I've used in ages, showing me the same information on 5 different looking screens, but not having a single screen that shows me a list of all of my friends. I don't use any of their addons as well because I don't want to bundle myself into a glorified chat app that can't even handle that correctly. I've had to restart not only curse, but my entire machine multiple times in order to get it to register a microphone switch or a switch in playback devices.

I agree with your main point of steam's slow movement, but the other thing is that steam is a very large incumbent with pretty high switching costs. I don't see them going away because a different platform offers twitch integration, because I can already stream twitch with my steam library that has hundreds of games in it. And if twitch limited that somehow, I think the pull of the user's library would overpower the pull of one individual streaming platform. It costs a lot more to switch the library after all.

Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by funkyy on Monday January 16, 2017 @08:39PM (#13414528)
Sounds like he left because of flat management and lack of oversight.
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by blazespin on Monday January 16, 2017 @08:41PM (#13414531)
Valve has always had flat management. Why'd he join in the first place?

Valve is a great game company. They've done great, hugely important things. Their work on Vive has been extremely innovative and it seems to be paying off in terms of sales versus Oculus.

Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by funkyy on Monday January 16, 2017 @08:50PM (#13414563)
You need to ask him for that. But about flat management - I heard many people saying flat management system have turned Valve to the highschool-style community with "Cool Kids" running things and some people being pushed into the "corner". I have read stories where people comment on how a lot of things are immature in the company. Sorry, I am busy coding now so cannot send citations your way, but they are not hard to find with Google.
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by bkraz on Monday January 16, 2017 @09:59PM (#13414858)
I joined Valve because "flat management" sounds a lot better than it actually is. I don't think Valve's implementation is especially bad -- I would never join another company that has "flat management".
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by jayjay71 on Monday January 16, 2017 @10:51PM (#13415083)
Is there a reason you didn't want to join Oculus and continue working on the same (or similar) technology with your colleagues?
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by bkraz on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @12:24AM (#13415381)
The work on VR at Valve was the most stressful point of my career, and I wanted a change (ie not to work on VR anymore). When I left, it was unclear if Valve was going to ditch the whole VR thing. They probably would have done so if HTC hadn't gotten a demo of our amazing tech. My new job at Verily (Google Life Sciences) offered better pay, lower stress, and far more job satisfaction, so it ended up being a good move.
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by drzaiusapelord on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @10:12AM (#13418152)
Care to talk about the pros and cons of flat management structures from your perspective?
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by bkraz on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @11:46PM (#13424041)
The biggest problem with flat management is that it isn't really flat. It only means that there is no formal organizational structure. Think of it like the Wild West: It's flat in the sense that you can get away with any behavior if you have enough influence or force. Those who are powerful end up ruling everyone else, making the system anything but flat. I'm not at all convinced this is better than a structured system that tries to ensure fairness (even if flawed). A lot of folks at Valve had very bad experiences with unfit managers (mostly at Microsoft), and I can understand why they developed a system to avoid the nastiness they experienced in the past. It sometimes works well: The unstructured teams appear to be very effective at product maintenance. The products that are already successful and have an established fan base do well with a small group of folks with an informal leader, who doesn't have to make difficult decisions to keep the fan base happy. For new products, there are lots of difficult decisions that affect the future of employees and customers, and it doesn't appear possible for a group to make these decisions together. I spent many, many hours in meetings discussing the same issues repeatedly because there was no leader to make a final decision and allow everyone to get back to work. Instead we just debated without end, causing everyone to become unfocused and demoralized. It's analysis paralysis in the worst way I've ever seen. I now understand why many social groups from primitive tribes to 1st-world nations have leaders and chiefs. It's fine to vote them out when necessary, but having visionary leadership is really critical to development and I don't see how this can be distributed among a group unless each person shares exactly the same vision, which I suppose is possible, but unlikely.

I think the best solution is to build structures that greatly reward effective management. Having a good manager is a tremendous benefit to both the company and the manager's reports. Of course, this is easier said than done, but the return on investment spent in this area is really quite high.

Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by sloppycee on Thursday January 19, 2017 @02:57AM (#13433959)
Reading PeopleWare was a revelation for me, in that cliques and politics are inevitable (it's human nature). It's a company's responsibility to put processes & structures in place to create a _better_ workplace by removing artificial leadership and cliques (in-groups).

The idea of a 'flat' organization is laudable, but in practice it is usually a massive failure.

Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by Hydraulix989 on Monday January 16, 2017 @09:27PM (#13414722)
I don't know, I would have also personally felt pretty unhappy if I was one of the Xerox PARC researchers whose hard work was essentially given away for free to Steve Jobs.
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by tinus_hn on Monday January 16, 2017 @09:40PM (#13414780)
Yeah, better not have it be used by anyone!
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by Hydraulix989 on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @12:50AM (#13415471)
Let me know all of your great ideas that you haven't gotten around to following through with yet.
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by twblalock on Monday January 16, 2017 @09:31PM (#13414737)
Xerox did not give its technology away for free. Xerox got a lot of pre-IPO Apple stock options in exchange.
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by Hydraulix989 on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @12:51AM (#13415475)
Imagine the upside of actually being Apple though. It really felt like a missed opportunity to everyone there, gauging from employees' actual testimonies.
Re:Oculus accused of destroying evidence, Zuckerberg to test... by DEADBEEF on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @05:40PM (#13431082)
If push came to shove, would you be willing to go on the stand and testify as much if compelled to?