Re:Certified Malice
by GrinningFool on Monday January 16, 2017 @10:18PM
(#13414945)
We don't - but most of the rest of the browsing public doesn't know the difference.
That's why it's up to the browser to distinguish them.
Re:Certified Malice
by GrinningFool on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @05:16PM
(#13421967)
The problem with that is that they haven't significantly done so yet - and people are well-trained to look for the green padlock to ensure the site is secure without much consideraton beyond that point.
So while I see your point, that's another transition that will take years to drill into public awareness - even if the browsers could agree on a meaningful and consistent representation, which seems like its own challenge
Safari has. There's no green on the address bar for a DV cert, just a little grey padlock. But with an EV cert you get the green text and the legal name (in addition to the domain). So that makes it easy - if there's green, you can trust it to tell you the legal entity that you're talking to.
So, in effect, CAs issuing DV certs for websites, including phishing sites, is a feature, not a bug. If users are misinterpreting what a DV certificate means and doesn't mean, then it is up to browsers to make clear the difference between DV, OV, and EV.
A Domain-Validation certificate is just that. We shouldn't expect it to act like OV or EV.