Still, more than 100 million people die every year from diseases. Even with the best available health care, few live beyond 90. So the very best outcome imaginable has not been achieved.
The risk with the current FDA is that by minimizing the risk of being harmed by new drugs, we've locked in the current life expectancy of ~75.
This is just false. The life expectancy has been rising through modern history, except a stagnation in 1993 and one this year. You can't point to 1 data point in 50+ years and say we're locked in. Look at the record with the FDA (data from world Bank)
https://www.google.com/search?q=us+life+expectancy
Granted UK and Japan are doing better. They also have healthier lifestyles in general and strong regulatory agencies.
What if, on the other hand, we have achieved the very best outcome that is safely attainable? We certainly don't want the needle of achievement to start moving downward.
Anyone, and I don't care how distinguished they are, who talks about drug approval policy without examining cases like thalidomide or DES is a liar. There is no way anyone with the legal/economic insight to have a rational conversation on alternative regulatory structures is not aware of those cases.
Promoted as a wonder drug for morning sickness, there were 10 thousand children born with birth deformities worldwide.
https://web.archive.org/web/20090512235601/http://www.fda.go...
Perhaps memories of this are shorter in the US precisely because the FDA got this right and there are fewer visible daily reminders why we need drug regulation.