[1]http://fortune.com/2016/11/21/vancouver-vacant-property-tax-...
I also have huge issues with the government deciding what you can do with your property after you've bought and paid for it. If they can change the terms of your contract, worth 6 and 7 figures, that not only erodes faith in the real estate market but it effectively means you never own it in the first place (inb4 the tax-protester argument of "you never owned it anyway because tax". yes I know that).
All this happens when you go to fill out your taxes and declare your properties and primary residence. I don't want to tell people they can't do it, but they ought to pay the price for disallowing others to enjoy our most beautiful locations.
Renting out to people during the 6 months of the year is already an incentive, you get a check each month. You might also get to talk to a few people, learn a few things and make some new friends. Not sure if there is renter insurance, but that might be nice in case you get a tenant that damages the place. A service like that might give property owners some peace of mind.
I also want to discourage anyone else from doing more landlording, and a tax break for you and others like you would work against that.
I've rented the same flat myself for ten years and barring any huge changes, it's in my financial interests to do so forever, rather than buy a house. That should be the common state, but it's more expensive in many places at the moment to rent than to buy. Which suggests, to my mind, that something should push that balance back the other way.
I just think it shouldn't be very profitable. There are some things a well run state or region can be very good at (and in a number of places around the world, is very good at); maintaining a rental housing stock or other such housing programme is one of them.
People have made your argument but with short-selling in the stock market: "short selling should be banned, there shouldn't be incentivized pessimism in the market", but those people overlook the fact that short-sellers are obligated to buy back, and they can create a bottom in the market when there otherwise wouldn't be one. (if XYZ corp just went up in flames, who the hell would want to buy them (thus allowing more people to unload their shares)? Why, short-sellers of course - because they have to )
so what do you suggest? make it illegal to not live in your house ? Have a city inspector drive by once a week and see if lights are on and cars are parked nearby ? Every homeowner has to show up every 90 days to get their property ownership license stamped ?
sure, having vacant houses is a waste of resources. but having wealthy people actually use their money - even in a wasteful manner - can be a good thing. more money moving through the economy is better than less money moving through the economy.