The point isn't preventing YOU, the consumer, from doing this.
The point is that most people as the supplier aren't doing Uber, AirBnB, etc because they like it. They're doing it because they don't have any other good alternatives.
Most of the people on the supply side of the serfdom economy are gaining very little benefit. This is a real problem.
Well, sure.
Why is it the fault of Uber/AirBnB/Seamless/TaskRabbit/DishDash/Handy/whatever that they don't have better alternatives?
And moreover, how exactly would these people's lives be better if they couldn't work for Uber etc.? Aren't they choosing to work for Uber etc. because it's better than the alternative (namely, not working for Uber etc.)?
There are lots of fucked up things about our economic policy. I won't give my top ten because HN is trying not to be a place for political debates, but I'm sure you can name a few off the top of your head. We just had a long discussion about the importance of the ACA on HN -- taking that away hits the poor the hardest. We can go on.
The governmental policies that perpetuate income inequality should be the target of your ire, not the fact that someone deigned to create yet another company that doesn't pay its employees "enough" money.
Edited for formatting.
The idea here is if technology was in fact improving the economy, society, or the world the individuals who are stuck working 2nd and 3rd jobs would have other options available, especially in light of how many jobs/career tracks/industries software has eaten in the last 20 years.
* poorly defined term in this context
How do you know this? The last five uber drivers I've had have been
- a bloke on the way home from the gym
- the owner of a small accountancy firm, also on the way home
- an IT student from China who talked about PHP with me
- a Korean migrant who really hated taxi companies and was saving up for a house
- a CFO for a smallish company who was driving people around because he had to pick up his wife from the airport in a few hours
They all seemed pretty okay with uber. Only one, the student, was driving as a primary source of income, and he was doing about 20 hours a week and making more than he would in any other job.
2. Wide array of feel-good details to check lots of boxes
3. Completely anecdotal and therefore unverifiable
4. Facebook-level knowledge of people you likely spent 10 minutes with
5. Glowing review of Uber
Isn't Fear Uncertainty and Doubt great?
All Uber cares about is that he has a rating > 4.3 stars - ethnicity is irrelevant.
(This is also why the racist political party is trying to get Uber shut down.)
3. My experience has been that uber drivers in my city work part time for supplementary income. This is a verifiable assertion, but I don't have the means to carry out that verification. However, the assertion that I was responding to has no verification either. Plus, it probably varies from city to city and country to country
5. There are a lot of reasons why Uber is awful, from monopolistic bullying of governments, to not letting drivers set prices, to exposing drivers to market forces at an unprecedented level, but the drivers I've talked to have nearly all worked part time and seemed pretty happy to do so.
I'm not in sales, I don't work for Uber, and that's all I'll say about the personal stuff.
So champion proposals that would grow the economy, create more jobs, increase the median hourly wages, and/or improve the social safety net. I don't see how vilifying Uber or AirBNB is going to help accomplish any of the above.
P.S. There is no way for you as an individual to be a supplier on the Seamless, but that still hasn't spared them the author's wrath. I don't think the author really has a clear idea of what he's complaining about.
These companies are part of a greater force eroding the role and rights of labor. I think it's right to vilify the "sharing" company - especially with the type of "this is great for the world" propaganda that they spew out.
If we accept these conditions as the norm, they will only continue to slide. We have laws and regulations for a reason. Bypassing said laws with billions in 1%, connected money, should rightfully be called out. Conveniences for the noble class aside, this is just part of a larger scheme to transfer capital from the poor/middle class into the pockets of the existing wealthy. It's a bit tone-deaf of you not to see the other side of the picture. Next time you're in an Uber, talk to the driver. You'd be surprised how many are doing this full-time because they can't find employment elsewhere... and even more when you discover how many actually understand the underlying economics of their "side hustle" (aka side-scammed).
What conditions are you referring to? The ability to work when you want for as long as you want? The ability to take an otherwise idle asset like your car or your house and make extra money with it?
Anecdotally, I've taken dozens of Uber rides and never once heard the driver complain about Uber. I have, however, heard many drivers complain about proposed legislation that will harm Uber.
This isn't true for all sharing economy companies, but it's true for Uber.
They might not complain if all they think it'll do is ding their star rating, but many of them are very upset with Uber. Most of these folks feel trapped by what they perceive to be an abusive monopsony buyer of labor.
Seriously, we're sitting here on our pocket supercomputers [1] using wireless city-wide broadband to complain about how tech doesn't make anyone's lives better.
[1] Ownership of which largely transcends class, at least in the USA, which is amazingly wonderful and is a consequence of the capitalist system TFA's author seems to hate so much.
Isn't it a good thing that companies like Uber are creating jobs? Particularly for people who can't find employment elsewhere.
Are they, overall? Are they expanding the total amount of money paid out to workers in this industry? I'm not so sure that's the case.
Those who spend time consuming tripe like this or Silicon Valley, over some internet service, and then bitch about brogrammers are the problem. The efforts of greater people past are rotting under the asses of loud observers and you're no fucking Cesar Chavez.
Everyone wants to make it sound like these people had a gun to their had and the only option was to be a wage slave to the uber type oppressors, this is completely lacking in perspective to the vast expanse of inexpensive areas there are in which unskilled labor can live comfortably.
And Uber is a taxi that comes. You just have to have experienced SF -- admittedly run by idiots playing city, badly -- pre Uber to understand why people love it. I mean, it's fair to criticize how Uber treats drivers, and I try to have cash to tip, but it's not exactly like taxi drivers were being treated particularly well before Uber. And they treated their customers like absolute shit.
Whut? I'm not sure that has ever been effective at reversing course. Sometimes a society has changed course, but that's just because this message got lumped in with the have-nots, which is unrelated. This sentiment has never been satisfied, so I'll disagree that shutting up and moving on is a bad strategy. It's the ONLY strategy since it's tied to frontiersman thinking of having too much after enduring risk.
Most people have no choice on this. They have to work and it's just to subsist. Typical of hacker news that this would be the most up-voted comment.
Regarding tech, the main change tech has brought is to allow very accurate tracking of debt. Most debt is created through land. Surplus value goes to the landlords and banks.
Before this was not completely efficient, now banks can react to productivity changes much faster. Prices are set by the highest bidder. Tech has enabled "side jobs" which means they can outbid others for rent / mortgage (renting fiat money from a bank). Banks scale up fiat money creation in response. Other workers must respond and they too need a side job.
If we all worked 3 days a week it would be enough to pay the rent. If we all worked 7 days a week it would be enough to pay the rent.
But we cannot coordinate this as workers. Tech is working against workers. Economic rent extraction is now fully efficient.
This is wrong. The reason rent is going up is because there's more demand than supply. Reducing the amount of money everyone has by a constant factor (in this case 3/5) will not change the supply/demand imbalance, so it won't solve the problem. Put another way: the reason rent is so high is to prevent some people from being able to purchase the product. There's not enough of it to go around. You're basically blaming the best known system for allocating scarce goods for the fact that scarce goods exist.
If you look at countries that try to act on the above notion, you'll find that high prices are replaced with impossibly long lines. And shortages. This is because reducing the price will only increase the demand for that good.
A better world view would be: if the baby boomers hadn't all had kids at the same time, we wouldn't be experiencing housing shortages. This theory (though incomplete) at least puts demand increases front and center. You could also blame cities for not allowing/supporting the construction of new housing. That theory (though incomplete) at least puts the supply shortages front and center.
http://i.imgur.com/oWxV1po.jpg
People live in one home, whether we work 3 or 7 days. You are confusing cheaper products garnering more demand with a flat need. This is why we should tax land: the supply is constant.
Demand is up due to financialization of housing by the banks and greedy landlords are their foot soldiers.
Edit can submit no more due to the usual HN censorship so this last edit for the guy below:
You are just talking across me with no regard to my point at all. The graph is from the ft and the y axis is linear, it's from 2012 with no cutoff due to a change in trend.
I'm not saying don't compete, my earlier post stated that when we all work more or smarter in aggregate the banks take the gains and we all end up running to stand still. That was my point.
NO. Prices are set by supply and demand. No one is being forced to take out a loan, and if they could buy a given home with a lower loan, they would. Hence the loan is only enabling demand. You could say the same thing about employment, or inheritance, or tax breaks. The only reason prices change is because supply or demand changes.
You are basically saying that you'd like everyone to just accept their lot in life, and not compete with you for your current house. And in exchange you'll not compete with those in houses you'd prefer. And you're blaming the banks because they're helping those who don't agree that you deserve the hose more than they do.
When supply is scarce, prices go up. The value of the good does not go up. What is that extra price doing? That's you bribing the owner of the good to sell to you, and not to some other guy. You're paying to make the price so high that the next guy in line would rather live somewhere else, share a room, or go homeless.
> http://i.imgur.com/oWxV1po.jpg
The image, though interesting looking, is missing context. What units is the Y-axis in, and why does the X-axis only go to (what I assume is) 2012?
> People live in one home, whether we work 3 or 7 days.
People aren't born with homes. If you lost yours, someone would move in. Where do you think this other person is currently living? Why do you deserve your home more than they do? How should homes be allocated if not by whoever is willing and able to pay the most? Who will make new homes in this new system of yours? (an especially worrying problem since I think you suggested all the construction workers only need to work 3 days per week, and housing is already scarce)
> The only reason prices change is because supply or demand changes.
We are living in year 16 of the era of government pushing loan prices lower than the market would set them. 8th year since they've been pushing the loan pricing down VERY hard (ie. essentially to the zero bound, where you're only paying for the (also artificially lowered) risk of the banks, admin (ie. people employed to check payment and tax and ...) and a small profit margin for the banks).
While of course it is not really known how high the market would set loan prices, it seems the long term average is 4%. Since we've been below that for a while, let's call it 6%. Add the 3%-4% of risk, admin, tax and bank profit and mortgage rates should be somewhere between 8% and 10%, if you have really good credit.
What would house prices be with 9% interest rates instead of 3% ? That's quite normal a rate for mortgages, long term. My back of the envelope calculation says that they'd be, with the same monthly payment, a bit more than double what they should be, in market prices. Prices should be 60% less, or put it another way houses are 120% overvalued.
At a very optimistic 7% (the long term average), house prices would be about 45% less, or they're 75% overvalued.
(example calculation: with 3% mortgage payment, a 4000$ monthly payment will get you 1.12 million dollars, at 9% it will get you 0.52 million dollars, or a little less than half. At 7% it will get you 0.8 million dollars, or 45% less)
Hence I strongly disagree with your notion that house prices are determined by supply and demand. House princes are as high as the government can get them, and damn the consequences.
If the banks weren't giving the same risk adjusted rates to everyone, you can at least make the argument now that you've got two consumers (the bank is essentially donating money for the purchase to the buyer). But I don't see where that gets us here.
The cost of carry remains associated with wages just as rent does because we have to pay more, however as the cost of other items falls (due to efficiency / progress) the bankers hoover up the rest.
We work longer, we work harder, and the bankers kick back.
This is a separate point from real estate costs increasing historically -- that is caused by supply and demand. People are (as your graph nicely shows) choosing not to move as more people enter a given area, driving up the cost of real estate. This is to say that their demand is inelastic.
Unless you are suggesting banking as an industry is engaged in trust like behavior, they're not able to set the terms of rates in a way that will change their risk-free profit from a given individual at a given market price. If the price rises due to a supply and demand imbalance, they may be able to charge more to offset the increased risk of the purchase they are financing.
For example recently in the UK the govt said they would "help" buyers by contributing a certain % for buyers. Housing went up by that amount. Available credit sets prices.
This is a waste of my time, I'm out.
Banks can't magically choose to write loans at unprofitable terms. They also can't write loans at noncompetitive rates in any sort of realistic quantity. These two forces (fear of principal loss through nonpayment/default, and loss of customers due to competition) dictate bank rates.
> If banks start lending $1MM to employees on the basic wage that is how much basic housing costs.
No. It will only cost that much for people unwilling to move away from highly competitive markets where construction is barred. For those living in areas which can be developed, housing prices will also be dictated by the cost of construction, which is presumably less than $1MM. Buyers will be pocketing the difference between the available $1MM and the cost of construction. This is to say that banks do not dictate prices for housing, but rather are only (sometimes) enabling (fools?) to go higher in an auction.
If banks did set prices for housing, they would have to also be setting the price of, for example, construction. Which is not the case, as that is dictated by the supply and demand of labor and materials.
Put another way: I'm sure in wherever you are, not every housing option is the same price. Do you honestly believe that banks are somehow dictating those price differences? If not, what is that force, and does accounting for it also account for the effect of increased credit availability on house prices? (A: supply and demand, yes)
> recently in the UK the govt said they would "help" buyers by contributing a certain % for buyers. Housing went up by that amount.
Yes, just like if you give everyone a raise by x% you'll see housing jump by that amount. As I've said in this thread several times already. This jump does not, however, represent a change in real cost to consumers (a change in the what percentage of their labor is being spent on a given good). As I've also said in this thread several times already.
> This is a waste of my time, I'm out.
Cya.
> Banks scale up fiat money creation in response
The US money supply approximately doubles every 10 years, it's remarkably consistent modulo the occasional hiccup.
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2
You're right, that that the markets will reprice very quickly, and roughly speaking the more there is (stuff, workers, etc.) the lower the price will be. This would be much less of a problem if money was more evenly distributed, or if there was an efficient tax system in the US. Mostly the problem (if it can be described as singular one) in the US, and elsewhere, is the failure to tax the financial sector properly and redistribute that money back into the public infrastructure.
https://bankunderground.co.uk/2015/06/30/banks-are-not-inter...
I think it's not possible to stop land speculation so it should be taxed to pass the gains onto the people. As most money is issued against land let's have a land value tax.
Secondly let the state decide how much money can be created each year via an agreed growth target, set by...look away now if you are a neo-liberal zealot...the state. Thirdly use LVT to provide an efficient basic income and to do away with income tax. Why do we tax work? We tax carbon to stop people emitting carbon.
The current "system", if one can even confer such a name on such a dog's dinner, is insane.
Regarding US M2, do we really have step jumps in productivity? Is it not reasonable that we see this trend upwards in a smooth(-ish) fashion? If so then bank issuance tracks productivity gains, no?
#### EDIT #####
Will have to stop posting now as whenever I post about finance and question banks hacker news emits a fake "you are submitting too fast" message which I just got now replying to a different thread about zsh on a different page.
I also cannot edit my top level comment two above this.
What a great platform for debat HN has. Clearly they are confident in their model of lending and taking a cut and someone posting conflicting information that questions usury is no threat to them at all!
I imagine a system where all capital gains associated with land (not the structures on the land) outside of the real inflation rate were captured via capital gains tax.
Bring it on.
It seems that you view these services, which are luxuries, as options for the people that have to provide these services in order to survive in the modern American urban environment. They generally can't afford these luxuries. Nobodies blaming, or complaining about tech companies providing services. People are blaming tech companies and complaining about the effects of tech companies arbitraging value from economic systems that already existed, further increasing the concentration of wealth (which is ostensibly access to resources) among those who can already afford to invest in building the mechanisms to arbitrage said value. And, quite frankly, some of us are getting annoyed with people who defend companies that actually influence legislature on local and national levels to enable this arbitrage to the detriment of the citizenship of these regions, while shoving advertising, and news stories in our faces, labeling this arbitrage as the quintessential if not sole definition of human progress.
Also, this article was comedy, and hilarious.
It was written by a comedian, and therefore I read it as meaning to be provocative and not to be taken entirely at face-value (eg, the title of the article). Therefore, I think answering something intentionally provocative with another polemic (eg, "move to bumfuck nowhere" etc) only prevents you from engaging with the actual issues being raised in the original piece.
What I think the piece really is talking about is where things are headed on the cultural and socio-economic compass for the peons (sic), and how that's being framed through this clever, winking, yet ultimately Orwellian language of the culture that validates and encourages what are arguably destructive social forces: being "always on" and "shut-in"-style social isolation.
The problem is that many people are doing all of that and still hustling frantically just to afford meals to cook and a house to clean.
They more I look at your post, the more it seems like you're genuinely unaware that poor people exist.
Personally, that sounds like hell to me. I like traveling to other cities and staying in people's homes. I like taking an uber to get around sometimes. I like ordering food on seamless and hiring house cleaners on Handy, so I'll have more time to do the things I actually enjoy. And if you don't want to do any of the above, that's fine too. Just pretend all of the above companies don't exist and do what you want with your life, instead of complaining about tech companies and "brogrammers" providing services that cater to other people besides yourself.